Dean

You and Dean had been casually hanging out for a while. He admitted that he wanted more, but you refused. He disappeared for a long amount of time and came back beaten up. You needed to know what he does when he's away if you were going to move forward with him. You told Dean that and he got irritated and left. It was now midnight and you were getting ready for bed when you heard a knock at your door. When you opened it, Dean was there.

"If you want to know what I do when I'm gone, then I'll tell you." Dean told you calmly.

"Come in Dean." You led Dean to your couch and sat down.

"I'm a hunter. I hunt monsters with my brother. I save people. That's what I do when I'm gone." Dean said simply.

"Monsters? Like bad people?"

"No, like vampires, werewolves, shapeshifters. That type of monster."

"Why should I believe you?"

"You don't have to, but you wanted to know." With that Dean stood up. "Think about it. I'll see you later, or not if you don't want to see me again." Dean kissed your cheek then left you alone in your living room.

Sam

Ever since Sam needed help with research on a werewolf, he's asked you for help with a few other beings. He kept telling you that it was for a school paper, but you knew he was lying. Once he got the information he needed, he would leave for a few days just to return hurt in some way. You told same that you knew he was lying to you and to either tell the truth or stop asking you for help. You were in his motel room with him, waiting for his response.

"Okay (Y/N), I'll tell you." Sam started, "My brother and I hunt monsters. The kinds you've helped me research. We save people." Sam explained hoping you'd believe him.

"So this is real?" You asked pointing to a wendigo.

"Yeah, all of it is real."

"You're insane...but I believe you. So I guess I'm insane too." You smiled at him. You could see he was relieved that you believed him.

"Thank you."

"When can I meet your brother?" you could see Sam's eyes widen.

"Never?" You two chuckled, but you were going to meet him. You have your own way to get what you want.

Castiel

You and the clueless man began spending a lot of time together. You'd go to a park and feed the ducks or go to a playground and swing on the swings. One of the days you were at the park, you decided to jump off of the swing. You landed wrong and it caused you to break your ankle.

"(Y/N), it'll be okay." Castiel told you as he appeared at your side.

"What? No it won't!" You were in serious pain and close to crying.

"Trust me (Y/N)." Castiel reached out and laid a hand on your ankle. His hand began to glow and you felt your ankle snap back into place, and heal completely.

"What...How did you do that? What are you?" You were freaked out and scared, but thankful.

"I'm an angel of the Lord."

"Prove it, if you're an angel, then where are your wings?" A moment later Castiel showed you the shadow of his wings. "Holy shit...literally..."

"I understand if you don't wish to be around me any longer." You smiled and kissed Castiel's lips.

"You clueless angel, I'll always want to be around you."

Crowley

You enjoyed your past year with your family. You weren't sure what was going to happen, but you were scared. You didn't want to die.

"Hello darling." Crowley's voice suddenly said from behind you. You were in your room pacing, so you just spun around.

"How'd you get in here?" You demanded, a little scared.

"I'm a demon, I can do almost anything."

"Are you here to kill me?"

"Oh heavens no. I'm here to make you my queen."

"What?"

"I'm not just a demon darling, I'm the king of Hell. As payment for your deal, you will become my queen."

"I guess I don't have a choice, so alight." You smiled at him. You were glad you didn't have to die, though you were scared about what being with the king of Hell could do to you.

Balthazar

Balthazar and you had hung out/went on a date a few times. It was always beautiful and amazing, but you would never remember how you got there. Once second you would be at your or Balthazar's house and then the next, you'd be at your date location. You finally decided to question how it was possible. You two were at Balthazar's mansion, he was drinking wine and you were reading a book.

"Balthy?" You started sweetly.

"Yes my dear? What is it?" Balthazar didn't look up from his wine as he spoke.

"How do we get to our dates?"

"What do you mean?"

"You know what I mean. It seems like you can just appear or disappear whenever you want. How is that possible?" You moved over to Balthazar and took his wine from him so he'd focus.

"I'm an angel darling. I have wings therefore I can fly."

"You what now?" You took a step away from him. He sighed, stood up and revealed a shadow of his wings.

"Now may I have my wine back?"

"No, I need it." You mumbled as you drank his glass. You then grabbed the whole bottle. "I need this too." You couldn't believe he was an angel. He seemed as impure as anyone could be.

Gabriel

You and Gabriel were hanging out and eating candy on the floor of your bedroom. You were talking about his trickster ways and what he planned to do next.

"So Gabe, you're and Archangel, right?" You suddenly asked.

"Yup cupcake, I am. Why?" Gabriel responded as he took a bite of a candy bar.

"Where's your wings. I want to see them."

"Huh? You can't see them?" He then chuckled. "They'd burn your eyes out babe, but you can see this." He revealed to you the shadow of his wings.

"Wow Gabe, those are huge!" You commented about his wings.

"That's not the only huge thing on me." He gave you his wiggly eyebrow look.

"Gross Gabe." You replied, chuckling.

Lucifer

When you were with Lucifer, people in suits came and went. They'd ask him questions or need him to order people around. You began to become curious about who he was and who they were.

"Luci? Can I ask you something?" you asked after a few people came and left.

"Of course my little human. What is it?" He looked up at you from the book he was reading.

"Well that. Why do you call me that? What do all these people do for you and who are they?" You closed the book you were reading as you talked.

"Demons. They serve me because I created them. I am the devil, the Archangel Lucifer. You're the only human here."

"Those are demons."

"Yes."

"You're an Archangel."

"That's what I said."

"Well then... that's not what I expected but okay." You went back to reading your book.

"What did you think I was?" It was Lucifer's turn to be curious.

"A drug dealer, or a mob leader. I'm glad you're better than those." Lucifer's only response was to look at you like you were crazy.

Kevin

After the two men left and you and Kevin talked about the kiss, you needed him to answer more important questions.

"Who were those men? Why are you and your mother wanted?" You demanded. Kevin kept trying to avoid the questions, but you weren't having any of it. "No Kevin, either tell me or get lost."

"Okay, okay, I'll tell you (Y/N). I'm a prophet. Those men were demons. They need me to translate a tablet from God."

"Seriously? If you two are some kind of serial killers, just tell me."

"I'm telling you the truth. Please, you have to believe me. I wouldn't lie to you baby." You carefully watched Kevin as he spoke. You weren't sure you believed him totally, but you did trust him.

"Alright, well how do we keep them away from you?" Kevin smiled at you, he was happy you weren't kicking him out and that you weren't accusing him of being a liar.

Chuck

(I believe Chuck is God, but for the sake of my writing, he's just a prophet.)

You spent many nights with Chuck. In his drunken state he would talk about the end of the world and something called Winchesters. You had no idea what he was talking about though. You saw him go through a horrible nightmare, and then instantly start writing a new chapter to one of his books. It confused and worried you, so you decided to confront him about it.

"Chuck? Are you listening to me?" You asked, when he ignored your other attempts of getting his attention. "Hey?!" You pulled him away from his computer and shook him.

"What (Y/N)! I have to write this now!"

"Why Chuck, what the hell is going on?"

"I'm just a dedicated writer." Even he didn't seem to believe that.

"No, you seem to be something more. Tell me the truth."

"I'm a prophet."

"You...You're a prophet..."

"Yes, I am."

"Okay then...wait you sometimes sleep talk about the apocalypse. Is that really going on? Are you books real?" Chuck had a lot of explaining to do.

Benny

After the two of you got caught together, you were determined to get to the bottom of the blood ordeal.

"Alright Benny. You owe me now." You told him after your friend left.

"I do, how shall I repay you sweetheart?" Benny asked as he collected his blood bags.

"Why? Tell me why you need the blood."

"Not here. Let's go to my truck." Benny went out the window while you went out the actual doors. You met him at his truck. You both got into the back of his truck and closed it up, so no one could see what was going on in it. "Are you sure you want to know (Y/N)?"

"Yes Benny."

"Okay." Benny then let his fangs come out. You froze and stared at them. "I'm a vampire, I don't drink people, so I need the blood bags to survive."

"You...you drink the blood...you're a..." You then proceeded to pass out from shock. That wasn't what you were thinking he was using the blood for. You were thinking satanic sacrifice or something like that. Your last thought before everything went black, was that you hoped h wouldn't drink you while you were unconscious.