Please vote and comment

He looked down at Spencer who was kneeling on the floor.

"Spencer, honey what's the matter?" He said concerned "Toby why is she crying?"

"She's fine" Toby said "minor disagreement"

His dad looked at Spencer, and he did too, she was knelt down by the desk, her panties in her hand, only her bra and skirt on, right next to where he'd dropped his pants and boxers

"Holy hell this looks bad" he thought to himself.

His dad walked over to him and yanked him off the bed by his arm.

"What did you do to her?" He said through clenched teeth "Did you hurt her? Did you force her?"

"What?" Toby asked incredulously "I would never, she wanted it!" He yelled before realizing how it sounded.

"That sounds bad but it's the truth" he said near tears himself "Spencer, baby, please tell my loud, mean daddy that you wanted this"

Spencer continued to cry, she needed to say something, he hadn't forced her, she had wanted it, she had wrapped her legs around him, and had definitely experienced pleasure.

She needed to say something but couldn't find the words. His dad knelt down beside her.

" you can tell me honey, if he raped you, I'll call the cops myself I swear" he said his voice full of concern

Cops? "Please don't do that" Spencer bawled, "I want to go home, I just want to go home" as discreetly as possible she put her panties back on and picked up her sweater.

"Tell him you're fine Spencer, he's looking at me like I'm one of those guys in those lifetime movies" Toby said angrily

Spencer sniffled a little as she buttoned her sweater "I'm fine" and she walked out the door.

"Do you have anything to say for yourself?" His father said with his hands on his hips.

"No because you won't believe me anyway"

"Toby..." His father sighed

"Get out!" He yelled

"Tell me what happened, explain it to me, I'll believe you"

"We've been having sex, we were getting ready to do it this afternoon, we got into an argument when she took a phone call from one of her male friends, I told her I didn't care to end the fight but I guess I did care because I was rough with her, I thought she liked it but when it was over she started crying" Toby's eyes had watered a little and he thought his father believed him.

"What do I do?" Toby asked tearfully

"First, you hope she calls you, and if she calls you, you hope it isn't to dump you, and if she doesn't dump you, you swear to her that you will never EVER touch her that way again"

"And if she doesn't call me?" Toby asked

His dad half-heartedly smiled "she'll call" before walking out the room.

Spencer was walking home. Keep it together she told herself. You can not cry yet. You can cry once you get to the safety of your room.

"Spencer?" She heard someone call.

She turned towards the voice.

"Oh, hi, Mrs. Montgomery" she said attempting a smile. She was in front of the Montgomery house.

"Are you ok?" She asked sounding concerned.

"Yea, uh..." She hadn't come up with an excuse for why she was upset. She thought she had a few more blocks.

"Oh honey" she said knowingly. That was when she realized she miss-buttoned her sweater. "Come inside"

Ella brought her inside, Byron looked at her questioningly but with one look at Ella Byron knew not to say anything and left the room.

"Aria!" Ella called, after a minute she called again "Aria! It's important"

Aria came downstairs then she paused at the fourth step taking a look at Spencer. She took the last four, two at a time and pulled Spencer into a hug, Spencer fell to pieces then bawling her eyes out.

"Aria, why don't you take Spencer upstairs where you can have some privacy, I'll bring up some tea"

Aria pulled Spencer upstairs to her room. Spencer sat in the desk chair and Aria sat on the bed. They stared at each other. Her mom brought up tea. They stared at each other some more.

Finally Aria spoke "Spencer, I want to know what's going on, what happened?"

" I can't Aria, I just can't" she said. The tears had stopped momentarily. She happened to see Aria's phone on the desk. She hadn't called Ali, she hadn't texted her either. Not yet.

"If I tell you, you have to promise not to tell Ali, or the other girls, you can't even write it in your diary." She said with a smirk. "You have to swear!"

Aria drew a cross over her heart with her finger, "I swear"

"I've been lying to you guys about Andrew" she said

Aria smiled a little "so you are dating! I knew it" she said still smiling she added "everybody knows that"

Spencer shook her head "No everybody thinks that because they think we spend a lot of time together but" she paused, if she said this she couldn't unsay it. She sighed "he's just my cover"

Aria looked at her confused

"What do you mean your cover?"

Aria asked "are you doing something illegal?" She said jokingly.

Spencer laughed "I kinda wish I was"

Aria stopped smiling.

"I been seeing someone..." Spencer started.

"Oh..." Aria prodded

She mumbled something.

"Huh?" Aria said

Spencer let out a loud heavy sigh

"Toby Cavanaugh" she said not looking at Aria

Aria began to laugh.

"Oh Spencer, good one, come on, you are not serious, Ali's head would literally explode" she said giggling

"Yes but, you swore not to tell Ali" Spencer reminded her seriously

Aria stopped laughing, she looked at Spencer's puffy eyes, her hair, which was a wreck, and her miss-buttoned sweater.

"What did that bastard do to you?" Aria asked grimly.

Spencer put her hands up "he didn't...we...uh...we had a fight"

"Did he hit you?" Aria asked concerned.

"He didn't hurt me!" Spencer yelled she covered her mouth crying once again.

"I'm sorry" Spencer said "it's been a long day"

"Spencer, what happened?" Aria asked

"We were...uh" Spencer hesitated

"Oh my god!" Aria gushed "you're sleeping with him?!"

There was no point in denying it "yes" she said quietly.

"Moving on" Aria urged "you were uh..." Aria said smiling

"We were making out but we were going to do it" Spencer said smiling

a little "Andrew called me, we fought about it and then we had fight sex"

Aria interrupted "I'm sorry, what is "fight sex""

"Angry, rough, you-belong-to-me sex" Spencer said tugging on her skirt.

"He raped you?" Aria asked.

"No, I got naked with him Aria, I wanted to do it, just not like that exactly" Spencer said annoyed that she had to defend him. "I love him"

"What a jealous jerk" Aria said "just because a guy called you?"

Spencer bit her lip, "it was probably because I answered it"

"Spencer" Aria chastised her "you didn't!"

"What?" Spencer asked.

Aria sighed "Spence, I love you, but sometimes you act a lot stupider than you are" she shook her head

"Thanks" Spencer said begrudgingly

"Switch places with him, no one he knows knows he's going out with you, he's convinced no one in his life will approve of you, his cover story is a girl like well...you...perfect, his parents love her, you two are making out ready to go at it, his perfect princess fake girlfriend calls him and he says "hold on Spencer my fake girlfriend is more important than you"

"I didn't say he was..."

"You answered the phone!" Aria interrupted. "You know I'm right"

Spencer put her head in her hands

"What did he want anyway?" Aria asked

"Who?" Spencer asked

"Andrew..." Aria reminded her "he's your alibi, was it important, your parents looking for you or something?"

"No, he just wanted to offer to read over my history essay before I turn it on Monday" Spencer said

"That's what I figured" Aria said rolling her eyes.

Spencer looked at her questioningly

"He called you on purpose" Aria said "he knows what rumors are going around at school, he called you because he knew you were with Toby and was hoping to start a fight between you two, because he thinks if you break up with Toby that you'll date him" Spencer thought this over

"And you played right into it" Aria said.

Aria was right, she felt awful, she needed to apologize to him.

"I need to "break up" with Andrew" Spencer said

"Would you be my alibi?" Spencer asked.

"Yes" Aria said without hesitation "but if he hurts you, I'll kill him"

"Thank you" Spencer said wiping away the left over tears in her eyes.

"I think I'll go home and change and then go see, you know who" Spencer said

"Ok" Aria said "if anyone calls looking for you I'll tell them you're in the bathroom" they both laughed for a minute.

"Thank you" Spencer said "I owe you one"

"I'm gonna remember that" Aria said

They both hugged as Ali burst through the door.

" I swear if my boneheaded brother does one mor...oh hey Spence, I didn't realize you were here" Ali's eyes narrowed in on Spencer, she circled her like a shark, Aria attempted a rescue "so what did Jason..." Ali put her hand up to hush Aria

"You look like hell" Ali said "what happened to you?" Spencer again kicked herself for not having prepared an excuse.

"Just tell her Spencer" Aria said sounding annoyed "you know she's gonna find out eventually"

Spencer was in a corner now, having been betrayed by Aria, maybe it was for the best. Spencer tried to think of the best way to tell her.

"Tell me what?" Ali asked inquisitively. "What's the big secret?"

She looked between the two girls neither saying anything.

"Look Ali, I don't want you to make a big deal out of this but..." Spencer hesitated everything in her being telling her not to say anything to Ali

"Andrew broke up with her" Aria blurted out, " because she wouldn't have sex with him"

"Oh" Ali got a venomous look about her. Ali pressed her fingers together, with an evil chuckle. "Andrew Campbell, you messed with the wrong girl" Ali said putting her hands on Spencer's shoulders.

"He damn sure did!" Aria said winking at Spencer.

"I'm gonna handle this" Ali said with a finality. "Muah" she said barely touching Spencer's temple with her lips. She waltzed out the door before Spencer could stop her.

"She's going to handle this Aria!" Spencer said panic rising in her voice "yeah" Aria said

"Why did you lie to her?" Spencer said suddenly angry

"Oh I'm sorry would you like me to call her and say I lied and what really happened was that your REAL boyfriend, Toby Cavanaugh sexually punished you for answering your phone." Aria asked with her phone on hand

"I should call Andrew and warn him" Spencer said

"That's my girl" Aria said "you should warn Toby too"

Spencer grabbed her things

"I'll call you" Spencer said dashing out the door.

Ella appeared a few minutes later "Spencer seems better" she said but Aria knew it was a question

"She just needed to talk" Aria assured

Ella nodded. She started to leave the room.

"Mom?" Aria asked hesitantly.

She turned back. Aria remembered moms talk to other moms.

"Never mind" Aria said.

Please vote and comment