Lily:

 Later putting on a pirate princess dress I walked to the pirate hunter's office and was about to knock when he opened the door I jumped and fell to the ground and blushed and covered my face.

Hunter: 

Donny! How did she leave your room!? I shouted, Donny came running and grabbed the mermaid picking her up. I didn't understand how he was so calm around it, I guess it was bee Donny always did a ritual of dropping something shiny in the sea after we grabbed a large load of fish to keep the mermaids away. I watched as Donny took the girl back to his room "Why does she keep trying to see me?" I thought walking to the wheel of the ship

lily:

 was taken to Donny's room once more but this time Donny began to pull out some different clothes. He approached me with two pairs of clothes, One: A dress that matched Hunter's style and the other that matched his, I pointed to the first one as Donny put the other one away and began to attempt to change me, Out of instinct I scratched Donny ripping his shirt, Underneath I saw a weird looking tape thing that I had broke Reviling that he is a she. She stared at me and she apologized for trying to change me and asked If she could do me a favor, I decided to tell her to tell Hunter I loved him.

Donny:

 I stared at the mermaid, I used my coat to hide my chest, buttoned it up, and went to the captain. I knocked on the door."Come in" He said as I came in."Sir...The mermaid wanted me to tell you something..." I gulped as he looked up from the book and at me, unpleased"She said she loved you...I mumbled"What?" Hunter asked, annoyed"Um...The mermaid said she loved you""Will you spit it out!?" He yelled "THE MERMAID SAID SHE LOVED YOU, SIR!" I shoutedI then immediately covered my mouth and ran out the door back to my cabin. I slammed the door closed as the mermaid stared at me, I gulped as she said."What did he say!?" Excitedly." Um...I wasn't able to get his response, so.."I replied grabbing a new shirt. 

Lily: 

"WHAT!" I screamed getting up.I opened the door and I ran to the caption's office and burst through the door and said to him calmly:" I love you. That is why I come to the surface to watch you when I am bored."

Hunter: 

I stared at the girl not knowing what to say, I wanted to call Donny but I could have sworn I saw a scar on her chest when she came to me. I took in a deep breath"Look, I am sure you are an amazing girl or mermaid or whatever and that you would never do me harm...But you did my first mate harm and I cannot be in love with someone who harms her, Besides you are a mermaid and I am a pirate..it would never work, Now go home"I began to walk her out of the cabin and then gently closed the door behind her as the rest of the crew went to their cabins and Donny began to do her nightly chores