Okay so I have a slight problem.

We're doing the probability thing in math class and I am in a group with my BFF and this other girl. We have to create a game and little kids will come play it. And we have 2 ideas for the game:

-an m&m themed game, we put cut-outs of m&m's under plastic cups and mix them around. Then the person will choose one and depending on the colour, will win coins. For example: red m&m = 5 coins, blue = 2 coins and yellow = you lose, etc.

-we get the fake fishing stuff (like the little kid's magnet fishing set from the dollar store) and they have to fish and depending on the colour of fish they win coins. For example: red = 2 coins, blue = you lose and yellow = 5 coins, etc

So we're making these games for 8-12 year olds. Which idea do you think is a) more appealing (as in gets people to come to our game) and b) the actual game that's more fun.

So the other girl that's in the group wants to leave the group cause we don't like her idea but my teacher said she can't.

Which idea do you think is better?

-Shipper