Note:This isn't meant to be offensive please don't kill me

Lapis

What Fans think:

Wrongfully trapped
Needed help
Bad stuff keeps happening to her

Reality:

Trapped in a mirror
Trapped on a ship
Trapped underwater
Chose to stay on Earth
Pissy and Emo because she "has to" stay with Peridot(she was literally given a choice about this)

Jasper

What Fans think:

Big buff cheeto puff
Sweetheart deep down

Reality:

Destabilized Garnet
Fought Garnet
Tricked by Lapis
Fell face-first into the cluster

Peridot

What Fans think:

Smol
Adorable

Reality:

Smol
Adorable
Hero

So yes, I am mad at Lapis after the events of Barn Mates. And after watching Same Old World and Barn Mates, I realized that we never see Lapis. And when we do, she's always trapped or leaving. So she's not as pure as people think. And since I don't have Photoshop at the moment:

Keep
Peridot

Sell
Jasper

Burn
Lapis