Stan:

Ya'll were making out and then he realized he was kissing you and he threw up in your mouth. He kept apologizing but like still...

Kyle:

Someone threatened to call the police on a Kyle because he pulled you by the hair and yelled at you. Like it was hella awkward for  you two to have to explain your weird ass relationship

Eric:

Once He got pantsed in front of you, like you can only imagine

Kenny:

His "pet" Possum attacked you, Like was just all like "sksksksksk geeze that was a mistake."

Craig:

He got his braces stuck on one of your shirts, and you had to cut a piece of your shirt off and help him pick out the fabric from his braces. He was so flustered

Tweek:

Once he like tripped once something and spilled Very hot coffee on you he was having a whole panic attack while you were burning and probably screaming

Token:

You guys walked out of like a restaurant or some shit and you had some like white frosting on your mouth and like people were like "Whooooaaaaa Token's gettin sommmeeee." You guys had to explain that is not what happened

Clyde:

One time he sneezed and his snot went into your mouth. Like that shit was nasttyyyyyyyyy. oof ya'll didn't talk to each other for like a whole 3 weeks because of how awkward and embarrassed you guys were

Jimmy:

You were like "You know what we should do?" and he was like "Foot fuck!" That was not what you were implying you guys should do and the whole atmosphere was awkward 

Butters:

You guys were making out and Not one, But BOTH OF HIS FUCKING PARENTS WALKED IN ON YOU TWO HEATEDLY MAKING THE FUCK OUT! His people were not happy and probably thought he was going to hell.