Hello everyone! The results for Taboo/Forbidden Romance are down below. Congratulate our winners. If you did not place in this category, feel free to reach out to me SapphirianJ82 for your scores and reviews. First place winner will get a shout-out on my announcements board. All winners will have a permanent place in my library. 

We have our first place winner!

Crossing Lines by _Reenie read and judged by gremlinsbookstash please reach out to your host SapphirianJ82 to receive your winning sticker.

Overall Score 1-100 score (98 of 100)

Title and Book Cover 1-10 score (8 of 10)

I appreciate the title; it’s concise and memorable. Especially with the use of capitalized letters. However, I wasn’t particularly fond of the book cover. While the imagery was clear and appealing, I found that the additional elements were somewhat overwhelming. 

Blurb 1-10 score (10 of 10)

The blurb is excellent. It strikes the right balance with just enough details to pique your interest without giving too much away. It leaves you wanting to read more, presenting the main character as flawless. The grammar and punctuation are impeccable.

Plot/Creativity/Originality 1-20 score (20 of 20)

The plot intrigued me, surprising me with the enjoyment of the genre I never expected to like. In the first few chapters I read, I found no plot holes, and the book brings with creativity. The author’s talent shines through.

Character Development 1-20 score (20 of 20)

The main character is depicted skillfully, enabling readers to easily discern her personality. Moreover, it is effortless for readers to step into her shoes. Every emotion the main character experiences feels authentic and tangible. For instance, you can sense second hand embarrassment or anxiety when she grapples with such feelings.

I appreciate that the character development diverges from the typical narrative. Rather than focusing on overcoming weaknesses. It delves into the process of discovering more details about oneself.

Story Flow 1-10 score (10 of 10)

The narrative flows seamlessly; you hardly notice when a chapter comes to an end.

Grammar 1-10 score (10 of 10)

There were no issues with grammar or punctuation.

Writing Style 1-10 score (10 of 10)

I appreciate the author’s choice of vocabulary, striking a balance between accessibility and sophisticated English. The paragraph lengths are just right, with a pleasant mix of descriptions and dialogue. Overall, it’s very reader-friendly for those who may not be native English speakers.

Overall Engagement 1-10 score (10 of 10)

I thoroughly enjoyed this book - it had me hooked, and I would have finished it in one sitting if not for work. The author’s provided playlist was perfect, adding another layer to the experience. Clearly, the author is immensely talented. I strongly encourage the author to keep writing.

Our second place winner is Rowdy by WakeWriteWrath read and judged by gremlinsbookstash. Reach out to me SapphirianJ82 for your winning sticker. ☺️

Overall Score: 1-100 score (96 of 100

Title and Book Cover 1-10 score (9 of 10)

I’m quite found of the title; it’s sufficient and memorable, easily leaving an impression. While the meaning isn’t explicitly outlined in the initial 10 chapters I read, a glance at the book's description provides a clear understanding. The cover, while somewhat uncomplicated, doesn’t necessarily equate to a drawback. A simple design often stands out amidst more extravagant ones. The pairing of red and black is consistently effective, and the color scheme, along with the font choice, grabs your attention. I also appreciate the centered layout.

Blurb: 1-10 score (10 of 10)

I thoroughly enjoyed the blurb; it provides just the right amount of information to pique your interest in the story. It precisely outlines what the book is about, allowing you to decide whether the theme aligns with your preferences. The punctuation and grammar are flawless.

Plot/Creativity/Originality 1-20 score (18 of 20)

In contrast to other books in the reverse harem genre, the author has introduced a fresh perspective in my opinion. I appreciate the story goes beyond mere intimate encounters offering a well-developed plot. The narrative unfolds smoothly in the initial 10 chapters that I’ve read. The book is rich in creativity, though it may be predictable at times; however, this predictability does not detract from the overall plot.

Character Development: 1-20 score (19 of 20)

Having focused solely on the female main character’s point of view in the initial 10 chapters, I assessed her character development. In general, her character felt authentic and lifelike, mirroring the emotions, struggles, and doubts that people experience in real life. She embodies the kind of female character both women and men can relate to. On a more personal level, I found aspects of myself in her. Throughout the first ten chapters, she takes small steps towards self-employment, and based on what I’ve read so far, it seems she has ample potential for further growth in the future.

Story Flow: 1-10 score (10 of 10)

The chapters maintained a steady pace with no sense of haste. The author skillfully ensured a smooth flow, avoiding hurried decisions and relationships.

Grammar: 1-10 score (10 of 10)

The grammar aspects posed no issues; everything was well-executed and understandable.

Writing Style: 1-10 score (10 of 10)

I appreciate the author employed a well-balanced vocabulary and phrasing. It’s not overly challenging for those who may not be highly experienced in reading English, yet it doesn’t compromise on complexity either. The author’s writing style is very accommodating for non-native English readers. 

Overall Engagement and Enjoyment: 1-10 score (10 of 10)

From a reader’s standpoint, everything was flawless. The intimate chapter was well-executed, not rushed. While I personally found it a bit on the milder side, it was impeccably written.

I appreciate that the author included visual elements, like pictures depicting the characters and aesthetics. Furthermore, the author supplied additional information, such as age, height, and hobbies, adding depth to the narrative. 

Our third place winner is Not My Little Sister by lostlovefairy read and judged by SapphirianJ82 Reach out to me for your winning sticker. ☺️

Overall Score: 1-100 score (95 of 100)

Title/Book Cover: 1-10 score (9 of 10)

The title of the book is truly unique, and it aligns perfectly with the overall plot of the story. Throughout the narrative, the author shares several vivid images with us, so I believe the book cover should feature a more vibrant and captivating image to reflect this. The font used for the title is bold and visually pleasing, adding to its appeal.

Blurb: 1-10 score (8 of 10)

While the blurb effectively captivates the reader and accurately portrays the story’s plot, it may be a tad lengthy and reveal excessive information. Consequently, it leaves little room for intrigue regarding the events that will unfold. To assist you in addressing this concern, I will send you a private message with my suggestions.

Plot/Creativity/Originality 1-20 score (20 of 20)

The plot of this book is incredibly smooth, immensely intriguing, and flows amazingly well right from the beginning. Moreover, it is highly creative and original, unlike anything I have read before. I was hooked right off the bat and couldn’t put the book down. It is definitely a must-read. 

Character Development 1-20 score (20 of 20)

In a culture that restricts a woman's freedom, Vinaya, an independent young woman, strives to leave her mark on the world. She is determined to make her own way and rejects the notion of relying on a male companion. As she embarks on her journey, her character undergoes significant development. It was truly captivating to witness her unwavering strength, strong-willed nature, and the unfolding of her independence. 

Story Flow: 1-10 score (10 of 10)

The flow of the story is smooth, neither too slow nor hastened, which effectively keeps the reader engaged and wanting more.

Grammar: 1-10 score (9 of 10)

The grammar and punctuation in the text are precise, with only a few minor issues here and there, most of which I pointed out during my reading. Fortunately, there were no major issues, which greatly enhances the flow, engagement, and overall enjoyment of the story. 

Writing Style: 1-10 score (9 of 10)

The author’s unique writing style kept me highly engaged and deeply immersed in the story. I found it hard to put down, and now I can’t wait to go back and read the newest chapters that have been uploaded. 

Overall Engagement and Enjoyment: 1-10 score (10 of 10)

When it comes to reading “Not My Little Sister,” there is no contest on engagement. The story is incredibly descriptive, capturing emotions, actions, dialogue, and surroundings. It immerses you in the shoes of the main female protagonist, making you feel a range of emotions. One moment you’ll be laughing, and the next, you’ll be filled with anger. You’ll experience love, pain, hardships, and a multitude of other emotions through this captivating story. It’s an absolute must-read, and I highly recommend that you all head over and see for yourself.