It was the same night after the last challenge, and you were still outside the cabin, just enjoying a soda by the beach.

???: Hey Y/n.

You look to your left and see Lindsay behind you with a box behind her back.

Y/n: Lindsay...what's the box for?.

Lindsay: I-It's for you.

You take the box from Lindsay and open it up, inside it was a bunch of your favorite things.

Y/n: Gaming magazines, punko flops, cowboy kid's old time style root beer, fried chicken-

Lindsay: Yep it's all your favorite things in one box-

Y/n: How do you know all my favorite things-

Lindsay: Remember I was a huge fan of your tv show, and when I found a clip online of what you really liked...I may have ordered some stuff for you in case I got to meet you-

Y/n: But I was an intern, just pulled out of thin air for the show because they miscounted...how did you get this stuff anyway.

You take a swig of the root beer and Lindsay smiles.

Lindsay: I may have found this stuff in Area 51-

You spit out the root beer and look at the blonde who takes your hand and holds it in hers.

Lindsay: Y/n...do you remember our date?.

Y/n: Yes?.

Lindsay: Well...I...I was wondering if I could be your girlfri-

Y/n: Lindsay I'm with Harley remember?.

Lindsay: But it's not even fair, she came onto the show out of nowhere, just to boost ratings and cause drama.

Y/n: And she seems to be doing a good job at it.

Lindsay looks down sad.

Lindsay:...Can I at least get a kiss?.

Y/n: Lindsay...

Lindsay: Please just one, I got this stuff for you, I could at least get a kiss.

You sigh and nod.

Y/n: True, and I like all this stuff...Alright, one kiss.

Lindsay nods and smiles as she wraps her arms around your neck and kisses you on the lips...

Harley: Hey babe I brought you a drink because I thought you were thirsty...

Harley drops one of the drinks she was holding seeing you and Lindsay "making out"

Y/n: Harley...it's not what it seems like.

Harley:...

Y/n: Lindsay brought me this stuff because she was a fan of the show and asked to be with me, I said no because I was dating you and I love you so in return for the stuff she wanted a kiss-

Harley: And you gave it to her!.

Y/n: Well yeah, I mean she's a fan of the show I was on...and she's...

Harley: She's what...

Y/n:...She's hot-

Harley was now red with anger, she was wiping her feet on the sand like a damn bull.

Y/n: Okay Harls, just calm down, I gave her one kiss for her bringing me this stuff, that's all there is.

Harley: Give me the stuff...

Y/n: Wha-

Harley: GIVE ME THE STUFF.

You hand Harley the box and she looks at it.

Harley: Wow...she really knows you.

Harley slams the box onto the beach and punt kicks it into the ocean.

Lindsay:...Hey that wasn't nice!.

Harley snaps her head at Lindsay and storms up to her causing Lindsay to back up against a tree and kneel down covering her eyes.

Y/n:(confessional.): Okay...so Harley is out of control and she's about to maul Lindsay, not only is Lindsay just slightly hotter then Harley but she brought me those things because she was a fan of me when I was younger...What I'm about to do might cost me my life, but as long as Lindsay survives I'll be happy.

Y/n: HARLEY!.

Harley turns around and looks at you.

Harley: Don't you worry honey, I'll deal with you soon enough.

Y/n: You are acting insane, in fact you've always acted insane, whenever we go out, some girl looks at me and if I smile or say hi, you make a scene and get us kicked out of the restaurant, Lindsay is not only a fan, she's been nice to me ever since I joined the show, while you've been only focused on making me yours. Well I say...Harley...We. Are. Through.

The other girls were watching the whole thing go down and started to cheer...some of the guys were also listening including Chris.

Geoff: What just happened?.

Alejandro: Our Amigo has broken his girlfriend's heart-

Scott: She looks angry.

Duncan: Time for a Mauling baby!. Woo!. Kick his ass Harls!.

Harley smacks Lindsay aside and charges at you, sending you through the damn outhouse with a tackle.

Everyone besides Duncan who was whistling and capping gasped as you were cut on your face and arms.

Harley: You can't break up with me, that's not how it works-

Y/n: It is now Harls...so go ahead, kill me, you'll be in jail and I'll be in paradise.

Bridgette: HEY GET AWAY FROM HIM!.

Bridgette ran to your side and knelt down beside you looking at your wounds.

Bridgette: Are you okay?.

Y/n:...No...maybe this could make me feel better.

You look at Harley and kiss Bridgette who blushes and smiles at you.

Harley: You just wasted your life surfer girl-

Samey: Then I'm about to waste mine as well.

Samey bends down and kisses you on the forehead.

Samey: Thank you for walking with me on the beach this morning Y/n.

Harley: You did what!.

Y/n: Yeah I took Samey on a walk to help her get away from her sitter, she also admitted feelings for me, same with Bridgette and even...can't believe I'm about to say this...even Heather admitted her feels for me.

The other girls look at Heather.

Heather: I'll admit I got a tiny bit tipsy on our date, they were serving free vodka shots.

Harley: I'm going to kill you Y/n-OW!.

Support bit into Harley's leg trying to protect his buddy.

Harley: You little- get off of me!.

Harley takes a plank of wood from the already broken confessional and hits support with it, sending him across the island she then turns to you and hits you in the head with it making you drop like a sack of rocks.

You later find yourself in the infirmary...with a giant bandage across your forehead.

Y/n:...Where am I?.

Chef: You are in the infirmary...also someone is here to see you-

Lindsay runs up to you and gives you a hug trying her best not to hurt you.

Lindsay: You didn't have to do that!.

Y/n: I just wanted to make sure you were alright...it's the least I could do after the stuff you got me.

Lindsay: You liked it?.

Y/n: Of course I did...now what was that you were asking me earlier, something about you wanting to be my-

Lindsay crashes her lips against yours and you see tears come out of her eyes.

Lindsay: Oh yes, oh yes, oh yes!.

Y/n: Great...now how long do I have to be in here for?.

Chef: That's a nasty cut on you boy, I say maybe we should evacuate you-

Lindsay: NO!. You can't take him from me!. Please Chef, I help him, I'll do it.

Chef: Suit yourself girl, I'm leaving.

Chef leaves and Lindsay sits next to you patting your head.

Y/n: Do you even know what to do?.

Lindsay: No, but I'll figure out a way-

Heather: Actually, we'll figure out a way.

You both see Heather, Bridgette and Samey come into the infirmary.

Lindsay: Heather...what are you doing?.

Heather: Well lindsiot, in case you forgot, Y/n took all of us on dates, and now all of a sudden you two are dating but leaving us out of it.

Y/n: I gave you all kisses.

Heather: But none of us are your girlfriends, what makes Lindsay get special treatment.

Y/n: I'd ask both Bridgette and Samey as like Lindsay they actually came to check on me, what's your excuse.

Heather: I had just gotten out of the shower and was in a towel, do you really think I was gonna let  somebody see me like that.

Y/n: But I did, remember-

Heather quickly hides a blush and folds her arms.

Heather: I was tipsy remember?. And besides, if you were too have four girlfriends all watching your back, nobody would mess with you, not Harley, not those aliens not even Duncan.

Y/n: Hey I like the aliens and plus they allowed me to keep Support.

Support climbed up onto your bed and he was holding a little medkit. He opened it up and took out a bandaid with your favorite fictional character on it and put in on a cut.

Y/n: Thanks.

Support smiles and Lindsay gives the plushie a hug.

Heather: Still. If you are with four of us, we can protect you and also take care of you and even...

Heather gives you a kiss on your cheek.

Heather: Please and entertain you.

You think long and hard about the options and nod.

Y/n: Fine...you've got a deal.

Samey and Bridgette both smile and start kissing your face while Lindsay kisses your forehead.