Fluttershy said,"Pinkie, I don't think it's working out with us...." She looked a tiny bit sad,"But I know you'll understand, right? Butterscotch and I are going to be together now and I hope you understand.... " Pinkie plastered a fake smile on her face and snuck a knife in her pocket,"Of course..... Who needs Pinkie when you got him..." Fluttershy smiled and said,"Thanks for understanding..." Not hearing that last part. Pinkie's smile was fake.
Once they were all outside Pinkie asked,"Can I go home with you?" To Butterscotch. He nodded and Fluttershy smiled,"They'll get to know each other better." While they were driving to his house, Pinkie put on some gloves and said,"Can we leave the car for a minute and explore those woods?" Butterscotch nodded,"Sure! Why not?" Butterscotch and Pinkie were deep in the woods, when she pulled out the knife and tapped his shoulder. He turned around and she stabbed him in his heart,"If I can't have Fluttershy, no one can!" The strike killed him instantly, and she picked up the knife and his keys and drove away to her house and she didn't stop. When she got there she his the gloves and knife in the glove box. She heard a scream from inside the house.
She ran in her house and saw her father pointing his gun at her chest, he was drunk! He fired the gun and she fell down to the ground, Pinkie screamed as her sisters ran down the stairs. Pinkie was next to her mom, her mother's last words to her before her death were,"Keep smiling......" Then she died and Pinkie cried, than her father left. He didn't come back for a long time. Marble freaked out, and Limestone yelled, and Maud looked very sadly surprised.