Act 2 = Season 2 

Luther: Phillip Hamilton - does everything he can to make his fam (not including vanya, sry bby) happy

Diego: Alexander Hamilton - NO REGRETS

Allison: Angelica... still

Klaus: Jefferson - bold, fancy, maybe a little self-centered

Five: Jefferson and a little bit of Hamilton

Ben: James Madison - quiet, agreeable, inquisitive, a little territorial (also a smidge of hamilton; "I REGRET NOTHING!"

Vanya: Eliza... OBVI (and a lil phillip, "im sorry"-phillip and vanya)

Sissy: Maria Reynolds - seducing hehe *winks to vanya*

Lila: Angelica with a little bit of Jefferson