Who you are related
Gabriel- Jess little sister

Lucifer- Deans old friends.

Michael- The Mikaelson's younger sister

Balthazar- Chuck little sister

 
What are you
Gabriel- Alpha Werewolf

Lucifer- A human/witch

Michael- Vampire

Balthazar- A banshee

How you met

Gabriel- You worked at a candy store. Kids came by, but this man was no kid. He came with two bags full of candy.

"Have a problem?" He said.

"No. I mean, I never seen a man that loves candy so much as I do." You laughed.

"Sweet tooth." He pulled out his hand. "Gabriel."

"Y/n." You gave him his change and you both talked.

"Full moon is out today." You nervously laughed.

"Yeah. Werewolves! RRAH!" You pretended to claw him.

"Hope to see you soon."

"Here's my number. Maybe you and I can share some of your favorite candies."

"Sure will do. Be careful tonight." And he left. He was a handsome man, but why would he speak about the full moon and werewolves?

Lucifer- You were outside taking a call. It was your old friend, Dean Winchester. He said that have a look out, the Devil is here. You started to worry.

"Hello." A man in a green unbutton shirt with a black shirt said.

"Hi."

"Sorry, but was that Dean Winchester?" You looked at him.

"Um, yeah."

"Isn't he a pain?"

"Don't get me started." You smiled. "Im (full name)."

"Lucifer." Your eyes widen. "Don't worry, I don't bite." And all afternoon you stayed at the restaurant with him. Even if it was the Devil you fell in love with, you had a good feeling about him.

Michael- You were doing to make a deal. (A/N: Pretend that Elijah is dead) You were drunk and running out of options. But this was no crossroad demon, it was the one and only Lucifer.

"Making a deal, Sweetheart?" And out of nowhere you got zapped somewhere and saw a beautiful guy.

"What are you trying to do? Get yourself killed?"

"My brother is dead! What am I supposed to do!" You cried.

"I'm Michael. I'm now your guardian angel." And that day he never left your side.

Balthazar- You were at a bar. Your friends left with some men and here you are, drinking some scotch. You saw this man sitting on a table, drink wine. You looked back every once and a while.

"What's a pretty girl doing at a dump like this?" The man with wine asked.

"A fella did me wrong." You smile.

"What did this man do that was so wrong?" You turned to him. His eyes were so beautiful, so beautiful that it made you feel like you were flying. You laughed.

"I'm Y/n." You pulled out your hand.

"Balthazar." He took your hand and kissed it.

"Nice to meet you."

"Same here." After hours of talking, your brother Chuck, called and he need you home. You both walked out.

"Here's my number." You gave it to him.

"I don't need. I'll find you again." He smiled and he walked away.

Nicknames:
Gabriel-
His-Candy man
Yours- My lady

Lucifer-
His- Little red man
Yours- Queen

Michael-
His- My guardian angel
Yours- Angel

Balthazar-
His- Love
Yours- Bubbles

Love songs
Gabriel- Iris by The Goo Goo Dolls

Lucifer- She Will Be Loved by Maroon 5

Michael- Give Me Love by Ed Sherran

Balthazar-Hey There Delilah by Plain White T's

Something you steal from him
Gabriel- his candy

Lucifer- his shirts

Michael- his sword

Balthazar- His wine

His favorite feature of you
Gabriel- Your feet. He likes how tiny they are and how you step on your tippy toes.

Lucifer- Your nose. He likes to kiss it whenever he wants you be careful.

Michael- Your smile. He loves how you show your beautiful teeth, you make him smile for once.

Balthazar- Your neck. He loves how warm it is when he kisses there.

How you cuddle
Gabriel- since he can't sleep, you wrap your legs around his waist so he won't go anywhere,

Lucifer- like Gabriel he can't sleep, but you guys hold hands and you lay on his chest.

Michael- He's angel he can't sleep, He was his arms around you while on your side and you hear 'his' heart beat.

Balthazar- you get the point, right? Anyways, he lays back down and you are on top of him while he breathes, making you go to sleep.

What you mention sex
Gabriel- already in bed

Lucifer- He smirks

Michael- Gets a little blushy

Balthazar- Gets wine afterwards

When you give him the slient treatment
Gabriel- When he compared you to his old girlfriends

Lucifer- When he talks about leaving Dean in hell

Michael- When he gets to bossy

Balthazar- When he and you got into a fight

First date
Gabriel- he took you to the movies

Lucifer- he took you to a legit hunted house 

Michael- he took you to a carnival

Balthazar- he took you to a fancy dinner in Italy

First kiss
Gabriel- on the first date

Lucifer- when he confessed his love for you

Michael- when you kissed him in front of your brother Klaus

Balthazar- on a dare he made for you

Him asking you to be his girlfriend
Gabriel- he changed your life into your favorite tv show and asked you how your favorite character said to her.

Lucifer- he almost lost you and that's when he said 'will you be mine.'

Michael- he got you a little of his grace and he told you to be his forever

Balthazar- he took you to paris and asked you there