So let me explain what was the worst thing he did tell me beacause others did even worse he lost his sister his mate also who got his mate killed bluestar he was as loyal as loyal goes he fought for his clan how did he die by chasing out intruders he didn't even kill any of them Thistleclaw did nothing to go to the dark forest Bluestar broke a warrior code and she got to see her mate but not thistleclaw he did nothing I know your gonna say he chose to be there but I'm sure he wanted to be with his mom and sister and mate so did he deserve it tell me what I think he did to deserve it