20 minutes before Glee Club...
In the cafeteria...
Finn's POV:

"Okay guys. Thank you all for meeting me before Glee Club. I know you all probably had something better to do, but, I have a favor to ask all of you" I say, and they all look at me confused

"What is it, Finn? And, where's Rachel?" Santana asks me, and I smile

"Actually, that brings me to why we are all here. Now, Rachel's birthday is coming up soon as you all know, and I wanna do something special for her" I say, and everyone is still looking confused

"What did you have in mind, Finn?" Mercedes asks

"Well, I planned for Rachel to have fun all day with her friends and then come back here, where there will be a surprise party" I say

"With unicorns?" Brittany asks, and I nod

"Sure, Brit. Anyway, I have specific things that you are all going to do. But, it's only if you guys want to" I say, hoping everyone said yes

"Of course we want to, Finn! As much as Rachel annoys some of us sometimes, we still love her. She's family" Tina says, and I smile

"Great! Okay, now, here's the plan. Some people are going to hang out with Rachel, while others will be in the choir room with me decorating" I say

"Speaking of which, why aren't we in the choir room?" Lauren asks

"Well, earlier, I had a feeling that Rachel was listening in on my conversation with Quinn and Puck, so I wanted to make sure that she went to the choir room, and didn't hear our plan" I say, and continue speaking. "Anyway, here is the list of people who are going where"

"Puck, Mike, Tina, Brittany, Lauren, Sam, Artie, Kurt-"

"Um excuse me? This better be the list of people going out with Rachel cause I'm not staying here to decorate" Kurt says, and I sigh

"Kurt, we'll need your help. You know what Rachel likes best and how we should decorate for her" I say, and Kurt scoffs

"I've known Rachel for the longest time out of everyone here. I'm not staying here to decorate. She's your girlfriend, Finn. Decorate it the way she would want it" He says, and I sigh again

"Fine. Kurt, your off the list. Everyone else, you'll go out with Rachel and make sure she doesn't suspect anything. I want her to have a fun time, and not think we are planing this for her. I want it to be a special one" o day, and they all look around

"I think I speak for all when I say that we are in, Finn" Santana says, and I smile

"Okay! Now, let's get to Glee Club. Rachel should be there when we get there" I say, and we all make our way to the choir room. On our way, Kurt stops me, and everyone else walks ahead of us

"Um, Kurt, what's up?" I ask him confused

"Well, I wanted to introduce you to someone" he says, and calls someone over

"Finn.... this is Blaine. My boyfriend" Kurt says, and I smile and put my hand out for a handshake

"Hey, Its nice to meet you. I've heard a lot about you since I've been back" I say

"The same goes for you, Finn. I'm glad to finally meet you. Coming to visit you in the hospital with Kurt just wasn't the same as actually meeting you." He says, and I laugh

"Yeah, it probably wasn't a very interesting conversation either" I say, and he laughs. "Anyway, Blaine, do you think you could take Kurt's spot and help us decorate?" I ask him, and he smiles

"Um, sure. Why not? It could be fun" he says, and I smile back at him

"That's great!" I say, and he make our way to the choir room

Rachel's POV:

I don't get it! They should've been here 15 minutes ago! It doesn't make any sense! I specifically came here 25 minutes earlier so that I would have five minutes to find a hiding spot and then I could hear what they were saying and figure out what they were saying about me! Okay, now that I say it in my head I sound insane.... but it was a good plan in my head! I come out from my hiding spot and go to walk out of the choir room and as I'm walking out, I bump into Mr. Shue

"Oh, hey Rachel. What are you doing here so early?" He asks me, and I laugh

"I'm always here 5 minutes early Mr. Shue, I like to be on time" I say, and he smiles

"Well, I'm glad you like to be on time Rachel. That is something that you do not have in common with many people in this world" he says, and I feel proud of myself

"Mr. Shue, have you seen glee club anywhere?" I ask him, hoping he'll give me an answer I want

"Uh, I don't believe I have. Why?" He asks

"Oh, nothing. I thought that they needed to talk about something but, I guess not" I say, and go and sit in a chair in the corner of the choir room. A few minutes later, one by one, the glee club slowly started to come in as if nothing had ever happened. Like there was no plan against me or something. Finn came over and sat next to me, and kissed me on the cheek.

"Where were you? I texted you a bunch and I waited at your locker" I ask, trying to not seem so suspicious

"Oh, I went to the cafeteria with Puck. We got some chips" he says, and I glare at him

"What? It's true. If you don't believe me, ask him" he says laughing a little

"Fine." I say sternly, and I turn to Puck

"Puckerman!" I call out, and he looks back at me

"What do you want, Berry?" He asks me annoyed

"Did you go to the cafeteria with Finn before Glee Club?" I ask him

"Yeah. Why?" He asks me, and I look back at Finn who is smiling

"No reason. No reason at all" I say, and slowly sink back in my chair

"Okay, guys. Now that we have Finn Hudson back, I wanted to try and get back to our regular lessons!" Mr. Shue says, and everyone groans

"Hey, guys! It's a fun lesson, I promise!" He says, and I sigh

"What is it Mr. Shue?" I ask, and he smiles

"Well, this weeks lesson is: Disney vs. Nick!" He says excitedly, and we all cheer. "Now, the way this is gonna work is that we were going to have two teams. Ones who were a Nickelodeon kids, and another who were Disney kids. I wanna see what you guys were like when you were little" He says, and everyone's smiles were huge. "Okay, so, on the right, we'll have Disney kids, and on the left will be Nickelodeon kids. Alright, go!" He exclaims, and everybody runs to either side. When everyone is on their side, I'm still sitting in a chair in the corner of the choir room.

"Um, Rachel, you have to pick a side" Mr. Shue says

"But, I wasn't just a Nickelodeon or Disney kid. I was both" I say, and Mr. Shue sighs

"Well then, Rachel, you can participate with both sides. There. Easy fix." Mr. Shue says, and then sighs

"As for the rest of you, I want each of you to pick a song that was either performed on Nickelodeon, or on Disney. If you're on the Disney side, you sing Disney. And vice a versa" he says, and claps his hands

"Okay, let's get to work!" He exclaims, and everyone starts talking to each other about what songs they're gonna sing. As everyone is talking, I see Finn go up to Mr. Shue. I could tell that Finn asked him something, but I didn't know what. Afterwards, they both went into Mr. Shue's office. I rolled my eyes, and went to walk out of the choir room

"Hey, where are you going?!" Santana exclaims

"I can't be in the same room with someone who isn't telling me the truth." I say, and look at Finn. I look back at Santana, and sigh. "Tell Mr. Shue that I got sick or something. I'll be in tomorrow" I say, and walk out of the choir room

Santana's POV:

"Rachel, wh-" I went to go ask Rachel what was wrong, but I couldn't. She was already out of the choir room. I sigh, and turn back to Quinn

"Guys, we can't keep this secret from Rachel for long" I say

"Why not? It's not like she'll know. We all acted completely normal" Puck says

"Well I guess we weren't acting normal enough, because she just left the choir room and said she couldn't be in the same room with someone who isn't telling her the truth" I say, and they all look at each other worried

"Well, what are we supposed to do?" Quinn asks

"We, are going to have to speak to the big man in charge" I say, and look at Finn in Mr. Shue's office