Aries- The first to die

Taurus- The one that comes home at the end to see everyone dead

Gemini- The one who figures out what the killer is

Cancer- The one who cancels the hunt to buy food

Leo- The one who fights back and ends up dead

Virgo- The one that sacrifices themselves but eventually comes back

Libra- The one who was the killer the whole time

Scorpio- The one with the most weapons

Sagittarius- The one who is secretly possessed the whole time

Capricorn- The one who cracks and goes on a demon murder spree

Aquarius- The one that crawled outta hell to get pie for Dean

Pisces- The one with an ear-splitting scream