Elijah had wiped the memories many years ago before a run in with his father. Several years later, he visited you...

"Can I help you?"

"Erm..."

"Are you okay?"

"Yeah... Sorry. I was just curious of which one of these drinks you'd like me to buy... [Y/N]."

"How do you know my name?"

"... Your badge..."

"Oh right. Sure."

"You're the best [Y/N]. You were the best..."

. . . .

[requested by
thesupernaturalTeen]