Zara's pov

    After shaking Silent’s hand, I spotted Eyeless Jack closely behind. “Yum!” He muttered,licking his lips. “EJ you can't eat her organs” scolded Silent. “Aww” said EJ as he left the room. “Sorry about that. EJ loves to taste visitors organs. Hey nice hair” said Silent. “Aww thanks!” I said smiling.

    “So, how long have you been dating Toby?” Asked Silent. “Um...were not d-dating. At least not yet.” I said nervously. “Oh come on! No need to hide it! I'm dating EJ. Toby doesn't just dance with anyone.” “Um well, Toby has been very protective of me.” I said, gesturing to my side wound. “OMG who did that to you!?” Asked Silent. “Hoodie!” I said coldly, I think he's after me. But I can't find Masky.” I explained. Silent shook her head. “ Well don't worry I'll let everyone else know that they can't kill you. Ziggy will probably do the same too.” She said as she swung her arm around me.

    “For now, I recommend you stay and eat dinner with us. That way you can meet everyone.” Said Silent, as she guided me to the dining room…...When we arrived, I felt tons of pairs of eyes lay onto me. I saw a lot of creepypastas that I recognized, and tons that I didn't. I decided to sit next to to Silent and Slenderman, that way if anyone tried to kill me, they would stop them.

    As I looked around, I realized that everyone already had food in front of them. Suddenly I heard a crash, and spotted Jeff the Killer run after the tiger named Ziggy. She was carrying a small knife in her mouth. She sprinted underneath the table, and Jeff tried to follow. “GIVE ME BACK MY KNIFE!!” he screamed, before trying to bolt underneath the table after Ziggy.

    Slenderman grabbed one of Jeff's legs and dragged him out from under the table. “ No horseplay at the table!!” He scolded Jeff. “Ziggy took my knife!!” Complained Jeff. Slenderman whistled, and Ziggy came out from under the table. “Hand me the knife please.” Asked Slenderman, as he held his hand out. Ziggy made a huge and dropped the weapon in his hand. “Good girl!” Praised Slendy, before chucking the knife behind him. Jeff freed himself from Slenderman's grip and ran to catch it.

    After getting his weapon, Jeff stuffed it in his pocket and sat in a chair next to one of Slenderman's brothers who was sitting across from me. Silent watched me look at everyone eat. “Aren't you gonna eat your food!?” She asked. I shook my head, and sighed. “Where's Toby and Masky!?” I asked. Silent laughed. “I'm surprised you didn't ask where Hoodie is, given that might kill you at any more moment.” She laughed. “ Don't worry Zara, We’ll protect you from harm.” Assured Silent, as she and Ziggy leaned protectively on me.

    “What's for dinner!?” Asked Toby as he suddenly appeared in the doorway. “Toby!” I cheered happily,as I ran to hug him. Toby smiled, and walked with me as we sat next to Silent. Toby eyed Ziggy, who was devouring some raw steak next to Slenderman. “I thought you said no pets at the table!” He joked. Slenderman gestured to Ziggy, who was barely making a mess. “She's an exception.” He said plainly…..

Toby's pov

As I sat next to Zara, something had me concerned. She wasn't eating anything,she wasn't even drinking. “You ok?” I asked. She smiled slightly, and leaned her head on my shoulder. “Um I guess…” She mumbled. “Please tell me.” I begged, worried that something serious was going on. Zara turned her head to face me and Silent, tears streamed down her face.

    Before me or Silent could comfort her, Sally got up from her chair and approached Zara, Ziggy was following behind. “Do you want to hug my teddy? When I'm sad he comforts me.” Asked Sally sweetly,as she gestured to her stitched up Teddy bear. Zara nodded and gently took the teddy bear and gave it a small squeeze. “I m-miss C-arrie!” She sobbed.

    I slowly put my arms around her. “I'm sorry to say this,but their wasn't anything I could do to save her. Zara sniffed, and began to pet Ziggy,who was now parly laying in Zara's lap. “Don't worry I'll make sure Hoodie and Masky apologize.” I assured her. “No need to, I'm…. sorry Zara. It was either you or her,and I saw how Toby’s face lit up when he first saw you.” spoke a familiar gruff voice from an open window.

    We all turned to see Masky climb swiftly through the window,and approach Zara and me. “Masky! You came back.” Said Slenderman, as if he expected Masky to come through the window...