THIS HAS NOT BEEN CONFIRMED JUST A THOUGHT

When comparing Ivypool and dovewing to ashfur and birchfall, some people think ashfur is the real father the kits since they have more so his looks over Birchfall.

Birchfall:  light brown tabby tom with amber eyes and
d glossy fur.

Ashfur: Pale gray tom with darker flecks and dark blue eyes.

Dovewing: Pale smoky gray she-cat with blue or green eyes.

Ivypool: slender, soft-furred, pale, silver andwhite tabby she-cat. She has white paws, a white belly and face, a striped silver tail and dark blue eyes.

I mean if true then Ashfur got his wish to join the family in a weird sort of way but YAY!