Okay. After reading Pinestar's Choice, I'll admit that my opinion of him COMPLETELY changed.

I'll keep this short and sweet, but they gave him a good reason to leave, a good reason to abandon his son. While it wasn't the right choice in my opinion, it was reasonable and you could see why he did it.

And I LOVE a worrier. You might remember that it mentioned that fact in Alderheart's chapter.

To sum this short chapter up, he loved too much, and I have a huge soft spot for those kind of cats. Honestly, I really like Pinestar now.