PONYBOY:

You two went as Devils and Angels

JOHNNY:
You two went as star football player  and cheer captain.

STEVE:

You two went as Bella and Edward

DARRY:

You two went as beauty in the beast.

Two-Bit:

You two went as Mickey and Minnie

Sodapop:

You two went as sleeping beauty and Prince charming

DALLAS:

You two went as Harley and the Joker