For this chapter and the next one the scenarios for the pastas will be in alphabetical order.
As seen:

Ben Drowned
Eyeless Jack
Homicidal Liu
Hoodie
Jeff the killer
Laughing Jack
Masky
Offenderman
Slenderman
Splendorman
Ticci Toby
Trenderman

All of the scenarios are in 2nd POV.
Note: Once I have finished all the scenarios in this chapter there will be a Your POV scene where you defeat Zalgo.
C/P = Your creepypasta character
---------------------------------

BEN DROWNED

You saw Ben lying on the ground nearly unconscious.
"Oh my god! Ben!" You yelled, running to him crouching down next to him.
"Mmmm...Y/N..." He moaned as he held onto his stomach.
You lifted up his shirt to look at his wound.
His skin had been burned severely, his skin looked raw.
Tears formed in your eyes as you stared as Ben.
"Why would you risk your life to save me?" You asked with your voice shaking as you pulled his shirt back down.
Ben lightly smiled as he brought got his hand up to cheek and caressed it.
"Because I love you." He replied staring into your E/C orbs.
You gasped at what he said but then smiled and held his hand as he continued to caress your cheek.
"I-I-love you too."
With that Ben sat up carefully as to not damage himself any more, and he closed the gap between you two.
His lips were soft, like silk and the kiss was full of passion.
You two parted after a couple of seconds and stared at each other.

EYELESS JACK

"EJ!" You yelled as you ran to him, then fell to his side.
The fire burned straight through his hoodie and his shirt, including some of the skin.
A few tears slipped from your eyes as you held onto EJ's hand and stared at him.
His mask was broken in half next to him.
He looked dead, he wasn't responding and he didn't open his eyes.
A few more years slipped away from your eyes as you said "W-Why?"
No response.
You sighed and kissed his cheek, still holding his hand.
After a few seconds EJ opened his eyes and looked at you.
"Y/N." He said gently squeezing your hand.
Your eyes met with his and you two stared at each other.
Something jumped inside both of you, and electric shock would be the only way to describe it.
Then slowly your faces started inching closer and closer together, and soon you two kissed.
EJ's lips were smooth and soft, the kiss was full of love that seemed to have been trapped for years.
A few seconds passed and you broke the kiss for air, staring into EJ's eyes.
"I've been waiting for that since day one." He said smirking.
You only blushed but then looked down at his wound.
"Don't worry about that, I'll be healed soon...eventually at least." He said mumbling the last part.
"Why would you nearly kill yourself for me?" You asked letting go of his hand and looking down.
"Because I love you." And with that you two kissed again.

HOMICIDAL LIU

You fell to the floor when you saw Liu.
His stomach had nearly been eaten by the fire when it hit him. 
You got up and ran to him, then immediately held him in your arms and started crying.
Liu's head rested on your breast and his eyes slightly opened.
He groaned in pain and looked down at his stomach.
"W-What just happened?" He asked trying to sit up.
You sat him upright and replied "Y-You saved m-me and I-I thought you died." You whispered the last part as you looked at Liu with tears welding in your eyes.
His eyes twitched when he saw you nearly crying.
"H-Hey it's alright. I'm fine, don't worry." He said moving closer to you.
You forced a smile but then noticed something, your faces were moving closer and closer to each other.
His emerald eyes didn't look away from your E/C ones.
Seconds later his lips sealed the space between you.
Neither of you wanted to part when your lips touched, it seemed as though he had been eager for that kiss for a long time.

HOODIE

"Brian!" You ran to his side when you saw him.
"Oh my god, oh my god." It felt like time stopped and your heart was beating rapidly.
He laid on the ground, his skin looked nearly burnt to a crisp and he was moaning in pain.
"Y/N..." He cried out your name as you crouched down next to him.
"What the hell is wrong with you? Why would you do that?" You asked looking at him.
He only pointed and tugged at his mask.
You took a deep breathe and carefully pulled off his mask, moving his black hair out of the way of his face.
Without any warning his lips were on yours.
You instantly melted into the kiss and closed your eyes not wanted to part.
But eventually you two parted and started into each other's eyes.
A bright yet weak smile grew on Hoodie's face as he responded to your question earlier.
"That's why."

JEFF THE KILLER

You nearly died when you saw Jeff jump in front of you.
"Jeff." That was the only thing you could say before you knelt down beside him.
You didn't want to look down at his wound, but you did.
The fire almost burnt through his whole lower half of his body.
You looked up at him and saw his eyes closed and he didn't appear to be breathing.
"Dear god." You started to cry as you laid your head on his chest.
Then you felt a hand on your back and you immediately looked up.
Jeff was awake.
"Did you think I was dead?" He asked smirking.
"Yes I did you idiot." You replied now smiling wiping away your tears.
"Your idiot."
That was all Jeff said before he lightly grabbed both sides of your face and pulled you close.
You two had been waiting for that kiss since day one.
Jeff's arm snaked around your waist and pulled you closer deepening the kiss.

LAUGHING JACK

You choked on air when you opened your eyes and saw LJ take the hit for you.
All you could do was hold him in your arms, and that's exactly what you did.
He was slowly breathing, and every breath seemed to have gotten shorter and shorter.
"No no no no." You mumbled rocking back and forth with LJ in your arms.
His was head resting on the crook of your neck.
"LJ." You said as tears trickled down your face.
No response.
You sighed and looked down at where the fire hit him, but only to cry more.
He was dead for sure, the fire was still eating away at his skin.
"Please don't leave me."
You stroked his hair and grabbed his hand gently squeezing it.
Still no response.
You then sighed and looked down at LJ.
His eyes were closed, and he was barely breathing.
You had to accept the fact that the clown might die, the person who's jokes always made you laugh and smile.
"I-I love you LJ." Your voice quivered as you leaned down and kissed him.
But in an unexpected twist, he kissed back!
Your eyes widened in shock and you parted looking at LJ.
His eyes were open!
"I love you too."
You start to cry again but then your tears were wiped away by LJ.
"I would never leave you."
Then you two kissed again, only this time it was longer.

MASKY

Your whole body nearly shut down and collapsed at the sight of Masky.
His mask had been shattered into pieces in it lay scattered all around him.
He was lying on his back with his hands near his stomach.
His stomach had nearly been burnt straight through.
"Timothy..." You mumbled.
He could barely keep his eyes open, his brown orbs met with your E/C ones.
"Y/N..." He moaned your name as he struggled to sit up.
Tears were pricking your eyes as you crouched down next to him and held him in your arms.
"Shhh, I'm here." You cooed stoking his hair.
A smile formed on his lips as he laid his head down on your breasts.
"Is this what heaven is like?" He asked looking up at you.
You didn't respond, you only smiled and kissed his forehead still stroking his hair.
He continued staring into your eyes with his lustful ones, and within a few seconds your faces were only a couple of centimeters apart.
"Y/N..." He closed the gap between you two.
His lips were soft and the kiss was DEFINITELY full of love.
You parted the kiss with your face.
"I love you." Masky said resting his head in your chest.
"I love you too." You replied.

OFFENDERMAN

You couldn't speak, nor could you barely stand.
Offenderman, the most sneaky and sexual guy you know took the deadliest hit for you.
He was holding onto his stomach and whimpering in pain.
"Offender!" You yelled his name collapsed next to him with tears forming in your eyes.
"Y/N." He said looking at you.
You wrapped your arms around his neck and laid your head on his shoulder and began crying.
"W-Why would you do that? Risk your life for me?" You asked between tears.
He only chuckled and wrapped his arm around your waist.
Then he whispered in your ear "Because I love you, and I couldn't bare to see you dead."
You froze at the answer.
"Y-You love me?" You asked lifting your head up and looking at him. He only smirked and nodded.
Without thinking, you smashed your lips onto his.
Offender was shocked at first was then he kissed back and pulled you closer deepening the kiss.
You then parted the kiss after a few seconds for air and rested your forehead on his.

SLENDERMAN

It almost took a minute for your brain to process what just happened.
All you could do was stare.
Slender's body lay on the ground, the fire burned some of his skin and it looked like a peeled tomato, but instead this was actual flesh.
You crouched to Slender's side with tears forming in your eyes.
"S-Slender?" You asked hoping for a response.
There wasn't a response.
Damnit Slender! Don't die on me!
You thought trying to check for a pulse.
You couldn't find one.
Tears were now falling from your face as you rested on Slender's chest.
"Please don't go..." you mumbled as you continued to sob.
A couple minutes passed and here was still no response, you sighed and looked up at Slender's face and placed a soft kiss on his cheek.
You were about stand up but stopped when you heard "I'm not leaving, Y/N."
You didn't even respond or say anything, all you did was wrap your arms around his neck and started sobbing.
"I thought y-you died and y-you l-left me." You said in between sobs.
Slender only chuckled before he wrapped his arms around your waist and replied "I love you too much to leave you."
You then looked up at his and without thinking, kissed him.
He didn't hesitate to kiss back.

SPLENDORMAN

You blinked a few times before even realizing what just happened.
Splendor took the hit for you.
He saved you.
You quickly went to his side, unaware that you were crying.
"Splendor?" Your asked trying to catch your breath.
His hat was tipped forward covering part of his face so you moved it back to its normal position.
His breath seemed to have started slowing down and he wouldn't respond.
"Splendor, please wake up!" You said shaking his arm.
You looked down at his stomach, and it caused more tears to fall from your face.
It was the worst burn you've ever seen, a layer of skin was burned and was still penetrating it.
You weren't certain if Splendor, the most cheerful and happiest guy you know would die.
"Don't go, don't go, don't go..." you kept mumbling this as you wrapped your arms around his neck sobbing.
A couple minutes passed and you were still sobbing.
Suddenly you felt someone touch your back and you jerked up.
Splendor was awake!
"Hey, don't cry." His calmly said as he wiped tears from your face.
"I though you were dead." You replied.
He only chuckled and held his hand on your cheek.
"Then I would never be able to see you smile again."
Without warning he smashed his lips into yours.
He kiss was passionate and you didn't hesitate to kiss back.
Seconds later you parted with a smile on your face.
"That's the smile I like to see."

TICCI TOBY

Toby took the hit for you.
He possibly died saving you.
"Toby!"
Tears streamed down your face as you picked up Toby and held him in your arms.
His goggles lay next to him, one of the lenses cracked down the middle.
"T-Toby." You choked out as you traced his mouthguard and stared at his closed eyes.
You didn't look down at his wound because it would only make you cry more, so you only stared at his face.
His breath grew slow and you thought there was no hope that he would wake up.
You then rested your forehead in his and resumed back to crying.
Suddenly, his eyes shot open.
"Y-Y/N?"
His voiced caused you to jerk up and the tears stopped.
"Toby, oh my god."
You two stared into each other's eyes.
He looked down at his wound, twitched, and tried to sit up but you stopped him.
"No, you'll hurt yourself even more than you already are." You said.
"*hic* I c-can't feel the p-pain though."
You didn't respond, and Toby rested his head in the crook of your neck.
Your heart started racing and you shivered as you could feel his breath on your neck.
Toby then looked up at you.
His eyes pierced yours, they were full of...love?
Then without thinking your carefully took off Toby mouthguard and threw it somewhere.
Seconds later he crashed his lips onto yours.
His lips were soft and you two instantly melted into it.
You then parted from the kiss.
"I love you." You said.
Toby only smiled and replied "I love you too."

TRENDERMAN

Trenderman was someone you never really saw around the mansion, he was either in his room or outside reading a book.
He lay on the ground, next to him were his glasses, broken and shattered into pieces.
Tears were falling from your eyes. 
You knelt down next to him and took his hand in yours, staring at him. 
You didn't look at his wound but you caught a glance of it, it grazed his skin yet it looked like a burnt tomato.
"Trender? Trender can you hear me?" You asked leaning forward and stroking his cheek.
His hand twitched and seconds later a small groan was heard.
"Y/N?" He asked looking at you.
"I can't see, is that you?"
You smiled and replied "Yes Trender, it's me, don't worry I'm here."
He then lifted his hand up and placed it on your cheek.
"You know why jumped in front of you right?"
You shook your head and closed your eyes recalling the event that happened moments ago.
"Because, despite the fact that you never really saw me around the mansion, I was always watching you and I...I love you." He mumbled the last words but he said them loud enough for you to hear as your eyes to shoot open.
You then crashed your lips onto his without thinking.
He instantly kissed back and it felt was the best kiss you've ever had.
You then parted and replied "I love you too."

Your POV (scene where YOU fight Zalgo)

I moved C/P away from the fight, where he wouldn't get hurt in the fight.
"I'm done playing these games!" Zalgo screamed as he walked towards me.
"I don't know why the hell I keep stalling! You haven't even discovered your true power yet!"
Fireballs appeared from his hands and his eyes glowed red.

I closed my eyes and it felt as if time stopped.
In my mind I saw two figures...demons.
They turned and looked at me, and I knew who they were.
"Mom? Dad?" I asked as I walked towards them.
They both smiled warmly and opened their arms as I got near them.
I wrapped my arms around them and started crying.
"My dear Y/N." My mother said as she patted my back "Don't cry."
I lifted my head up and looked at their dead figures.
"You're a very strong girl. We'll always be with you." My father said as he kissed my forehead.
I let go of them and saw they were staring to fade away.
"We want what any normal parents, yes we're demons, but we have hearts full of love. We daughter to grow up strong, and live a normal life." My mother said, her voice fading away.
"Kill Zalgo Y/N, find the power you were born with and protect the ones you cherish." My father said.
Then they were gone.

I opened my eyes, and was met with the same black fireball just inches from me.
I growled and swung my arm at it, it instantly blew up, but no harm was done to me.
Lets finish this.
I started walking towards Zalgo, who was firing more fire at me.
All I did was swing them away, no harm done to me.
"My father told me to protect the one I cherish..." I spoke as I looked as C/P and everyone else.
I caught a glance of Sally at the window, who was staring with pure shock.
I turned back to Zalgo and raised my hands up.
"So that's what I'm going to do."
Fire formed in my hands and I ran at Zalgo at the speed of light.
I struck him in the stomach, he flew and hit some trees, knocking them down with him.
Zalgo jumped back up, fear in his eyes as he raised his hands and started summoning demons.
I continued walking towards Zalgo, the demons he summoned getting closer to me.
I threw a fireball and they all fell dead.
"How is this possible?" He exclaimed as he started backing away.
I smirked and ran at him again.
I appeared behind him he quickly turned around.
I took one step and jumped up, grabbing his horn and leaning close to his ear.
"You talk to much."
I yelled angrily and swung my fist in his face, the fire burning through him as the bones crushed.
Blood spewed everywhere and I jumped kicked off of his body.
His body collapsed on the ground, dead.
I looked back down at his dead body, an aura of fire and power surrounding me, "What a shame, you talked big, but that was easy."

[Edited, June 16th, 2019]