Aries: The Puppeteer

Taurus: Offenderman

Gemini: Jeff The Killer

Cancer: Sally Williams

Leo: Clockwork

Virgo: Eyeless Jack

Libra: BEN Drowned

Scorpio: Slenderman

Sagittarius: Ticci Toby

Capricorn: Jason The Toymaker

Aquarius: Homicidal Liu

Pisces: Nina The Killer