Requested by: Scooby_dubydoo234

Imagine: You are friends with Castiel, Gabriel, Lucifer, and Michael and they all love you and fight for your attention.

You had met the Winchesters about three years ago on a hunt. You were an even better hunter than them, and it was clear that they needed your help, and you needed a home, so they took you in.

The first angel you had ever met was a friend of theirs: Castiel. You were shocked by him at first, after all, you have never had an encounter with a celestial being, but soon you and Cas became pretty good friends. You spent time with him everyday and he told you things about Heaven, and his brothers, and each story only intrigued you to know more about the angels. After a little while, Cas started noticing things about you that he had never noticed before. For example, the sparkle that appears in your eyes when he tells you his stories, or the smile that appears on your face when you dance and sing to your favorite songs, or even that cute little eyebrow thing you do when your focusing, or when your confused.

The next angel you met was the infamous Michael. The badass archangel who saved our world from the apocalypse once before. Unfortunately, you had met him for the same exact reason. You had met him before Dean or Sam ever had, when he came to you in a dream. He figured if Dean would ever say yes to being his vessel, you would have to be the one to convince him. You worked with Michael for a while, really getting to know him, which nobody had ever really done before. You listened to him, and you treated him like an actual person, instead of just some big hero that everyone depends on to save the world. Eventually, this rule-abiding archangel started falling in love with you, a human.

You had met Lucifer pretty soon after Michael. At first, you hated Lucifer, I mean, after all, he is the devil, and he is trying to destroy your world. But, you couldn't help it, you felt drawn to him. Something about what he was saying didn't match up to how everyone described him. So, you started going to him yourself, without Dean and Sam knowing, to find out his story first-hand. Although, he was Satan, the story that he told seemed authentic, and eventually you started developing sympathy for him, and only a little while later, you gave him the nickname Luci. Of course, that ended up turning out bad, because you called him Luci once in front of Sam and Dean, and they found out about you secretly visiting Lucifer. Although they forbid you to see him, that didn't stop you, and you secretly met up regularly, and every time the two of you would meet up, he became a little less evil, and a little more loving, at least towards you.

Of course, the next angel you got to know was Gabriel. You were the first one to figure out that he wasn't a trickster, but, being you, you of course didn't tell Dean or Sam. Because, you were afraid of how they would react after the whole Mystery Spot thing. So, you instead kept Gabriel's secret to yourself. When Gabriel had found out, however, that not only did you know both Michael and Lucifer, but you were friends with the both of him, he became immediately intrigued by you. He started visiting you on a regular basis. Whenever you weren't around Sam or Dean he would pop in and just get to know you. He would make jokes constantly, and you laughed at every single one of them, which he absolutely adored. The two of you became a mischievous duo, working together to try to stop the apocalypse, and, of course, pulling pranks of Sam and Dean whenever you got the chance.

You honestly loved being friends with all of them. You were the middle ground that kept everyone civil, which meant you were keeping the world as safe as possible. Lucifer couldn't kill Michael without hurting you, which he didn't want to do, and Michael couldn't kill Lucifer for the exact same reason, which gave you and Gabriel time to try to come up with a civil way to stop the apocalypse, and then there was Cas. You trusted in Cas the most, since you've know him the longest, so whenever you and Gabriel had a plan, you made sure you ran it by Cas first, so he could tell you any mistakes that may lead to either yours' or Gabriel's death. You also went to him when you wanted to complain about Lucifer's or Michael's childish behavior. Basically, Castiel was your confidant.

Little did you know, though, that while you were trying to be friends with all the angels, you were only making them fall more and more in love with you. You were pretty oblivious to this, but they all knew how they all felt about you, which meant war. Obviously, they weren't going to murder each other in cold-blood, making sure the last one standing would be the man for you. Instead they did something much more simple: they tried to woo you.

Michael took you on the grand tour of heaven, showing you the most beautiful, amazing places, yet telling you that it's beauty didn't compare to yours. Lucifer showed you his compassionate side, taking you on all of your dream dates. Gabriel made you desserts, constantly, always keeping you happy, and making sure to tell you how perfect and gorgeous you were to him when you asked if the desserts he made for you was making you fat. Then there was Cas, since you probably talked to him the most, he knew everything about you. From your favorite TV Show to your favorite movie, to your favorite song, and every night he got the chance, he would have TV marathons with you, or he would have dance parties where he would make a total fool of himself, but that led to you teaching him how to dance, which made him even happier.

Eventually, however, this little contest for your love turned extremely competitive, resulting in the angels fighting constantly. You had no idea what they were fighting about, but you hated the fact that they were fighting at all, and you had had enough. So, one day when they were all fighting, once again, you stood in the middle of it all. "Enough! This fighting has gotten ridiculous! And, either you tell me what you're fighting about or I will find out myself," you yelled at them. This made them all become quiet, as they all blushed a slight shade of pink.

All eyes were on you, but no one dared to speak, so you said, "I'm waiting." The three archangels looked down as Cas kept eye contact with you. "Cas, please, tell me what's going on," you begged. He gave you a  sympathetic look as he walked closer to you, and took your hands in his. "We're fighting over a human, Y/N. One that is extremely beautiful, one that is smart, one that is brave. We're fighting over a human that is friends with all of us, and also the woman that we all love...we're fighting over you, Y/N," Cas explained to you.

You let a small gasp escape your lips as you took a small step back, trying to process the words that just left Cas' lips. Your eyes furrowed as you looked back up, noticing that, again, all eyes were on you. "I don't know what to say," you replied in a bit of a quiet voice.

"You have to choose someone, Y/N, before we all kill each other," Gabriel told you, and you studied the faces of the others. They all agreed. "I don't want to choose, because once I do, I lose the rest of you," you responded. "No, you won't. If you don't choose us, if you don't love us, we will still love you. We won't leave you," Lucifer replied, and you gave him a small smile. "So, who is it, Y/N? Who do you love?" Michael asked, and everyone got the same expression of hope on their face as they all held their breath. You exhaled a shaky breath, and said, "I choose..."

Castiel:

"I choose Cas. It's always been you, Cas. You're my best friend, you understand me more than anyone ever has. I love you," you told the angel in a trench coat, and you watched as an adorable smile spread across his face. "You really choose me?" he asked, not believing you actually said his name. "There is no one I would rather have marathons of my favorite TV shows and movies with," you responded. Castiel smiled as he pulled you into a hug, before releasing you, and stroking his thumbs over your face, and both of you had the same expression of happiness.

Michael:

"I choose Michael," you said, making eye contact with the archangel. "Me?" he questioned in disbelief. "You showed me places that I could never have even dreamed of existing. You opened my eyes to the beauties of the world, but you also opened my eyes to the beauties of you. I fell in love with you the moment you first took me to Heaven, and every time you called me beautiful I couldn't contain my happiness. I'm in love with you, Michael. I choose you," you told him. He had never felt happiness like he did in that moment, and he didn't care who knew how happy he was. Because you chose him, and in that moment he only fell even more in love with you.

Lucifer:

"I choose Lucifer," you said, scared of how everyone would react. Lucifer jumped up with a smile on his face as Michael asked in disbelief, "You choose the devil?" Lucifer ignored his older brother as he picked you up and spun you around placing a quick, gentle kiss on your lips. "Are you sure you know what you're doing?" he asked you. "Yes, I'm starting a new life with the man I love. You made my dreams become a reality, and I knew that as soon as I started going behind Sam and Dean's back to see you, I was going to get myself into trouble. But, it doesn't matter how much trouble I'll get into, because I'll be with you. You are my dream guy, and I am completely in love with you," you told Lucifer, as he crashed his lips onto yours.

Gabriel

"I choose Gabriel," you responded, confidently, sure of your answer. "Seriously?" Lucifer asked in disbelief. Gabriel started walking to you with a smile on his face as you explained your reasoning. "There is no angel more human than Gabriel. He understands what I want, and what I need, and he is always there to give it to me. I never felt more safe than when I'm in his arms, and I know that he will never let anything happen to me. He's the only one who could make me truly happy," you told the other angels as Gabriel inched closer and closer to you. He leaned down, his lips were only a couple inches away as he whispered to you, "I am so in love with you," before he closed the gap between you, and you felt safe once more, because you were with Gabriel, and you knew he was the only thing you needed in life to be happy.

Hello my little monsters,

I hope you all enjoyed this imagine! It was pretty fun writing it! Let me know who you chose. Thank you for reading, and thanks for all your comments and votes. I love you all and all of you are amazing!

Always Keep Fighting!

~Caela~