🍓Title: 4.5/5
I personally really like the title, "Was it All for Nothing?" as it presents a contemplative exploration of sacrifice, purpose, and the enduring quest for meaning.
The title perfectly fits the central theme of the book. That struggle to focus on personal as well as collective sacrifices and to dwell on the outcomes they produce, this forces readers to confront the uncomfortable question of whether our actions and sacrifices truly yield the results we hope for.
But, the only flaw for me in this is adding the Author Name on the title, which makes it a bit less appealing to many readers.

🍓Cover: 4/5
The cover of "Was It All For Nothing?" presents a strikingly emotional image. The watercolor illustration of the young woman sitting on a brick wall captures a deep sense of melancholy and introspection.
Her posture i.e. her hands covering her face and gaze directed downwards, emphasizes that she's emotionally vulnerable. The color palette, includes soft pinks and oranges which adds to the overall mood of sadness while also infusing the cover with a subtle warmth.
The prominent placing of the title, "Was It All For Nothing?," along with the author's name, Sarah Jaju is good. But, the author could have integrated the title and author's name more harmoniously with the illustration.
A more bold font that complements the watercolor style could create a better visual balance and blend the text with the artwork.

🍓Blurb: 4.5/5
This blurb introduces a compelling and multi-layered story with well-drawn characters and emotional depth.
Park Hae-Ri, our main character is positioned in an engaging scenario where her ideal university life is disrupted by romantic and personal dilemmas. The introduction of Hae-Jun, the handsome Korean-American student, adds a romantic twist, while Min-Jae's confession introduces potential conflict.
The stakes are heightened with Hae-Ri’s family problems and Jessica’s unexpected romantic development. The blurb effectively teases the main conflicts and emotional stakes without giving too much away.
The excerpt from Chapter 18 provides hints for a deeper emotional connection. The romantic and emotional moment will definitely draw the readers in.
But yes, the author could briefly summarize the main characters' key traits to help readers connect more quickly with them.

🍓Character Development: 7/10
All the characters are really well-developed, with complex emotions and interactions that drive the story beautifully.
Hae-Ri, our protagonist, the main female lead is a talented and ambitious student with a unique cultural background. Her struggles with her expressing her emotions are beautifully shown. Her passion for singing and fashion, combined with her practical outlook on life, makes her a relatable and empathetic protagonist.
On the other hand, her best friend, Jessica Myres is a lively, sporty Australian who faces insecurity despite her cheerful demeanor. The fact that she's a mathematical genius is really awesome. Her character is my favorite in the whole book.
Coming to Min-Jae, Hae-Ri's other best friend, he is a loyal, city-boy with a talent for guitar and a knack for getting into trouble due to his short temper and need for approval. His bond with Hae-Ri is precious and pious.
Hae-Jun, the main male protagonist, is a reserved, high-achieving student with a background of moving from the U.S. to Korea. His quiet struggle with loneliness and betrayal, coupled with his determination to support his family really hikes up his character graph. The budding relationship between him and Hae-Ri is just so beautiful and you've expressed it perfectly. ✨
But, given the focus on personal and romantic dilemmas, it’s essential that characters are relatable and multidimensional. The depth of their struggles and relationships should be even more described. Yes, in the further chapters noticable growth has been seen in the character but I feel that the going more into the depth of these characters can be beneficial for the author.

🍓Plot: 9/10
The plot seems engaging, with romantic and personal conflicts interwoven with emotional stakes. It centers on Park Hae-Ri, whose ideal university experience is disrupted by complex romantic and personal dilemmas. The introduction of Hae-Jun, a Korean-American student, and Min-Jae’s emotional struggles add layers of romantic tension and conflict.
The combination of university life with romantic entanglements as well as family issues enhances the storytelling, makes the plot really compelling and worth reading for.
The evolving relationships between Hae-Ri, Hae-Jun, and Min-Jae drive much of the plot’s tension. Hae-Ri's feelings for Hae-Jun and Min-Jae's feelings for Hae-Ri introduce the emotional conflict in the story. The struggles faced by Jessica and Hae-Ri as a non-Korean  and Half-Korean respectivly, living in Korea provide a relatability to the plot.
Then the last straw, Jessica's relationship with Ho-jin and the family issues faced by Hae-Ri just adds to the drama. ✨

🍓Grammar and Vocabulary: 3.5/5
The grammar is generally sound, but there are a few minor issues. For example in the starting chapter only you've written a statement,
"I said, slapping the exercise book shut"
But, in my opinion if you would have written it differently like,
"I said while slapping the exercise book shut."
That would have added more weight to it.
In the same chapter, "He was a pure Korean - unlike me therefore he'd never given much importance" should use a semicolon or a period instead of a dash and "therefore" needs a comma after it.
Additionally, at a lot of places you've used double punctuations in the dialogue, for example in the chapter 8, you've written,
"Uhm, to be honest, we did have a couple of awkward moments, apart from that...we're okay.", I said, hesitantly.
Where you've used a full stop in the end as well as a comma, but grammatically it should have been,
"Uhm, to be honest, we did have a couple of awkward moments, apart from that...we're okay," I said hesitantly.
So, I suggest you to work on these minor errors. Now, talking about the vocabulary of the book, it is appropriate, fits the context of the story, is engaging and understandable as well. The informal language used at many places gives an overall natural feeling to the interactions.

🍓Engagement: 4.5/5
The book appears to be very engaging, with extremely relatable characters and emotionally charged situations that will draw many readers in.
The challenges faced by the protagonist, Park Hae-Ri and the romantic tension between her and Hae-Jun are likely to hold the reader's interest.
Your writing style is engaging and conversational. It captures the tension and frustration of the main character well. Also, the relatable dialogues along with a clear setting are the cherry on the top.
The author just needs to make sure that there are more smoother transitions between the multiple POV's used in the book. Additionally, enhancing the grammatical structure will further boost reader engagement.

🍓Overall: 4.5/5
The book’s strong title, compelling cover, intriguing blurb, and engaging characters and plot all contribute to its overall appeal. With minor improvements in grammar and some refinement in the cover design, it has the potential to be highly impactful.✨

🍓Total Marks: 41.5/50

🍓Extra Pointers:

Whether the book is K-drama worthy or not?
→Yes, the plot of the book is most definitely K-drama worthy but the grammar needs to be looked after. The plot’s combination of romantic and personal conflicts, along with its emotional depth, makes it well-suited for adaptation into a K-drama. The Author just needs to polish her grammar skills and try to maintain a smoother transition between the POV's to make it even better.

2.Uniqueness of the characters:
→As I said earlier, each character has distinct traits and motivations. Their individuality and impact is what I really like in this story. Choi Min-Jae's loyalty, Jeon Hae-Jun's solitude, Jessica Myres' positivity, and Park Hae-Ri's ambition and vulnerability. The characters’ personal conflicts and growth trajectories are portrayed with depth, making them engaging and memorable.

3.Is the plot worth reading?
→Yes, the plot seems engaging and rich with emotional and romantic elements. Its exploration of personal sacrifices and relationships makes it a worthwhile read, especially for those interested in character-driven stories with deep emotional stakes.

Author: Sarah_Hanguklover_13
Reviewer: DazzlingVee_

■□■□■□■□■■□■□■□■□■