(A/N: I totally didn't almost forget about his birthday, I have no idea what you're talking about-)

Your POV~ Toby's birthday is tomorrow! Masky, hoodie and I are planning a party- well, masky isn't helping, but anyways, right now I'm talking to sally and lazari they said that they wanna decorate the cake... I'll trust them with that, but right now I have to find toby a present...

(You can either give him, 1: A jar that has many reasons why you love him, 2: A box with nothing in it, then attack him with all the hugs and kisses XD, 3: ... I don't know what to put here, make something up)

~Time skip to his birthday~

Toby is gonna come back at any minute! I smile and look at everything, it's perfect! Surprisingly, laz and sal did a good job on the cake!.... they misspelled a few things and there are alot of sprinkles...  but other than that, it's amazing! "Guys, toby will be here any minute, we should hide in the living room now." They all nod and we head to the living room.

I hear the front door open and he walked in. "Y-Y/N?" I heard him call out. "I'm in the living room!" I yelled to him. Lazari turned off the lights and she went back to her hiding spot, you heard him walk to the living room, he turned on the lights and...

"Surprise!" 

Toby looked at everyone. "H-huh?" he tilted his head and looked at me. I run over to him and hug him tightly. "Happy birthday, toby!" He blushed and looked at everything here. "D-did yo-you plan this y-yourself?" He asked softly, kissing the top of my head. "Mhm, do you like it?" Toby picked me up and spun me around. "O-Of course I d-do!" Hoodie coughed to get toby's attention. "We helped too!" Laz pouted. "Hey, I came up with the idea to make a surprise party!" I chuckled. Sally ran over and hugged toby. "Can we open the gifts and eat the cake?! Laz and I worked really hard on the cake!" Toby thought about it. "H-how about w-we eat c-cake, then I-I open my g-gifts?" Toby suggested. Sally and lazari smiled. "Yeah!"

Toby and I went to the cake, the girls went a bit overboard with the sprinkles... "W-well..." "Do you like it!?" Sally looked up at him, smiling alot. "Y-yeah!... Why s-so many s-sprinkles though...?" Sally looked at lazari with a 'How about you explain this?' face. "Well... I was going to put on a few sprinkles... I may or may not have broken the container..." She looked at the ground and mumbled 'sorry'.

Toby hugged her. "H-hey, I li-like crunchy c-cake!" everyone stares at him. "... Dude, what the hell is wrong with you..." Ben facepalmed. "I-I'm trying t-to make her f-feel better!" Toby glared at ben. "Whatever, let's just eat the cake." Ben rolled his eyes.

~Time skip to presents cause I'm lazy!~

"W-who's present sh-should I open first?" Toby looked at all the presents. "Save me for last, toby!" I tell him, smiling. He chuckled and nodded, opening sally's gift. "Aw, th-thanks sally!" He hugged her, she gave him a new hatchet... where did she even get that- You know what- I wont ask. She giggled and hugged back. "Open my gift next! Actually, Sally and I both worked on it! It took forever too!" Laz threw the present at his face, why is everyone abusive to toby?? Toby opened it and gasped. "Y-Y/N, look a-at this!" I look at it and gasp softly, it was a scrapbook of toby and I... Did the girls spy on us just to take these pictures?! 

After awhile, toby opened everyone's presents, everyone except mine. "Toby? Can we be somewhere alone? I don't really want everyone to be watching..." I whisper to him. He hesitantly nodded and took my hand, we walked to the backyard and went behind a tree. "So... W-what's your g-gift?"

If you gave him the jar that has many reasons why you love him:

I slowly give my present to him, he reads what it says and blushes softly, hugging me close. "I love you..." I hug him back. "I l-love you m-mor-" 

-SNAP- 

We look over and see sally and lazari with a camera. "SAL, THEY CAUGHT US, RUN!!!!" They run away, toby and I laugh. "w-well... S-shall we g-go back?" I held his hand and kissed his cheek. "We shall"

If you gave him a box with literally nothing: 

I give him the box. "Huh? W-what's in h-here?" Toby tried shaking it, but couldn't hear anything. I hid my smile. "Just open it!" Toby quickly opened it, he had a confused look. "Th-there's nothing i-in here...?" Toby looked at me again. "D-did something h-happen to the g-gift-" I cut him off and kiss him

He blushed a dark red but kissed back, after awhile I pull away and hug him. We hear two squeals and look at lazari and sally. They quickly ran away.

Then we hear lazari shout to sally. "DANGIT, WE FORGOT THE CAMERA!" We both laugh and go back into the mansion.

(Sorry that this one was shorter than the last :') I'm tired)

If you gave him -insert awesome present here- (I know I'll regret this):

I am really proud of my gift, it took me forever to find something perfect for toby, I slowly give him the gift with a smirk. "W-what's with th-the smirk...?"  Toby hesitantly looked at what I got him, it was rather amusing, his eyes lit up and he smiled and pulled me to him.

"I l-love i-it!" He kissed my forehead, I chuckle. "I'm glad you like it! It was really hard to find a gift to be honest..." I mumbled the last part. 

"Come on, let's go back to the mansion." I grab his hand and run into the mansion with him, he almost dropped his gift but managed to keep up with me.

~Later that night~

Toby and I were just cuddling on our bed, I started to fall asleep...

Toby's POV~ I look at Y/N and chuckle, I turned off the T.V and laid down, kissing his/her forehead softly I lay down next to her and hug her/him close. "Goodnight, Y/N, I love you..." I start to fall asleep next to her/him.

A/N: Happy birthday, toby!