Chapter Six
The Reality of Sperm

Sitting in Hank's dimly lit office, I felt a mix of anticipation and anxiety. My cousins, Joshua and Jonathan, flanked me on either side, and the atmosphere was thick with unspoken thoughts. This meeting held the potential to reshape our lives in ways we had never fully considered.

We had all made the decision to donate sperm at Xytex, a choice that had ripple effects we were still trying to understand. Now, here we were, ready to confront the consequences of that decision.

Hank, the private investigator, was a steady presence in the room, shuffling through a stack of papers as he prepared to share what he had discovered. His expression was serious but not unfriendly, a contrast to the tension that gripped us. "I've managed to track down three children who were born from your donations, aside from Ocean," he began, his voice steady.

"Three?" Joshua asked, brow furrowing in confusion. He had been quieter than usual, worry flashing across his face. He was a father too, but the child resulting from his donation had remained an elusive mystery.

"Three children," Hank confirmed, flipping through his notes. "Two of them are directly connected to Jonathan, and one belongs to you, Joshua. However, I don't have any further details on the woman who used your sperm. That information was not disclosed."

I glanced at Joshua, feeling a twinge of sympathy. The idea of him having a child out there—one he couldn't connect with—made my heart ache. He had been through so much since his divorce, and this revelation was just another layer of complexity to navigate.

"What about Jonathan?" I prompted, eager to shift the focus and keep the conversation moving.

Hank smiled slightly, turning to Jonathan. "Well, it turns out Jonathan has twins. They were born to a woman named Ilona Gaines, who goes by Tookie. She's somewhat known in certain circles."

"Wow," Jonathan breathed, his eyes widening. "Twins? That's... a lot to process." I could see the gears turning in his mind, calculating what this meant for him, for us.

"Yeah, definitely," I agreed, feeling the weight of the moment settle on my shoulders. "What are their names? How old are they?"

"Let me check," Hank said, rifling through his papers with purpose. "Okay, the twins are named Jett and Jersey. They're just over three years old."

A rush of emotions swept over me. Two tiny lives, part of our story yet entirely separate. I imagined their giggles and cries, the chaos that twins brought into a household. It was beautiful and overwhelming all at once.

"I wasn't able to uncover much beyond the basic information," Hank continued. "But I can tell you that the families seem to be private. It might take some additional digging to find out more about them."

Joshua leaned back in his chair, a thoughtful expression clouding his face. "What do we do now? Do we reach out to them?"

Hank nodded slowly, the gravity of his words hanging in the air. "That's entirely up to you two. This can open up a lot of questions and potential relationships. Are you all ready for that?"

"I think we should at least consider it," I finally said, searching for the right words. "They deserve to know about you guys, don't you think?"

Jonathan looked thoughtful, his brows knitting together. "Yeah, but what if they don't want to know us? Or what if they have families already? It could complicate things."

I understood his hesitation. My own experience as a father had shown me how fragile relationships could be. "But they might also want to know where they came from," I argued. "And we could give them that. It's not just about us—it's about them too."

"True," Joshua agreed, leaning forward in his chair, a glimmer of determination in his eyes. "I can't help but think about what it would have meant to me as a kid to know I had siblings out there. It could be a source of connection for them."

The conversation began to shift into a discussion about what reaching out might look like. We batted around ideas, weighing the pros and cons, as each of us shared our perspectives. It felt like navigating uncharted waters, where every decision held the potential for unforeseen consequences.

As we wrapped up our meeting, a noticeable shift settled over us. What had begun as a daunting task had transformed into a mission that felt meaningful. We were no longer just three brothers leading separate lives; we were becoming a family again, intertwined with new lives waiting to be discovered.

Walking out of Hank's office, I felt lighter, as if a burden had been lifted. We were opening a door that had felt closed for so long, inviting possibilities into our lives.

Turning to my cousins, I couldn't help but smile. "Whatever happens next, I'm glad we're doing this together."

"Me too," Jonathan replied, a spark of excitement in his voice.

Joshua nodded, his expression shifting from worry to determination. "Let's see where this takes us."

As we stepped out into the sunlight, I felt a rush of hope. This was just the beginning of a new chapter—one filled with unknowns but also the promise of connection and family. I took a deep breath, ready to embrace whatever came next.

Liked by tookegaines, tanyaarenas, charmbarbeau, and 90,712 others
tatianaarenas Daddy with the off guide photo
View all 1,893 comments

Backstage at SmackDown, the energy was electric, a vibrant blend of excitement and nerves that pulsed through the dimly lit corridors. The distant roar of the crowd seeped in, but it felt like a world away from where I stood. I'd just bumped into Charm Barbeau, someone I knew through mutual friends but hadn't had the chance to really connect with. As we settled into a quiet corner, I could sense the buzz around us, but I was too caught up in the moment to care.

I recounted the whirlwind of events that had led to my relationship with Joe. Charm listened intently, her eyes reflecting a mix of empathy and intrigue. I found myself drifting occasionally, caught up in the memories that had shaped my life over the past few months.

"It's been a crazy ride, you know?" I began, feeling the words spill out. "From the moment I found out Joe was Ocean's father to actually deciding to be together—it's like I'm living in a soap opera."

Charm nodded, her expression earnest. "I can only imagine. It must have been a lot to process."

Just as I was about to dive deeper into my story, Charm's expression shifted. "You know, something wild happened to me too," she said, a glimmer of mischief in her eyes.

I leaned in, curious. "Oh? What's that?"

She took a deep breath, clearly recalling a moment that had changed everything for her. "So, Joe delivered my daughter, Ocean, in the parking lot of a mall."

My eyebrows shot up, the absurdity of it hitting me like a punchline. "You're joking!"

"Nope, it sounds crazy, but it's true. And that's not even the craziest part," she said, her voice dropping to a conspiratorial whisper.

I urged her on, captivated. "What could possibly top that?"

"Joe, at the time, was a complete stranger who had drunkenly donated sperm during a bet at his bachelor party back in 2014. We both went to this place called Xytex." I grinned, a mix of nostalgia and disbelief dancing across her features.

Charm blinked, processing the wild turn of my tale. "Wait, you used Xytex?" Charm asked, incredulity etched across her face.

"Yup," I answered.

"I did too, but the sperm I used had never been used before," Charm explained, the implications of her casual admission crashing down around us like a wave.

What were the odds? My mind raced. The world felt impossibly small at that moment, threads of fate intertwining in ways I never could have predicted.

"Charm, I think you need a DNA test because Joshua or Jonathan may be Amias's father," I suggested, my tone shifting from casual curiosity to something more serious.

Charm rubbed her temples, the weight of the revelation hitting her. "I didn't expect this to happen at my new job," she said, a hint of panic in her voice.

The tension in the air was palpable as I processed what she had just revealed. The idea that Joshua or Jonathan could potentially be the father of Charm's son, Amias, was both wild and interesting.

I stood up, my mind racing. "I need to tell Joe about this," I said, my voice firm.

As I left, my words hung in the air like a heavy fog. The universe had a strange way of connecting us, and this latest twist felt almost too surreal. I walked briskly to Joe's locker room, my heart pounding with the news I had to share.

I opened the door to find Joe seated comfortably, feeding our four-month-old daughter, Ocean. The sight warmed my heart. It had only been two months since we discovered that Joe was Ocean's father and decided to give our relationship a real shot. We were taking things slow, but I couldn't deny the progress we'd made.

"Guess what?" I said, excitement bubbling beneath the surface.

"What is it?" Joe replied, looking up with that familiar sparkle in his eyes.

"The new ring announcer may be Josh or Jon's mystery baby momma," I blurted out, unable to contain my enthusiasm.

Joe raised an eyebrow, clearly intrigued. "She used sperm from Xytex?" he asked, the pieces falling into place.

I nodded, my heart racing. "Yup, most likely Josh is the father. But honestly, I'm starting to think the universe is working overtime."

"That's crazy. We couldn't find anything on her, and now she's working at the same place as him?" Joe said, shaking his head in disbelief.

"I know! It's wild. I told you, we just needed to be patient," I replied, feeling a rush of adrenaline at the thought of this bizarre connection.

As I sat next to Joe, watching him carefully balance the bottle for Ocean, I couldn't help but reflect on how strange life had become. Just months ago, I was navigating the uncertainty of motherhood alone, trying to figure out how to provide for my daughter while grappling with the complicated feelings surrounding Joe. Now, here we were—co-parents and partners, figuring things out together.

"You know," Joe said, a hint of a smile creeping onto his face, "this whole situation is like something out of a movie. I mean, we went from strangers to raising a daughter together, and now this."

I laughed, the tension easing. "Right? If someone had told me all of this a year ago, I would have laughed in their face."

"Life is strange," he said, a thoughtful look crossing his face. "But I'm glad it brought us here, together."

I felt my heart swell at his words. We had been through so much in such a short time, but each challenge only seemed to deepen our bond. The past may have been complicated, but the present felt full of possibilities.

As we sat in that locker room, I couldn't help but feel grateful. The journey had been fraught with unexpected twists, but each moment had led us to this point. It reminded me that sometimes, the most beautiful things in life come from the most chaotic circumstances.