A reminder that we unexpectedly had to change one judge in this genre, you can see the reasoning behind it in our "Update" part of this book. 

Results for the first round

10. Echo in the Wind by strawberry1d 

Judge OutOfMyImagination 

Engagement 7/20

Concept 5/10

Cover 7/10

The book description 7/10

Technicalities 25/50

Total 51/100

Judge deviljooniefics 

Engagement 10/20

Concept 5.5/10

Cover 7.5/10

The book description 6/10

Technicalities 29/50

Total 58/100

Total from both judges: 109/200

✵✵✵✵✵

9. Bound By Blood by LordEzekiel 

Judge OutOfMyImagination 

Engagement 12/20

Concept 7/10

Cover 9/10

The book description 8/10

Technicalities 32/50

Total 68/100

Judge deviljooniefics 

Engagement 12/20

Concept 9/10

Cover 10/10

The book description 6.5/10

Technicalities 30/50

Total 67.5/100

Total from both judges: 135,5/200

✵✵✵✵✵

8. The Shunned Wolf Fights Back by ArdenTownsend 

Judge OutOfMyImagination 

Engagement 14/20

Concept 7/10

Cover 5/10

The book description 4/10

Technicalities 40/50

Total 70/100

Judge deviljooniefics 

Engagement 17/20

Concept 8/10

Cover 4.5/10

The book description 6.5/10

Technicalities 46/50

Total 82/100

Total from both judges: 152/200

✵✵✵✵✵

7. Palingenesis by DeathBlade__ 

Judge OutOfMyImagination 

Engagement 14/20

Concept 7/10

Cover 9/10

The book description 7/10

Technicalities 38/50

Total 75/100

Judge deviljooniefics 

Engagement 16/20

Concept 8.5/10

Cover 8.5/10

The book description 10/10

Technicalities 35/50

Total 78/100

Total from both judges: 153/200

✵✵✵✵✵

6. I Live For Nights Like These by ArielMLongee 

Judge OutOfMyImagination 

Engagement 15/20

Concept 8/10

Cover 8/10

The book description 9/10

Technicalities 43/50

Total 83/100

Judge deviljooniefics 

Engagement 14/20

Concept 7/10

Cover 7/10

The book description 9/10

Technicalities 35/50

Total 72/100

Total from both judges: 155/200

︵‿︵✵✵✵✵✵︵‿︵

Books that are going to round two!

5. Crossing Over by KatherineCosette 

Judge OutOfMyImagination 

Engagement 19/20

Concept 7/10

Cover 6/10

The book description 8/10

Technicalities 45/50

Total 85/100

Judge deviljooniefics 

Engagement 18/20

Concept 8/10

Cover 5/10

The book description 6.5/10

Technicalities 42/50

Total 79.5/100

Total from both judges: 164,5/200

✵✵✵✵✵

4.  Scars and Secrets by TalleFey 

Judge OutOfMyImagination 

Engagement 18/20

Concept 8/10

Cover 9/10

The book description 10/10

Technicalities 40/50

Total 85/100

Judge deviljooniefics 

Engagement 19/20

Concept 8/10

Cover 10/10

The book description 9/10

Technicalities 39/50

Total 85/100

Total from both judges: 170/200

✵✵✵✵✵

3. Cascadia by RavenMoon420 

Judge OutOfMyImagination 

Engagement 16/20

Concept 8/10

Cover 8/10

The book description 10/10

Technicalities 42/50

Total 84/100

Judge deviljooniefics 

Engagement 18.5/20

Concept 10/10

Cover 9/10

The book description 9/10

Technicalities 45/50

Total 91.5/100 

Total from both judges: 175,5/200

✵✵✵✵✵

2. Hiraeth by marina_swampert 

Judge OutOfMyImagination 

Engagement 15/20

Concept 8/10

Cover 8/10

The book description 7/10

Technicalities 45/50

Total 83/100

Judge deviljooniefics 

Engagement 18/20

Concept 9/10

Cover 9/10

The book description 10/10

Technicalities 47/50

Total 93/100

Total from both judges: 176/200

✵✵✵✵✵

1. Black Avatare by SuVida777 

Engagement 18/20

Concept 9/10

Cover 10/10

The book description 10/10

Technicalities 50/50

Total 97/100

Judge deviljooniefics 

Engagement 19.5/20

Concept 9/10

Cover 10/10

The book description 10/10

Technicalities 49/50

Total 97.5/100

Total from both judges: 194,5/200

Note: Feedback will be sent to each participant who didn't move to the second round via dm.