Requested by: the_cookie_whisperer

Imagine: You and Sam are out on a date and you run into his ex girlfriend, Amelia.

The day had started off normal. You had woken up around the same time that you normally do, you took a shower, and then you went downstairs to eat the breakfast that your boyfriend, Sam had made for you. You gave him a quick kiss as you grabbed your plate and then you went to go sit down in the dining room with Sam following suit.

He sat down next to you and asked, "So, how is my beautiful girl this morning?" You smiled and said, "Well, I woke up to an empty bed this morning. You see, usually my boyfriend is there to kiss me good morning, but he wasn't today." Sam raised an eyebrow and replied, "Yeah, I'm sorry about that. I have had a lot on my mind lately, and I went out for a run to clear my head. I tried to make it back before you woke up, but I was late."

"It's okay, Sammy. I just missed you, that's all." you told him as you finished your breakfast and stood up to put your plate in the sink. You felt Sam come into the kitchen as well as he cleaned up his plate too. You were about to leave the kitchen, when Sam grabbed you by your wrist and spun you around to face him.

He pushed you against the wall and placed the perfect kiss on your lips. You were so caught up in the kiss that you didn't even realize when it ended, and you just tayef there for a moment longer with your eyes shut. Sam chuckled lightly and you opened your eyes. "What was that for?" you asked. "Good morning," Sam responded.

"Oh, you're making it up for not being there is morning," you replied. He nodded his head as he tugged on his lip making you want to kiss him again. "Well that almost made up for all of it. Another kiss like that and you'll be golden," you told him with a wink.

Sam laughed and said, "How about I take you out for dinner tonight?" You smiled and replied, "Like an actual date? We haven't been on one of those for a while." "I know I miss going out with you without fearing for our lives," Sam joked. You laughed and responded, "Alright, dinner it is. When and where?"

"I'll make reservations for 7 and you know that restaurant that looks really fancy, but is actually really cheap? I'll take you there," Sam explained. You nodded your head before pulling Sam into another kiss. When you broke away, you told him, "Its a date."

~Time Skip: Brought to You by the awkward stuff that's about to happen~

It was about an hour and a half before 7, and you decided to start getting ready. You didn't have many elegant gowns, why would you when you were a hunter? But, you did have a couple, just in case you would ever need them on a case. You looked through your closet and finally found the dress you were looking for.

It was a beautiful, long, red dress that fit your shape perfectly. It was a v-neck with a flowy skirt and the top back of the dress cut out. You put the dress on and immediately you felt ten times hotter. You knew that you always looked like a super model when you put that dress on. You curled your hair in loose curls and let them fall naturally.

You then did your make-up flawlessly and put in your red strappy heels even though no one could see them. You wore red dangly earring to top off the outfit, and then you applied some lipstick. You then heard Sam call from the bottom of the stairs that led to yours and his shared bedroom, "Hey Y/N, we should probably get going." "Okay, I'm coming!" you called back.

You checked your appearance one more time in the mirror before walking down the stairs. As you descended the stairs, you noticed that Dean was there talking to Sam. You kept walking and Sam stopped talking to his brother when he noticed you. He was speechless.

You approached him and asked, "Ready?" Sam didn't respond though, he just continued to look at your beauty. "You know Y/N, it's not to late to choose the other Winchester brother," Dean joked. You laughed and Sam said, "Heyy." Dean just shrugged his shoulders with a smile and walked away.

"You look absolutely gorgeous," Sam told you. You smiled and replied, "You look pretty handsome yourself." He smiled and then offered his arm for you to take, which you gladly did. Sam led you to the Impala which Dean was letting him borrow and he opened the door for you.

You got in and soon so did Sam. He started driving to the restaurant was a little bit far away from the Bunker, but you didn't mind. You enjoyed talking to Sam the whole way. Sometimes you and him needed a nice break like this from hunting.

Sam arrived at the restaurant a while later and he parked the car and went around and opened the door for you. You gladly got out and Sam interlaced his fingers with yours. You walked into the restaurant, and after ten minutes, you were seated. It was a nice restaurant with low lighting and fancy dining ware. The entire building looked elgantly simple.

The waiter led you and Sam to your table which was in the middle of a room with many other tables in it. But, the table next to your right was empty. Sam thanked the waiter and then you say down, and Sam pushed your chair in for you before sitting down as well.

The waiter came back, and Sam ordered some wine for you and him. The waiter nodded his head and left and Sam looked back at you with a smile. "I'm glad that we're doing this," he told you. "Me too. Sometimes I just need to get away from it all, you know?" you replied. "Yeah, believe me, I know," Sam responded.

You smiled softly and Sam took your hand in his. Just then, a different waiter led another couple to the table next you. It was a beautiful woman with black curly hair and a man with brown hair and blue eyes. "Sam?" the woman asked.

Sam looked over at the woman and his eyes widened in shock. "Amelia?" he asked. You looked at the both of them confused and Sam noticed. "Oh, Y/N, this is Amelia, my ex, and her husband, Don," Sam explained. You smiled and offered them your hand for them to shake, but Amelia just gave you a small smile as she sat down while Don shook your hand.

"So how long have you been dating?" she asked you. "A few years," you replied. "What? That's impossible, Sam and I only dated a couple of years ago," Amelia replied, confused.

Sam sighed as he looked down and you looked at him. "Oh, well, Sam and I had a falling out a couple of years ago, that's probably when you and him for together," you responded.

It was true. When Dean had gone to purgatory, you and Sam had been dating at the time, and you wanted to help Sam but he wouldn't let you. He was mad at everyone for letting his brother die, and blamed himself and you for it. So, he left you and went to another town. When Dean came back, he made Sam find you and Sam has been trying to make it up to you for leaving ever since. Conveniently, however, both Sam and Dean forgot to mention the fact that he dated someone else during that time.

"So, how did you and Sammy meet?" you asked Amelia. "Oh, he hit a dog and brought it into the animal shelter I was working at. We kind of just instantly clicked," Amelia answered with a smile. "So, why did it end between you two?" "Because when Amelia first started dating Sam, she thought I was dead but then I came back and she realized that we belonged together," Don replied.

"Or that she had a responsibility to you," Sam muttered, though it was very audible to everyone. "I'm sorry what was that Sam?" Don asked. "I'm just saying you came back to your wife who thought you were dead and see her with another man. Of course she felt guilty. How do you know she just didn't choose you because she owed it to you?" Sam replied. Suddenly, the waiter came over and started to pour you some wine but you told him, "Just leave the bottle." He chuckled as he set the bottle down at your request and then left.

You looked at the other three people who were sitting there and Amelia said, "Sam, I did love you. But I also loved Don, and he was my husband for a reason." Sam just signed and you looked at the group of people. They all had history, but you didn't know the couple, only Sam did. So, you stood up and told them, "Thank you for the lovely dinner Sam. I think that I'm going to head home now."

You then started to walk away and Sam followed you. "Y/N," Sam started, but you just said, "We'll talk about this later." Sam nodded his head and you and him walked to the Impala. Sam opened the door for you, and you got in. He got in as well and the ride home was silent.

When you got back to the Bunker, you didn't even wait for Sam to open your door, you just got out and walked inside, up to your bedroom, with Sam following you. "Y/N, please talk to me," Sam said as he shut the door to your guys room. "What do you want me to say Sam?" you asked. Sam just stay silent as you continued, "Sam when Dean went to purgatory I never stopped searching for you. You left me and I never gave up on us. Guys flirted with me at the bars, and every time I would tell them that I was taken. I thought that even though you needed your space that you still loved me, and you were going to come back to me one day.

And then, when you came back and found me, it was the happiest day of my life. But then I find out that the whole time that we were apart, you weren't missing me, you were falling in love with someone else."

Sam looked at you sadly and asked, "You think that I didn't miss you? That I didn't spend every minute of every day wanting to be with you? Y/N, I was hurt. I just lost my brother, and the only reason why I even got together with Amelia was to get over you. Being with you was too hard, because I knew that at any moment I could lose you just like I lost Dean. So, I thought that maybe if I found another girl to be with that wasnt caught up in all of this drama, then all of the pain would go away. So, maybe I tricked myself into thinking I loved her, but in all reality Y/N, even when I was with her I never loved her more than I loved you."

You looked you at Sam and asked, "Then why did you get mad at her husband at dinner?" "Because when she chose him over me I realized how unworthy of love I was, and even still, I don't know why you are with me, Y/N. You are the most beautiful, smartest, sexiest, girl in the world and you could have any guy you wanted. Seeing Amelia with her husband tonight just reminded me of that," Sam explained.

You smiled and walked over to Sam and cupped his face. You pulled him into a loving kiss and when you broke away, you told him, "Sam, I love you, and no matter what you do, that will never change. You are the only man for me, and the truth is that I'm not worthy for your love." Sam could do not nothing but smile and pull you into another kiss. "I'm sorry about tonight," Sam told you.

"It's okay, it just reminded me how much I love you," you replied. And Sam said, "Not as much as I love you." You smiled and you and Sam spent the rest of the night showing each other how much you each meant to each other.

Hello my little monsters,

Second Imagine -- what did you think? Thank you all so much for your reads votes and comments. I love you all so much and all of you are amazing!

Always Keep Fighting!