"What's up?" He asked.

I couldn't hold back anymore as I pulled him closer to me and felt his lips crash with mine. Colby started to pull himself back a little and thought I was beginning to feel uncomfortable. Without hesitation, I pulled him close to me and sat down on the bed.

"Katherine?"

I remained silent while looking into his eyes.

"Hey, are you okay? You don't look so good." He asked with concern.

"I need to confess something to you. Yes, I like you a lot."

"Is that right, huh?" He looked down at me with a smirk on his face. "I thought so after our first kiss that we shared together."

"Colby. I'm sorry for coming straight out about that."

He interrupted me as his lips began crashing with mine once more. And I felt him coming close to my body. His hands gently held against my waist and I felt his tongue slowly making its entrance into my mouth. However, we took in the moment. While making out, I couldn't help but to notice that he was getting aroused in the process.

"Shit." He huffed, pulling back, "I am so sorry."

I couldn't help myself. I didn't understand why I was feeling this way for him. I sat down and rubbed my hands around his calves, leading up to his erection while he continued to blush and stutter.

"Didn't you tell me that you had morals, Katherine?" He asked.

"I know I do, but I feel like my morals can be broken for tonight. Can't it?"

"Babe." He said in a deep monotone voice. He's never called me that before, and it made me develop butterflies in my stomach.

"I mean, Jon and Brianna are in the other room and I don't want to do something that you could end up regretting because we aren't in a relationship." Colby said quietly.

"I don't mind at all. Do you, Colby?" I said with a devilish grin.

"Now that you think about it. No, I don't mind." He chuckled, leaving a smirk on his face.

He started undoing his leather belt and his black skinny jeans as they dropped to the floor. After he slipped out of his shoes, he was left in his boxers.

I started undressing myself from top to bottom. After unveiling my body, I was left in my laced panties and my laced black Victoria's Secret bra.

Colby was speechless for a few moments until he broke the silence. "Damn, Katherine."

I slowly unhooked my bra, leaving my breast exposed.

"You look so beautiful underneath all of those clothes." He said with astonishment.

"So do you, Colby." I blushed, gazing my eyes upon his six-packed abs and muscles.

He quietly allowed a small growl escape from his mouth while he softly hovered over me as our bodies were touching in skin-to-skin contact for the very first time.

Now that I thought of it, I remembered why I had morals. I was terrified of history repeating itself like it did with Tony. But with Colby, everything felt perfect and I couldn't believe I was about to do this with the man I met a month ago because of a WWE event; let alone him being a WWE superstar with a busy schedule on his hands.

His voice became deeper as he leaned in closer into my ear and began whispering. "Katherine, you better listen to what I have to say, alright?"

I nodded and seen him slide my panties to the floor. He looked into my eyes and I felt a huge connection with him that I could never see in another man. I've never had this interaction before with any man.

Colby leaned down in between my legs and slowly kissed my inner thighs, trailing his tongue down to my pussy. He looked up at me and leaned down, slowly eating me out.

This huge amount of pleasure I was feeling was something I've never imagined having in my entire lifetime. His tongue gliding around me made me wetter with every stroke and flick that he'd make. I couldn't help but to allow soft and quiet moans to escape from my mouth and I seen him look back at me with a devilish grin.

"Colby." I moaned.

He leaned back and laid me down on the bed. He smiled down at me and softly chuckled, noticing that my face was growing red and my breathing grew heavier.

He pressed his body against mine and gently nibbled around my earlobes and down my neck. After giving me enough pleasure, he slowly lined himself against me and thrusted himself inside, making a deep growl.

"Colby, it hurts." I winced in pain.

"I'm sorry, baby. I'll take things slow so it doesn't hurt as much, alright?"

He kept his word and continued to take things slow. Whenever I began to feel a sharp pain, he'd lean down and press his lips against mine in attempt to comfort me.

"Fuck, Katherine. You're so tight." He moaned while looking into my eyes.

My hands were around his back while he continued to thrust harder. My nails began digging into his back, accidentally drawing blood while I heard him loudly moaning.

"Fuck!"

After a few minutes of feeling pain, it started transpiring into the feeling of pleasure. Colby started to lift my legs over his shoulders and went deeper inside of me. I couldn't believe what was going on between Colby and I. Part of me was terrified that Jon and Brianna would hear us from downstairs with the noises we kept making.

I allowed more moans to escape from my mouth while he continued.

"Go faster, Colby!" I howled.

He started chuckling and looked into my eyes. "Anything for you, beautiful."

He started picking up the pace and I heard him groaning with pleasure whilst looking into my eyes with a devilish grin.

"I'm about to cum, baby." Colby moaned. "Fuck!"

He kept moaning as I felt him throbbing inside of me with each deep thrust. Before things transpired, I watched him pull out as he released himself all over my body.

We were both feeling heavily exhausted for a few minutes after he finished, catching our breath in the process. He then gave me a warm smile that I've never seen before from him.

"Katherine?"

"Yes, Colby?"

"Is it okay to say that I love you right now, or is it still too soon?"

I paused for a moment. Love was a powerful word with a very huge meaning behind it. I was scared of saying it for now.

While remaining silent, Colby's smile began to fade. "Baby?"

"I just don't know how to say it back. Just know that I do, though."

He chuckled while playing with the strands of my hair, wrapping a strand of my hair around his finger with his body on top of mine. "I understand. I'm not mad or upset by any means necessary. At least I know you do."

"This stays between us, right?" I asked.

"I promise. I won't tell Jon, Joe, Brianna, or anyone else." He grinned. "This'll be our dirty little secret, alright?" He said with his lips pressing against mine.

"I agree." I looked at him with a warm smile. "We should head back downstairs since we've been up here for a long time."

"Right." He coughed a couple of times. "But you should get in the shower, beautiful. I'm sure you don't like having sweat all over that gorgeous body of yours. Am I right?" Colby said.

"I should, actually. I'll catch up with you guys in thirty-minutes."

While he put back on his clothes, I quickly found a new outfit to wear after I was done showering. Colby looked back at me with a smile on his face and went downstairs to talk with Jon and Brianna while I took a shower.