ㅤ⏜︵ ㅤׁㅤWelcome to the Frozen Echoes Awards. In this chapter, we have given the reviews of the category of Best Title. Our judges have carefully evaluated each entry based on originality, hook and creativity, relevance to the book's genre and story, memorability, unique language usage, and ability to convey the story idea. After careful consideration, we are pleased to share our reviews and ratings for each title. Let's dive into the reviews and see which titles have made a lasting impression on our judges!ㅤ

✶ㅤ

Judge - Ansha_Writes

Cataract of Delusional by new_erasktaylor

- Originality (20): 20 unique metaphorical uses of "cataract".

- Hook & Creativity (20): 17 intriguing phrase, but not extremely creative. Replacing the word 'Delusional' might help.

- Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story (20): 14 somewhat connects to the story, but needs more context like the idea of genre etc.

- Is it worth remembering (20): 19 very memorable.

- Usage of any unique/rare language to highlight (10): 8 uses "cataract" in a rare way.

- Does it give some idea regarding the story (10): 7 difficult to infer the story from the title

Total: 85/100

────────────────────────────
But Then I Fell in Love by Jahools

- Originality (20): 14 more original than initially thought because of the usage of But and Then, but still common

- Hook & Creativity (20): 15 more creative than initially thought, but still straightforward

- Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story (20): 16 fits a romance story well, with a hint of surprise of maybe again falling in love or falling in love after being determined not to be.

- Is it worth remembering (20): 14 somewhat memorable, but may not stick

- Usage of any unique/rare language to highlight (10): 6 no rare language used, but starting the title with a conjunction adds up the points.

- Does it give some idea regarding the story (10): 8 implies a romance story with a twist

Total: 73/100

────────────────────────────

Miss Fantasy by Honeyrose2020

- Originality (20): 10 somewhat unique, because of using 'Miss' but not entirely new.

- Hook & Creativity (20): 12 straightforward, but "Miss" adds a touch

- Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story (20): 14 fits a fantasy story, but lacks depth

- Is it worth remembering (20): 13 somewhat memorable, but may not stick

- Usage of any unique/rare language to highlight (10): 4 no rare language used

- Does it give some idea regarding the story (10): 7 implies fantasy, but the only hint which I can get is a girl who fantasizes?

Total: 60/100

────────────────────────────

The Gathering Dark by Aravis-Brightspell

- Originality (20): 18 very unique and evocative. I liked how you used 'gathering' before darkness, which may imply that the characters will get surrounded by darkness eventually.

- Hook & Creativity (20): 19 intriguing and ominous

- Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story (20): 18 fits a thriller/mystery/horror story perfectly

- Is it worth remembering (20): 17 very memorable and sticky

- Usage of any unique/rare language to highlight (10): 6 uses "gathering" in a rare way

- Does it give some idea regarding the story (10): 9 implies a dark, suspenseful story

Total: 87/100

────────────────────────────

The Forbidden Golden Five and The Philosopher's Stone by Cassiopeia_Lestrange

- Originality (20): 8 not original, familiar phrases have been used.

- Hook & Creativity (20): 12 familiar phrase, but adds a touch of intrigue due to the addition of 'Forbidden' & 'Golden'. Also the title is really long.

- Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story (20): 13 fits a fantasy/adventure story.

- Is it worth remembering (20): 14
Memorable because of similarity but the readers will not be able to remember full and would end up mixing due to the length.

- Usage of any unique/rare language to highlight (10): 5 uses familiar language and references

- Does it give some idea regarding the story (10): 7 implies a complex story filled with adventures of the 5 characters maybe,but no clear idea.

Total: 59/100

────────────────────────────

Experiment 3:30 by 12Oceana12

- Originality (20): 19 unique, but "experiment" is common

- Hook & Creativity (20): 15 intriguing, adding 3:30 might refer to the time when the experiment was conducted or maybe the time taken to complete it.

- Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story (20): 17 fits a sci-fi/thriller story, but lacks specificity

- Is it worth remembering (20): 19 it is very memorable, but readers may get confused about the time.

- Usage of any unique/rare language to highlight (10): 10 uses "3:30" in a rare way

Does it give some idea regarding the story (10): 10 implies an experimental or sci-fi story

Total: 90/100

────────────────────────────

Judge - Adiliraven

LOVE IN 3D by dwarkaratna

- Originality: 10/20 - The title isn't super unique, but it's not overly common either.

- Hook & Creativity: 12/20 - It's somewhat creative, but it doesn't immediately grab attention.

- Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story: 8/20 - The title doesn't match the historical fanfiction genre very well.

- Is it worth remembering: 18/20 - It's easy to remember because it's simple.

- Usage of any unique/rare language to highlight: 6/10 - "3D" adds a bit of uniqueness.

- Does it give some idea regarding the story: 6/10 - It doesn't give much insight into what the story is about or its genre.

Total: 60/100

────────────────────────────

BEAUTIFUL LIAR : LOST IN LOVE by Ay_Princess

- Originality: 14/20 - While the phrase "Beautiful Liar" is somewhat common, combining it with "Lost in Love" adds a unique twist.

- Hook & Creativity: 16/20 - The title has a strong hook with the contrast between "Beautiful" and "Liar," and "Lost in Love" adds intrigue.

- Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story: 18/20 - Since the main character, Angelina, is portrayed as a beautiful liar, the title fits well with the story's themes.

- Is it worth remembering: 18/20 - The title is memorable because it paints a vivid image of the main character.

- Usage of any unique/rare language to highlight: 6/10 - There's no particularly rare language, but the juxtaposition of "Beautiful" and "Liar" is effective.

- Does it give some idea regarding the story: 10/10- The title effectively hints at the central theme of the story, which revolves around deception and love.

Total: 82/100

────────────────────────────

TO MELT A FROZEN HEART by KalliopeAdair

- Originality: 18/20 - The title stands out as unique and intriguing.

- Hook & Creativity: 19/20 - It's both hooking and creative, making readers curious about the story.

- Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story: 20/20 - The title aligns perfectly with the book's genre and storyline, suggesting themes of thawing emotional barriers.

- Is it worth remembering: 19/20 - With its catchy and evocative imagery, it's likely to stick in readers' minds.

- Usage of any unique/rare language to highlight: 8/10 - While not overly unique, the use of "Melt a Frozen Heart" is powerful and evocative.

- Does it give some idea regarding the story: 10/10 - The title provides a clear indication of the central theme, suggesting a narrative focused on emotional transformation.

Total: 94/100

────────────────────────────

WOODS by _KimAes_

- Originality: 10/20 -The word "Woods" is quite common in titles, so it doesn't stand out as particularly original.

- Hook & Creativity: 8/20-The title is very simple and doesn't have much creative flair. It doesn't immediately grab attention or spark curiosity.

-Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story: 6/20- The story is a mystery thriller, and based on the chapters read so far, there's no significant connection to woods. It doesn't seem relevant to the current plot.

- Is it Worth Remembering: 12/20- "Woods" is easy to remember because it's a single word. However, its simplicity might make it less distinctive.

- Usage of Unique/Rare Language: 2/10- The word "Woods" is very common and doesn't use unique or rare language.

- Does it Give Some Idea Regarding the Story: 5/10- The title suggests that the woods will play a significant role in the story. However, this hasn't been evident in the chapters read so far, so it doesn't provide much insight into the story yet.

Total: 43/100

────────────────────────────

TOTAL ECLIPSE OF HEART by strawberry1d

- Originality: 15/20 This title is recognizable because of the famous song, but it's not common for a book title. It feels somewhat unique but not entirely fresh.

- Hook & Creativity: 18/20 The title is catchy and poetic. It grabs attention and suggests a deep, emotional story, making it very creative and interesting.

- Relevance to the Book's Genre & Story: 14/20 If the book has an "enemies to lovers" theme, the title can fit well because it hints at a big emotional change. "Eclipse" suggests a major transformation or shift in feelings, which can match a romance or dramatic story.

- Is it Worth Remembering: 19/20 The title is very memorable. It's easy to remember because it's connected to a popular song and has a strong, emotional impact.

- Usage of Unique/Rare Language: 7/10 The words aren't rare, but the way they are combined is unusual and striking, making it feel special and unique.

- Does it Give Some Idea Regarding the Story: 8/10 The title hints at a story involving big emotional changes or challenges, possibly related to love or personal relationships. It suggests something intense and transformative will happen.

Total: 81/100

────────────────────────────

The participants are requested to contact the founder either on discord (id : sviiari) or Instagram (id : ariscwtch) for the stickers (winners) and certificates (all the participants). There might be a delay in delivering the certificates, however.