Warriorcats00114 I believe you asked this question? And first, before I start. I am SO sorry for not doing your requests! Tell me if I have not done yours in Comments 😩

Well let's start with it

This is a tricky one!

So.... What if Mudclaw survived...?

Well, the clans would be led into chaos, perfectly terrible. Mudstar would have killed Onewhisker and Ashfoot would've like, gotten killed. (ASHEH!) probably resulting to a Hawkfrost deputy, named by Mudstar. A dead Mistyfoot, probably a depressed Mothflight, which also results to a bunch of dead cats, depressed cats, and absurd material. If Ashfur had (sorry) actually turned evil, he would have probably joined WindClan, been deputy? Got revenge on Brambleclaw (NU!) and the prophecy "Before there can be peace, blood will spill blood, and the lake will run red" will fail, and it will be turned around, Hawkfrost and Ashfur killing Brambleclaw instead of him killing them. (Not Ash)

OKAY SO I Don't  KNOW IF THIS IS GOOD OR NOT