Watching as the bottle stopped, my eyes gazed up at the quiet man sitting near me. "If you give me anything stupid--" Puppeteer growls, crossing his arms.

"So it's a dare then?" I smirked, raising a brow. He didn't say anything as he looks away from me. "Dare it is! I dare you to do the cinnamon challenge~" I chirped, clapping my hands together.

"Oh, so Jeff did it first, and now you want me to do it?" Puppet sighs, running his hand over his face as he stands.

Everyone watched as he floated towards the kitchen and disappeared.

"You have to do it so everyone can see!" I shouted, cupping my hands around my mouth. Some people started to snicker as we heard Puppeteer muttering under his breath before he floated back out into the living room with a spoonful of cinnamon.

"I hate all of you." He coughs, putting a spoon full of cinnamon in his mouth. We all waited to see his reaction, but inside of leaving the cinnamon on his tongue, he decided to swallow it.

"That wasn't a smart move, bro." Jeff pointed out, cringing.

Puppet dismissed us with a smile on his face. 

"Talk, I dare you." Sally glares, as if she were taking revenge on him. Puppeteer went to open his mouth, but the cinnamon began to rise back up his throat, causing him to cover his mouth and run to the bathroom.

"I warned you." Jeff sighs, shaking his head.

~~~

Seeing that I accidentally spun the bottle too hard, it hit against Masky's foot before it stopped. "Maybe you should take it easy on the bottle, (Y/n)." The proxy states, glancing up at me.

"Sorry." I gave him an awkward smile before seeing who the bottle was pointed at. "Candy Pop! Truth or Dare?" I smiled, sitting up straighter.

"How about dare?~" He wiggles his fingers around, chewing on a piece of Halloween candy.

"I got a good one... I dare you to kiss Jason." I snickered, crossing my arms as Candy Pop's smile fell.

"You're-You're joking... right?"

Shaking my head, I pointed at the Toymaker that was sitting next to him.

"It's a dare~ Unless you wanna be known as the chicken!" I purred, everyone around me began making chicken noises, causing me to chuckle.

"That's not going to happen!" Candy glares at me with a frown on his face.

"Then do the dare~ It's easy." I waved my hand in the air, seeing Candy's cheeks getting red.

"Fine" He pouts, turning towards the Toymaker.

"I know you're not going to forgive me." He states, making Jason glare at him. Candy wasted no time and quickly placed his lips on Jason's. A simmer of green began to swirl around in Jason's eyes before Candy broke the kiss. "You didn't kiss back." The jester complains, causing Jason to slap him upside the head. "Ow"