This idea belongs to x_xstar1012x_x

Saraya's eyes fluttered open.  She instantly knew something was wrong.  She had a pounding headache.

She groaned, sitting up.  She looked around, and her eyes landed on a pile of clothes on the ground.  Her clothes.

She frowned.  She didn't see Kevin last night, so whose clothes were those?

A cough distracted her, and she turned to find the source of it.  When she saw the two-toned hair, her eyes widened and she jumped out of bed.

"You do realize you're naked, right?"

***

Seth Rollins has been dating his fiancée, Leighla Schultz, for almost six years.  They are in love.  They are soulmates.

Paige has been dating Kevin Skaff for five months.  It may not seem like a long time, but to them, it's been the best five months of their lives.

Paige and Seth hate each other, which confuses all of their friends.  They have such similar interests, and the same friend group, that it only makes sense that they'd be friends.

After a night of drinking, they wake up to find themselves in bed together.  At first, they are both disgusted, but after some talking, they realize what happened.  They've been on the road so much, they miss Leighla and Kevin.

They make two agreements:

1. They won't tell Leighla or Kevin (or anyone) what happened.

2. They'll continue this.  Whenever one of them misses their significant other, or they just really want to have sex, they'll agree to meet.

It all goes as planned for a while; they even manage to become friends. But one day, Paige realizes she doesn't hate him anymore.

In fact, she loves him.

She knows she can't tell Kevin, but that doesn't mean she can't act on her feelings for Seth.

Meanwhile, Seth is trying to keep these feelings hidden.  He loves Leighla.  They are going to get married.  He just sees Paige for the sex.  But soon, he has to make a decision: Paige or Leighla?

***

This is named after the song In The Night by The Weeknd.  Also, Seth is dating Leighla instead of Zahra, because so many people dislike Zahra omg.  And Kevin and Leighla are meant to be likeable people in this story.

As implied, this story would have a lot of sex.  So don't ask for it if you're not interested in/comfortable with writing that.