Before we proceed with the results we have something important to announce:

We are limiting this war phase to just one round since everyone has exams going on and so the groups are backing down one by one. We'll start this again in March/April, this with better rules and newer strategies. 

And now the rubrics:

(Please do keep in mind that we have no intention to hurt anyone. Our remarks are for your betterment and we hope you take it that way!)

Designpolis

Graphic Quality: 7/10
Originality/Creativity: 15/20
Color Scheme/Contrast: 6/10
Font selection: 7/10
Text placement: 8/10
Blending/Manips: 16/20
Relevence to Genre/Summary: 6/10
Overall impression: 15/20
Individual involvement: 10/10
Group work: 16/20

Total: 106/140

The quality of your covers could've been better specially of 'The Coming of Hope'. All three are definitely creative in their own corners although they doesn't seems relevant to each other. For example, 'The Coming of Hope' and 'The Sun of Yesterday' highlights wings so you could've done that with the 'Conjured Chaos' as well which would've reflect your group work and also the connection between the three since it's a trilogy series. The colors are too bright in 'The Sun of Yesterday' which only makes the other two appear dull so you could've chosen a universal color palette just so it doesn't looks messy. The text placement is done neatly although the font chosen for 'Conjured Chaos' could've been different or in a different colour since it doesn't really highlights in the cover and is getting blended with the cover. So, to make it more visible you could've done a better job with it. I really liked how you've decided to do something different than the usual covers, but if we talk about your plot, it doesn't connects that much with it. With this plot, you could've done something real good trilogy based because it was real good. Overall, the one thing that backfired with your team was the connection between the three covers. How 'Conjured Chaos' looks completely different with the other two and how 'The sun of Yesterday' is too bright than the others.

Designorama

Graphic Quality: 9/10
Originality/Creativity: 19/20
Color Scheme/Contrast: 9/10
Font selection: 10/10
Text placement: 9/10
Blending/Manips: 19/20
Relevence to Genre/Summary: 9/10
Overall impression: 19/20
Individual involvement: 9/10
Group work: 19/20

Total: 131/140

Can I say I love your covers? They are just fantastic. From the color scheme to the font, everything is apt and chosen absolutely to perfection. The quality is really amazing which let me look at everything very clearly, without any problem. How you connected your covers with the plot and genre was done perfectly and it reflected your creativity very well. I didn't know this could've been done this way, but you guys did a great job. I love how the three covers were relevant to each other, specially how your decided to use the similar face claim in all the three covers and also how your placed it. The font matched with the cover quality and theme very well and I really appreciate how you decided to use the same in all the three since it's a trilogy cover and would obviously lessen down it's messiness. The blending was up to mark, however I would suggest you do some more with the manakin part in 'Blood Manakin' since it looks a bit odd, considering it's color. How you people connected each cover with it's title was a good move. I don't know how you managed to do the font and placement in perfection and similar to each other or what was each team member's role, but the end result came out amazing with your team.

Designqueue

Graphic Quality: 8/10
Originality/Creativity: 17/20
Color Scheme/Contrast: 8/10
Font selection: 7/10
Text placement: 7/10
Blending/Manips: 18/20
Relevence to Genre/Summary: 8/10
Overall impression: 17/20
Individual involvement: 10/10
Group work: 19/20

Total: 119/140

Your covers overall are a good impression of Trilogy series. Since the color scheme is similar in all the three, I love the fact how it connected the three covers and how the contrast worked with your bluish tone. The quality of 'The Whispering Voyage' is amazing and I love how the blending was done with the hair and the face which didn't lower down its quality. It was really creative. However, in 'The Wallowing Shacks' the quality could've been better since the blending and placement done of objects in left side is a bit messy and not that clear, but I love the placement of text and choice of font in that one as I was able to read and understand it from a good distance. In 'The Weeping Shards' I absolutely loved the wolf blending and the cracks of mirror just in the centre. It was a good move and the template was amazing. However, the font of 'The Weeping, could've been chosen better as it's not visible clearly and the word Shards is completely disrupted as you placed it between those cracks. Also, the watermark was almost not visible with the author's name as well. My impression about thus cover would be good, more in positive side as the team work was amazing and individual involvement was also up to the mark. Each one of you did a lot of work so, great teamwork.

THE WIINERS ARE: Designorama

Others please don't be disheartened. If anything you guys should be proud that you aced your group graphic war! It was a joy hosting this. We hope you enjoyed too!

Any suggestions you wanna give? Drop them here →