Requested by afellownerd

DC vs DC vs DC vs DC, which one of Batman's sidekick will come out as the strongest Robin of them all?

<Cue: Invader Theme>

Toomi: Robin, the Boy or Girl Wonder has been Batman's most faithful sidekick. Helping him beat up the big bads of Gotham City.

Megumi: And knowing how there are so many of them, based on the rules of What if Battles, we are only going to do this battle royale based off four of the most iconic Robins

Toomi: Like Nightwing, the original protege of Batman,

Megumi: And Red Hood, the violent gunslinging vigilante,

Sachi: And Red Robin, the third Robin,

Megumi: And Robin, the son of Batman, she's Sachi, Toomi and I'm Megumi.

Sachi: And it's our job to analyse their weapons, armor and skills to find out who would win a Death Battle

Nightwing backflips into What if Battles

<Cue: Bad Boy by Red Velvet>

Toomi: Dick Grayson was a twelve-year-old acrobat who is of the Flying Grayson, trained in acrobatics from birth.

Sachi: While on tour in Gotham City, Dick overheard a infamous crime lord Tony Zucco extorting the circus owner for protection money

Megumi: But they refused which unfortunately, causes their deaths after their zeppelin was sabotaged. So Dick was forced to watch his parents die.

<Shows footages of Dick witnessing his parent's death>

Toomi: But fortunately for him, Dick was soon adopted by Bruce Wayne, who just so happens to be the Caped Crusader, Batman.

Sachi: Eventually winning his mentor over to let him help him as his crime-fighting partner: Robin, the Boy Wonder.

Megumi: And when the time comes, Dick eventually gave up the Robin mantle and became his own superhero, Nightwing, just like that really delicious wings.

Toomi: What wings?

Megumi: These wings called Plague Knights, but I'd like to call them Knight Wings.

Toomi: Moving on, Dick is a prodigious natural athlete, possessing a peak human level of agility, strength, endurance from undergoing a vigorous and intensive training regimen under Batman.

Sachi: His genius intellect allows him to understanding various sciences that allows him to build his own gadgets and equipment. He's also a trained detective, expert interrogator and escape artist.

Megumi: Nightwing's uniform is made of a Nomex fire-resistant, triple-weave Kevlar-lined material. It is an excellent protection against damage, and it's also electrically insulated. The suit is designed to be light sensitive, darkening when there is more light in the area.

Nightwing

Expert acrobat

Peak human physique

Mastered over 10 martial arts

Aikido

Capoeira

Judo

Ninjutsu

Detective training

Escapology expert

Stealth mastery

Firearms expertise

Computer hacking

Triple-weave Kevlar suit

Domino Mask

GPS, thermal vision, electromagnetic wave scanner

10,000 volt electric shock

Gauntlets

Eskrima sticks

50,000 volt tasers

Wing Dings

Smoke pellets

Grapple Gun

Lockpicks

Wrist Darts

Toomi: He also has his Nightwing Gauntlets. Each gauntlet's sections can contain a wide array of equipment, such as sonic or smoke pellets, modified batarangs, knockout gas capsules and throwing tracers. The right gauntlet is also equipped with a 100,000-volt stun gun.

Sachi: Dick Grayson has always been deemed as one of the greatest human acrobat in the DC universe, being able to do a quadruple somersault.

Megumi: He has also defeated most of the skilled martial artists, especially Red Hood, Deathstroke, Cassandra Cain, Bronze Tiger, disarmed Wonder Woman with a batarang and even pulled a Batman on Batman. Oh and he even became Batman himself.

Feats

Founding member of the Teen Titans.

Succeeded Bruce Wayne as Batman after his presumed death

Beats the crap out of Batman proclaiming that he isn't his boy

He snuck up on and actually harmed Batman who had the powers of Superman at the time

Generally regarded as the greatest human acrobat in the DC universe, being able to do a quadruple somersault.

Defeated Jason Todd despite being electrocuted, taking Scarecrow's fear gas, and taking multiple bat tranquilizers to the face

Was one of the candidates to take Abin Sur's place as Green Lantern until Hal Jordan beat him to it

Breaks free from the jaws of a Killer Whale, which can deliver a bite force of 19,000 PSI one of the strongest in the animal kingdom

Takes down KGBeast

Dodges multiple sniper rounds

Just for fun, solves 4 cases on America's Most Wanted in a single morning

Stalemates Cassandra Cain, one of the best martial artists in the world and daughter of Lady Shiva

An enraged teenage Dick Grayson dodges a maze full of lasers

Hits Gorilla Grodd hard enough with his escrima sticks to make him bleed

Stalemates Azrael in a sword duel

Dodges machine gun fire from a SWAT team despite being cornered

As Robin disarms Wonder Woman of her sword with a Batarang

Dominates Bronze Tiger who is skilled enough to give Batman a hard time

Survived being shot in the back of his head by a .32 bullet

Before he became Robin he solved a riddle that Batman himself couldn't

Defeats Arsenal, the protegee of Green Arrow and one of the best marksmen in the DC Universe

With the clues left behind at Wayne Manor, he deduced that Batman is trapped in time

Is stated by Scarecrow that his willpower is second only to Batman and is officially second only to Batman as a martial artist

Dodges 200 rounds per minute from a flying gunmen

Bested Ra's Al Ghul in a sword duel, who has stalemated Batman himself multiple times

Impaled on his side and is still able to defeat the White Knight

Was able to find his way out of a maze before The Flash could

Intercepts Two-Face's coin with a Batarang before it could land back in his palm

Pulls a Batman on Batman

Was able to restrain a superhuman Talon with one foot while fighting off several minions of the Court of Owls at the same time

Sneaks up on and away from the speedster Jesse Quick, and proved difficult to find despite Jesse actively looking for him for over an hour

Defeats Deathwing, his alternate evil self

Solves a mystery before Batman could, impressing him

Dominates the superhuman mercenary Deathstroke

Was able to dodge gunfire from Slade who can think and react faster than a normal human and is a master marksmen

Makes Scarecrow talk, impressive since Crane states that he fears only Batman

Defeats a Talon by impaling his escrima stick into the brain, disabling the Talon's healing factor

Solves a homicide case that remained unsolved for 15 years

Sort of a chick magnet

Holds his own against a Batman clone created by Darkseid's new god scientist Dessad, who has all of the original Batman's skill and physical abilities and had just taken a dip into the Lazarus Pit granting him superhuman physicality and temporarily making him insane

Arguably one of the strongest non-metahumans in the DC universe, from taking out opponents larger than himself to knocking out the likes of Cinderblock.

Toomi: It's even more impressive to note is that Nightwing was even deemed worthy to be a Green Lantern by Abin Surr, only to lose out to Hal Jordan.

Megumi: Man, talk about a protege.

Toomi: However his time with Batman does ends up forcing him to live under his shadow, which causes him to become desperate to proof to Batman that he is more than a sidekick.

Sachi: And he's pretty much one hundred percent human, having the same weakness as any normal man.

Weakness

Same weaknesses as any other mortal man

As Robin, Dick's small frame and lack of power was a weakness. Despite his intense training with Batman, he usually had to resort to dodging attacks from superhuman foes, rather than taking them head-on like other sturdier heroes.

Despite being a team leader, the reasons ranging from his immature and childish overconfidence to his experience as Batman's sidekick, he has a lack of conventional teamwork and runs off abruptly to either scout ahead or perform some other sort of task

He is incredibly impulsive and desperate to prove himself

Reckless and takes life-threatening situations quite lightly

It was once blackmailed to go to a dance with the daughter of killer moth, Kitty

Despite wanting to separate himself from his mentor, he is just as distrusting to others as Batman is

Gets his arm broken, like a lot.

Humiliated by Harley Quinn

He was killed by Batman

Toomi: And despite his effort to separate himself away from Batman, his distrust of others and his stubborness ironically makes him no different from his former mentor

Sachi: And Dick Grayson is a big ladies man. Literally, to the point he was even blackmailed into dating Killer Moth's daughter, Kitten.

Killer Moth: Will you take this lovely young lady to her junior prom?

Kitten: Hi Robbie Poo!

Megumi: Oh. Well, guess you can't argue with the ass on that Dick. I mean seriously, Nightwing's really got some ass!

Starfire: Robin?

Nightwing: I haven't used that name in a long time. Call me...Nightwing.

Red Hood is loaded up for a What if Battle

<Cue: Blame It On You by Charlie XCX>

Toomi: I'm sure you all know of Batman and Robin, the Dynamic Duo who teams up to stop crime in all of Gotham.

Megumi: But one of these days, the Robin eventually has to leave the nest and become a superhero. Man, what a Dick. Get it? Dick Grayson a Dick?

Sachi:...Not funny Megumi

Toomi: Anyway, after Dick Grayson left, Batman eventually found a boy by the name of Jason Todd who was trying to steal his tyres.

Megumi: And so once again, Batman adopted another kid and made him a new Robin.

Dick: So you're his new Robin eh?

Jason: In the flesh.

Sachi: However, despite being talented and skilled, Jason is rather impulsive, arrogant and possesses an explosive temper, going too far during his crusades.

Toomi: And this recklessness would result in him being captured and killed by the Joker.

Joker: Hey, I never asked. What's the big secret? Who is the big, bad Bat? His name. Tell me.

Jason: Of course sir, it's...

<Before Jason could finish, Joker suddenly spun around and he opens fire, ending Jason's life right there>

Megumi: Damn. Little Robin's been through so much.

Toomi: However, Jason was resurrected thanks to the Lazarus Pit and after knowing that Batman has never thought of looking for him or even avenging him, Jason went under a new identity as the Red Hood, a gun wielding vigilante determined to kill Batman.

Red Hood: Ready to dance with the devil?

Batman: Think I haven't planned for this?

Red Hood: Let's see you bleed.

Sachi: But eventually, Red Hood then reconciled with the bat-family and has formed the "Dark Trinity" together with his new allies Bizarro and Artemis.

Toomi: Being a Robin under Batman, Jason was taught a large number of martial arts involving those like Ninjutsu, Krav Maga, Judo, Boxing, All-Caste and many more. And his training with the League of Assassins further enhances his combat skills.

Megumi: And being under Batman means that the kid is also really smart, able to perform acrobatics and even high pain tolerance.

Sachi: And as the Red Hood, he carries a range of weapons ranging from dual handguns, shurikens, bolas, knives, grenades and a bulletproof vest which is also a taser.

Toomi: But Red Hood's most important feature is his helmet, which protects his head from gunfire, gas and knives. It also has a a built-in radio transmitter, starlite night vision lenses, built-in breathalyzer and built-in explosives which Jason can detonate

Red Hood

Weapon Master

Marksmanship

Tactical Analysis

Intimidation

Peak Human Physiological Abilities

Stealth

Master Martial Artist

Training under Batman (as Robin II)

Additional martial arts (post-Robin II)

League of assassins

All-Caste

Has a punch taught by the All Caste that removes someone's powers and immortality

Indomitable Will

Master Escape Artist

Master Acrobatics

Genius Level Intellect

Resistant to many forms of mind control and toxins

High tolerance for pain

Can fight blind

Zip-Kick

Dual Handguns

Capable of piercing bulletproof armor

Hollow-point Armour-piecing shells (able to stop a tank)

Flashbang, gas, and shrapnel grenades

Grapnel Gun

Taser

Shurikens

Bolas

Sticky explosives

Combat Knives

Sharp enough to cut Batman's grappling cable

Red Hood Helmet

Offers protection from knives, gunfire, and gas

Has a built-in radio transmitter/receiver

Starlite night vision lenses

Built-in breathalyzer

Has built-in explosives which Jason can detonate

Bulletproof armor with a built-in taser

Pair of magical "All-blades"

Materialized whenever he wants

Can match up against the Swords of Hephaestus

Electric gliding wings

Japanese military-grade cyber-armor arm blades

Wrist-mounted lasers

Has access to a specific type of venom like Banes although it is much stronger and does not turn him into a huge, mindless beast

Toomi: With all his wits and weapons, Red Hood is a very deadly assassin, being able to take down and kill multiple opponents without any assistance.

Megumi: He has even bested Batman, Red Robin, Catwoman and Lady Shiva, held his own against Green Arrow and even threw down Bane, who weighs about 350 pounds. Oh and even a 600 pounds woman.

Sachi: Red Hood is even able to dodge alien bullets to the point that even Supergirl, who like we mentioned in Miss America vs Supergirl, can fly fast enough to keep up with the Flash, is actually impressed of his speed.

Toomi: And speaking of Supergirl, Red Hood has even broke out of her grip once, something that she mentions that no human is strong enough to do.

Feats

Orchestrated a masterful scheme to get his hands on the Joker by tricking Black Mask in freeing him by feigning a mob war.

Forces Lobo to his knees

Took down Lady Shiva in a single motion

Has assembled his team of anti-heroes (twice)

Founding member of the Outlaws

Was able to break out of Supergirl's grip (twice) who claims "no human is that strong" and even sneaks away from her despite her senses

Was able to hold his own against Green Arrow in a sword fight

Is respected by the League of Assassins

Was chosen to lead the League of Assassins if both Ra's and Talia al Ghul are out of the picture

Holds his own against Batman and Nightwing

Implies that he has been holding back in each one of his battles with Batman

Defeated Batman (Dick Grayson) and Robin (Tim Drake) alongside Scarlet

Held his own against Deathstroke and even defeated him, even though he wasn't trying to kill him

Collected the heads of several gangsters after killing them in merely 20 minutes

Has effortlessly flipped the 350 pounds Bane and 600-pound women over his shoulders

Gets the crap beaten out of him by Batman and even gets pushed through several layers of walls and is perfectly fine

Immobilized the Teen Titans

Defeated Tim Drake and Catwoman

Killed an alternate universe Joker

Held up the roof of a broken building

His kick makes Deathstroke fly

Fast enough to dodge rockets and laser fire

Kicked off an airplane door

Punches through the hull of a military submarine

Fought a SWAT team while naked

Fought a large group of Talons by himself

Outruns a man on a vehicle

Weaves in-between alien bullets and Supergirl compliments him on his speed and skill

Takes on a group of Venom users

Can shoot accurately on moving peoples' feet

Can quick-shot before gunmen could react

Can shoot faster than a man moving on a hi-tech motorcycle

Beats Batman in a fistfight and takes his car

Dodges Batgirl's Batarang

Calms down a new released Bizarro

Resists mind control from H.I.V.E

Survives an explosion by a bazooka

Dodges Deathstroke's fire and Victor's sniper fire

Beats Mr. Freeze and a Talon at the same time

Breaks out of chains set by the League of Assassin's, says they're a joke

Beats up a large group of Shiva trained Man-Bats

Fought through the GCPD SWAT team with only shower pole

Fought Ravager to a stalemate

Beats a godly powered Ra's al Ghul in a sword duel

Beats a group of alien constructs in seventeen seconds

Uses agility to survive a fall Supergirl thought would kill him

Has been shown taking down multiple opponents unaided and single-handedly bested an Untitled, powerful beings with superhuman physical attributes, a healing factor and nigh immunity to conventional pain

Fought off joker's paralytic toxin through sheer force of will

Faster fighter than Tim Drake

Withstood blow after blow with a crowbar from The Joker

Defeats Joker's Daughter despite having a gun at his head

Easily takes on Meta Humans such as Man-Bat

Took down a gang while constantly dodging bullets fired from 30 different places

Easily stood up after getting thrown into a building, cracking the concrete

Bad mouthed to Helspont, a super-villain who casually gave Superman a concussion

Toomi: Red Hood has even took a massive amount of beatings, endured endless blows from the Joker's crowbar, shrugged off getting thrown into a building and even survived an explosion from a bazooka.

Megumi: Oh! And did I mention that Red Hood even orchestrated a masterful scheme to get his hands on the Joker by tricking Black Mask in freeing him by feigning a mob war.

Toomi: However, as tough as Red Hood is, Red Hood is still an ordinary human, possessing no superhuman level strength and durability.

Sachi: And his Helmet, though is tough, special metals like the once Talon used are strong enough to destroy it.

Weakness

He is still only human

While his iconic Red Hood helmet is resistant against most bladed weapons and bullets, daggers with special metals like ones used by the Talons can crack it

Has been blown up before his resurrection

Prone to rage initially upon the resurrection

Most violent and ruthless member of the Batman Family

Nearly killed by Flamingo

Overconfident and arrogant

Was defeated by Dick Grayson in a battle of obtaining the mantle of Batman

Toomi: But Jason's greatest weakness is anger. After enduring endless torture from the Joker and even died. The trauma and hatred gained even turned Red Hood into the most violent and bloodlusted member of the Batfamily.

Megumi: But when Red Hood finds the Joker, he is gonna do what Batman always fails to do, kill him.

Batman: I don't want to fight you.

Red Hood: All evidence to the contary.

Batman: Please, I can help you. I know what happened.

Red Hood: Oh! You got to talk in grace huh? But does it make it easier for you to think that my little dip in his 'Fountain of Youth' turned me rabid? Or is this just the real me?

Red Robin out thinks What if Battles

<Cue: 2U by David Guetta feat Justin Bieber>

Toomi: Timothy Jackson Drake was the son of businessman Jack Drake and Janet Drake, normally left behind in boarding school in Gotham while his parents traveled the world.

Sachi:  But Tim's parents have attempted to bond with their son, taking Tim to the circus where Tim met and befriended Dick Grayson. Around the age of 9, Tim began to idolize Batman and placed newspaper clippings on his wall.

Megumi: In the aftermath of Jason Todd's death, a teenage Tim saw the downward spiral Batman is taking from the event and offers himself to become the third Robin.

Toomi: Though turned down, Tim did not take no for answer and nearly got himself killed by provoking The Penguin.

Megumi: Ayy, typical kids, always getting themselves into trouble. But Batman eventually took him in though many events ends up scarring poor Tim.

Sachi: When Batman forbade Tim from donning the Robin costume ever again, Drake moved to Bludhaven to escape his demons while reinventing himself as Red Robin of the Teen Titans.

Toomi: Tim has the conditioning of an agile athlete and the smarts of a computer genius.

Megumi: While primary trained by Batman, Tim was trained by others in the various martial art styles ofninjutsu, karate, judo, jujutsu, aikido, Wing Chun, Shaolin Kung Fu, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, and Jeet Kune Do.

Toomi: But his preferred fighting style is bojutsu, which is the use of a bo staff to parry, counter and strike at his enemies.

Red Robin

Agility

Bojutsu

Jujutsu

Aikido

Karate

Judo

Jeet-Jutsu

Birdarangs

Bo Staff

Great Intelligience

Expert Detective Skills

Explosive Pellets

Toomi: With his knowledge, Tim Drake is certainly not known as the World Greatest Detective for nothing, at the age of nine, he figured out Bruce Wayne's identity as Batman and even offered himself up to be the third Robin.

Megumi: He's even smart enough to figured out the identities of many other heroes like Huntress, Wildcat and can even stalk Batgirl and Nightwing for days without them noticing.

Sachi: It doesn't just stop there, Red Robin's is also strong enough to defeat Damian Wayne, beats down multiple goons while his vision impaired and even defeated King Snake, who is literally the father of Bane

Feats

Member of the Teen Titans.

Member of Young Justice.

Member of Batman Incorporated.

Figured out Batman and the first Robin's identities from seeing the latter's movements at the age of nine.

Beat his mentor Lady Shiva in a sparring match involving stick fighting.

Foiled Ra's al Ghul's plan, becoming the second person the man called "Detective."

Respected by Dick Grayson as his equal.

Defeated Batman

Considered to be the smartest person to be called "World Greatest Detective"

Batman says he has the potential to be better than Nightwing

Alfred considers Tim more capable than Jason and Dick as Robin

Harm considers Robin the most dangerous member of Young Justice

Respected by Poison Ivy

Defeated King Snake

Early Robin beats Joker

Beats Bracuda a man who stalemated Catwoman in the previous issue

Casually dumpstered Eddie Fyers, a skilled mercenary who had many fights with Green Arrow

Beat Catwoman she also compliments his speed

Casually beats up Shen Chi, his former martial arts teacher

Defeats a mind controlled Prometheus although he does come back shortly after

Has the advantage on Jason Todd

Megumi: Damn, now this is one side kick I can get behind.

Toomi: However, Red Robin is not really perfect, mostly lacking back in terms of martial arts skills, relying on his intelligence to give him the upper hand in battle.

Sachi: And several missions as Robin ends up traumatizing him.

Weakness

Suffered countless trauma while as Robin.

Almost killed Clayface over him absorbing a piece of himself that developed a sense of self, considering it an act of "murder".

Felt betrayed that his friend Stephanie Brown faked her death.

Sometime after passing the Robin mantle to Damian Wayne, Tim ends up being captured by the Joker and was tortured for three weeks while subjected to a the Ha chemical created by the psychopath.

Toomi: And right after giving up his Robin mantle, Tim was captured and tortured by the Joker for three whole weeks

Sachi: And ironically, he ends up transforming into the Joker

<Shows footages of Tim transforming into Joker>

Megumi: I mean if someone as smart as Ras would admit that he is worthy enough to be his heir, then I'm sure Tim would be the best Robin there ever will be.

Red Robin: Sorry to bust in, but we couldn't wait to spoil your fun.

Robin slashes into What if Battles

<Cue: What Do You Want From Me by Forever the Sickest Kids>

Toomi: Damian Wayne is the illegitimate son of Bruce Wayne and Talia al Ghul, making him the grandson of Ra's al Ghul.

Megumi: Damian was raised by his mother for the first ten years of his life, trained to be a formidable warrior in the League of Shadows until that fateful meeting between father and son

Damian: Don't look so stunned father, I thought you'd be taller.

Sachi: Although misguided and malicious, Damian seems to genuinely want to aid his father's war on crime and became the current Robin.

Megumi: And he began leading the Teen Titans. Oh and in some futures, Damian became the new Batman.

Toomi: Having been trained by the League of Shadows since a toddler, Damian is more physically powerful than most adults and all his physical capabilities are peak human ability as seen in his agility, pain threshold, and overpowering larger opponents.

Sachi: Damian is surprisingly smart for his age with detective skills and a mastery of stealth. And he's a pretty good marksman.

<Shows footages of Damian tossing a bunch of rings, causing them to land on the top of the bottles.>

Megumi: He is a master of unarmed, melee and close quarter combat, capable of using any weapon he picks up

Sachi: But his most standard gear includes a katana, batarangs, sais and grappling hook.

Damian Wayne

Martial Arts Skills

Skilled Tactician

Peak Human Endurance

Katana

Sai

Batarangs

Grappling hooks

Spiked brass knuckles

Robin mask with assorted lenses for various situations.

Toomi: But whether it is with weapons or without, do not be fooled by his appearance for as a toddler, Damian has beheaded a tiger.

Sachi: He's also strong enough to beat down numerous enemies, render a man brain dead with his punches, and if you are asking, yes. He was holding back

Feats

Beheaded a tiger while a toddler

Renders a man brain dead with his punches while holding back

Beats down Ubu

Hacked the Bat-Computer, also hacked into government mainframes at age 8.

Current member of the Teen Titans.

Holds his own against a pissed off Tim Drake

Evades all security cameras in Gotham

Easily identified his father before he met him

Solves the Gyroscopic Array that frustrated even the Worlds Greatest Detective himself

Beats Jason Todd through psychological warfare and fighting dirty

Can defeat Deathstroke, Ra's Al Ghul, and his own father in a battle

Becomes a mentor figure to Terry McGinnis in the distant future.

Killed Victor Zsacz

Megumi: And not to mention, Damian has beaten Deathstroke, Ra's Al Ghul and even Batman himself. Damn, the blood really runs deep in the family.

Toomi: And speaking of families, Damian also possesses his father's mistrust upon others, with causes him to be rather distant and sometimes his stubborness even exceeds Batman himself.

Sachi: He's also rather egotistical, rude and also very blunt.

Weakness

Entitled, egotistical, condescending, rude, and blunt in his opinions.

Extremely cocky and arrogant

Can be murderous when he loses his temper.

Ultimately only trusts himself and is even more stubborn and untrusting than his father

Underestimated Blue Beetle in a sparring match that nearly killed him.

Megumi: But as far as Damian has shown, spending the rest of his childhood with Batman really helped changed him into a better person.

Deathstroke: Talia would have been mine, until your father came along!

Damian: He created something special, me!

Toomi: Alright, the combatants are set, let's end this debate once and for all.

Sachi: Don't forget to vote, comment what you think of the fight.

Megumi: Yeah, but right now, it's time for a Death Battle!

Fight

Wayne Tower, rooftop

<Cue: Bored by Tessa Violet>

On the top of Wayne Tower, Nightwing, Red Hood, Red Robin and Robin sat together, staring at the dark starrry sky.

For some strange reason, all of Gotham seems to be...peaceful.

No armed robberies, no gang wars, not even Killer Croc or Bane spreading menace across the city.

For once, everything seems to be normal.

Feeling bored, Red Robin leans in onto Red Hood and he asks meekly.

Red Robin: Hey, so what are we gonna do?

Red Hood: I don't know, what ya wanna do?

Annoyed, Red Robin then says.

Red Robin: Look Jason, first I say "What are we gonna do?" then you say " I don't know, what ya wanna do?". Then I say "What are we gonna do?"" I don't know, what ya wanna do?" Let's do something!

Nightwing twirls his baton before jumping up, declaring out.

Nightwing: I've got it! Why not let's see which one of us is truly the better Robin

Damian scoffs.

Robin: Seriously Dick? Come on! We all know I'm the best Robin.

Red Robin: Nuh uh! I believe that goes to me.

Red Robin disagrees.

Red Hood then stood up, saying.

Red Hood: Bah, no use talking, let's fight it out!

Nightwing: Heh! You've read my mind.

Nightwing holds up his batons, narrowing his eyes just as Red Hood loads up his dual pistols, at the same time, Red Robin twirls his bo staff whilst Robin brandishing his sword.

All four of Batman sidekicks faces each other, ready to prove their superiority over the other.

Announcer: Fight!

<Cue: Bang Bang by Jessie J, Ariana Grande and Nicki Minaj>

BANG!!! BANG!!! BANG!!!

Red Hood opens fire, forcing all three of his teammates to move.

Nightwing jumps over Red Hood before throwing a kick right into Robin, striking him in the gut.

WHAM!!!

Robin staggers back, narrowing his eyes as he swings his blade upwards, slashing right at Nightwing.

CLANG!!! CLANG!!! CLANG!!!

At the same time, Red Robin shuffles across the ground, dodging every gunshot before leaning forward, swinging his bo staff right at Red Hood.

PAK!!!

Red Hood raises up his arm, shielding himself from the attack before swinging his elbow up, striking Red Robin in the chin.

WHAM!!!

Red Robin: GAHHHH!!!

As Red Robin staggers back, Red Hood sprints forward, only for Red Robin to throw a smoke pellet down onto the floor.

BOOM!!!

Red Hood: Cough! Cough!

Red Hood coughs out, his eyes scanning through his visor as he surveys the area for his opponent.

At that moment, something moves past him, striking Red Hood by the back.

WHAM!!!

Red Hood: YAAAHHHHH!!!

Red Hood then pulls out a shotgun, swinging the butt across Red Robin's cheek.

WHAM!!!

While Red Hood and Red Robin are locked in battle, Robin throws several batarangs across, forcing Nightwing to somersault across the floor, dodging the projectiles.

As Robin swings his sword, Nightwing shifts his body, dodging every swing before throwing his knee up, striking Robin in the chin.

WHAM!!!

As Robin is sent flyin, Nightwing throws multiple strikes across his body.

WHAM!!! BAM!!! POW!!!

Robin wipes the blood off his nose before lunging forward, swinging his blade across Nightwing's body.

SLASH!!!

Nightwing: Ngn!

However, right at that moment, Nightwing swings his elbow up, striking Robin under the chin.

As Robin staggers back, Nightwing swings his baton across Damian's sword, cracking the tip before slamming it right into his body.

SHOK!!!

Robin: ARGHHHHH!!!

Robin coughs out blood before dropping onto the floor, dead.

KO!

Meanwhile, Red Robin launches himself up into the air, dodging every gunshot before landing feet first onto a generator.

Red Hood throws several shurikens upwards, only for Red Robin to spin his bo staff around, rapidly deflecting the projectiles.

Clak! Clak! Clak!

Red Robin backflips over, narrowingly dodging a kick from Red Hood.

However, right as Red Robin lands feet first onto the ground, Nightwing tosses his baton across, striking Red Robin by the back of his head.

BAM!!!

Red Robin: ARGHHHHH!!!

As Red Robin staggers forward, Red Hood took that opportunity to open fire onto the helpless Robin, firing seemingly endless shots of bullets at him.

BANG!!! BANG!!! BANG!!!

Red Robin: YAAAHHHHHH!!!

Red Robin screams out in agony before collapsing onto the floor, dead.

KO!

With both Red Robin and Robin dead, Red Hood and Nightwing walks across the roof top, facing each other.

Red Hood: So it's just you and me now huh?

Nightwing: Yup.

Both Red Hood and Nightwing faces each other before Red Hood swings his arm out, throwing several batarangs at him.

Nightwing spins his batons, deflecting the projectiles before throwing one of them at Red Hood, only for the latter to catch it right into his hand.

Before Nightwing could react, Red Hood lunges forward, throwing the baton square into Nightwing's nose.

PAK!!!

However, right at that moment, Nightwing ducks down and he swings his legs out, striking Red Hood behind the knee.

As Red Hood fall forward, Nightwing throws his elbow up, striking up square in the head.

WHAM!!!

Angered Red Hood slams his head down, the tip of his helmet slamming Nightwing square in the nose.

As Nightwing staggers backwards, Red Hood points a gun at him, questioning out.

Red Hood: Any last words?

Nightwing smirks, saying.

Nightwing: Yeah. This.

Before Red Hood could react, Nightwing swings his leg out, kicking the gun out of Red Hood's hands.

Red Hood: What?!

BZZZTTT!!!

Powerful surges of electricity forms along Nightwing's gauntlet as he throws powerful punch, striking Red Hood hard in the face.

BAM!!!

Red Hood's entire head went off into an explosion of blood and gore, collapsing onto the ground as Nightwing says to himself.

Nightwing: Welp. There's that.

KO!

<Cue: Forever In My Dreams by Really Slow Motion>

Megumi: Man, Dick what have ya done?

Toomi: This battle was very close as each Robin has an edge over the others. Dick Grayson was the fastest, most durable and has the best experience, Jason Todd was the most armored, Tim Drake was the smartest and Damian Wayne got the best training but he's hasty and he had the least experience.

Sachi: And that's why he died first.

Toomi: You see, Damian's recklessness caused him to lose multiple battles, and against someone like Dick Grayson, who has matched Bane and Batman and has a superior speed, someone like Jason Todd who got a superior arsenal and someone like Tim Drake who could use Damian's recklessness against him and outsmart him, he simply didn't stand a chance.

Megumi: And though Red Robin's analytical brain and intelligence certainly gave him the edge, his fighting style however is nothing compared to Red Hood's.

Sachi: Mainly due to the fact that Red Hood spent a huge amount of time battling enemies of all sorts, especially since he has broken the grip of Supergirl just proves he has the strength and combat advantage over Tim.

Megumi: And mainly his use of weaponary which are more than capable of taking Red Robin down.

Toomi: But the real fight happens between both Nightwing and Red Hood. Now both Robins certainly have taken each other down before, defeated Batman in battle and have their fair share of battles against all kinds of enemies.

Megumi: But having done the superhero act even longer than Red Hood, along with his detective skills, Nightwing is able to figure out Red Hood's weakness and take advantage of it, especially since that's how he mostly deals with his opponents.

Sachi: Regardless, in terms of skills, all four of them received similar training, defeated many of the enemies in Gotham and even proved to Batman they are rather independent of him, but their strategies, experience and choice of weapons are another story.

Toomi: Having the advantage in experience, intelligence and combat ability, we can hereby declare that Nightwing is the true Robin of them all

Megumi: Quite sad that he was just Robin the rest of their wings. Man, what a dick

Sachi: The winner is Nightwing

Nightwing: Now that was crash.

Toomi: Hey guys, thank you so much for checking out our battle in What if Battles 2.

Sachi: If you want more content like this, don't forget to add this in your library and comment if you have any idea for a fight.

Megumi: Until then, next time on What if Battles....

Up Next

Dr. Jack Griffin

VS

Leatherface

VS

Rena Ryugu

VS

Chris Walker

Psychopathic Killer Battle Royale

Trivia

* The connections between Nightwing, Red Hood, Red Robin and Robin is that all four combatants are young boys who were raised by Batman, going through training and undergoing his mentorship whilst carrying the Robin mantle. The four eventually became their own superheroes, carrying their own titles and wielding their own signature weapons

* The four also seems to have a rather edgy relationship with Batman

* This is the first time a DC character fights a DC character

* This is the thirteenth time a DC character won a What if Battle, the first being Power Girl vs Cooler, Piccolo vs Martian Manhunter, Mercy vs Hawkgirl, Captain America vs Deathstroke, Ultron vs Cyborg Superman, Miss America vs Supergirl, Superman vs Saitama, Hulk vs Darkseid, Captain Marvel vs Green Lantern, Black Widow vs Batwoman, Punisher vs Red Hood and James Rogers vs Damian Wayne

* This is the tenth battle where a DC character loses a What if Battle, the first being Doomsday vs SCP-682, Ego vs Mogo, Toph vs Terra, Batman vs Sub-Zero, Catwoman vs Cassie Cage, Roman and Neo vs Joker and Harley Quinn, Spider-Gwen vs Batgirl, Gwenpool vs Harley Quinn and Black Manta vs Cyclops

* This is the first battle to be a four way battle royale with the previous battle royales being three ways

* This is also the first battle royale where all of the characters fights at the same time with the previous battle royales having new characters coming in halfway into the battle.

* The part where the Robins ask each other over what they want to do is a reference to the vulture scene from "The Jungle Book"

* Coeincidently, the fight soundtrack "Bang Bang" has the word "Robin" mentioned in the song.

* Both Red Hood and Robin were returning characters from previous What if Battles, with Punisher vs Red Hood for Red Hood and James Rogers vs Damian Wayne for Robin

* Coeincidently, the two emerged winners from both those battles only to end up losing in this match.