Icestar stared at her, " That's not true! " She yowled in denial. Skystar looked at her, " Ask Kinkpaw, Feathermist, or Hairtail! " Feathermist growled and Kinkpaw shouted, " Its true! " But than realized her mistake and shut her mouth. Hairtail scolded her, and looked back up, dipping his head respectfully, " We are sorry. " Icestar's eyes widened, " We will talk more about this at camp, but you will have to be punished. "  Hairtail growled at Kinkpaw and the young apprentice studied her paws, her ears back in guilt. Skystar finished her report and nodded to Heatherstar, the new Flameclan leader, " Flameclan is well, but our territory is colder that we are used to. "She paused, giving a stare of hatred to Icestar, and than continued, " We are still getting prey, though. " He nodded to the leaders, signaling he was done, and Skystar nodded, " Than this gathering is over! " She yowled, spreading her wings and heaving herself up. Her clan followed close behind and they soon got to the camp, the group went to cats that were left behind to tell them about the gathering. Skystar headed straight to her den after grabbing a mouse, and just sat eating the warm, juicy, mouse. She soon fell asleep in her moss-bed.