Requested!

CW: smut, first time, bottom!reader, top!gus, swearing

Just saying now and for future reference, I'm one of those people who uses "member" for a substitution. I don't know what's wrong with me, but typing anything else makes me cringe so bad-

Do witches use lube?.... Or magic-? Eh, whatever-

Both are adults. Like last chapter, it will be told in second person. Also, I will still let you decide what the character is named. Just know you're male in this. Enjoy! 😊💙

~~~

You've never been one of those people who gets upset when people forget important days, like your birthday. Or, in this case, an anniversary. Not that it mattered, though; your boyfriend, Gus, is hyper vigilant about remembering everything important about you and your guys' relationship.

You've had boyfriends in the past, sure, but that was all highschool drama and such. None of those men were quite like Gus.
Gus had gone out of his way to plan an entire day with you for your anniversary, and it just made you fall harder for him. He took you out to eat somewhere nice, and you couldn't love him more for it.

"Hey, {y/n}, so... I was thinking, today's really special, right?" Gus started once you had both gotten home. You looked at him, wondering where he was going with this.
"Well,.. and you can say no, I just- I was wondering if you wanted to... Um.. Take things to the bedroom..?" Gus asked, blushing a little.

Even though he had grown up, Gus was still the shy boy you knew in school. And honestly, you liked that about him. Shy, yet confident, and supportive, and caring... There wasn't much not to like.

The question flustered you a little, but you were more than willing to try. It would be your guys' first time doing anything like this together, and you got butterflies at the thought.
"I'd love to, Gus." You tell him. Gus smiled, taking your hand and leading you up to the bedroom. Once you got to your room, Gus shut the door, giving you a soft kiss.

"I want you to tell me if you need me to stop or slow down, okay?" He says. And titan, if that didn't swoon you more. This man is so compassionate.
You nodded in response to his question, and he reconnected his lips to yours. You kissed him back, putting your arms over his shoulders as he led you to the bed.

You'd be lying if you said you weren't a little nervous, but that didn't stop you. You trust Gus, and you love him, dearly. Plus, there's no way he won't be gentle with you.
You and Gus started to undress each other slowly, letting your clothes fall randomly onto the floor. Once you two were out of your clothes, Gus grabbed lube from the nightstand.

"You sure you're ready to do this, {y/n}?" He asked. You smiled up at him and nodded. "I'm sure, dear." You responded. Gus nodded, putting some lube onto his fingers. "Okay, just.. let me know if it starts to hurt, okay?"

With that, he slowly pushed part of his finger into you. He gave you a moment to adjust to the feeling, peppering soft kisses onto your neck in the meantime.
Eventually, you relaxed, and he pushed his finger the rest of the way in. You groaned softly, leaning your head back into the pillows. "Are you alright?" Gus asked.

"Yeah, I'm okay, hun~." You responded. Gus smiled softly and started to pump his finger in and out gently, and titan, you could already feel the pleasure.
Gus carefully worked in a second finger, opening you up nice and gentle. You moaned softly, absolutely loving everything he was doing to you.

After a while, he pulled his fingers out, causing you to whine a bit. He chuckled lightheartedly at the sound. "Awe, it's okay, {y/n}. You know we're not done yet~" he coos, putting lube on his member.

"Still okay with this?" Gus asked. You loved how focused on your comfort he is, really, but titan,you wish he'd just fuck you already. You nodded, your breath hitching when he started pushing in.

"O-oh-~" you said, gripping onto the bedsheet under you. "Shh, it's okay. Take your time, I've got you." Gus said, pausing and letting you get used to him.
You pulled him down for a kiss, a bit heated due to your arousal. Gus happily kissed back, placing one of his hands on your cheek.

Once the kiss breaks, you have him a small nod. "Y-you can continue." You say, a bit breathlessly. Gus nodded, pushing all the way in and trying to be gentle. You moaned when he bottomed out, putting your legs up around his waist.

"Please~.." you whispered.

Gus took it nice and slow to start, adjusting speed, angle, or force if you asked him to. He was focused on making sure you felt good, and comfortable. And you loved that.

At one point, he thrusted right into your prostate, making you moan louder. "Oh- fuck, Gus, there~!" Gus did his best to hit that spot with every thrust, and good lord, was it sending you to the edge.

"G-gus, I'm not going to last much longer~" you warned him. "That's okay, {y/n}. You just let go whenever you need to, hun~" Gus responded.

It wasn't long after that you reached your climax, moaning Gus's name as you came. Gus thrusted into you a few more times before reaching his own orgasm, stilling afterwards and letting both of you calm down for a moment.
Afterwards, he carefully pulled out, and started cleaning you up carefully.

"Woah-" was all you could manage to say. You had an amazing time. Gus smiled, kissing your cheek. "Was I good?" He asked.
"Good is an understatement, dear- titan, I feel wonderful-" You responded. Gus giggled softly, holding you close and laying down. "Happy anniversary, {y/n}."