Holly Marie Combs as Elena Graham

Robert Adamson as Reid

(Great representation, except Reid has dark brown/black eyes, not blue.)

Noah Graham

(Arachibutyrophobic, a good friend of mine, specifically requested a faceclaim for little Noah, and although this isn't exactly how I picture the munchkin in my head, he's close enough.)

Blake Lively as Brooke

(I literally can't picture anyone else as Brooke. The difference is simply that Brooke has hazel brown eyes and her hair is an ash brown, slightly darker than Blake's blonde.)

Ralph Fiennes as Victor Martin

Patrika Darbo as Bonnie Mayner

Karen Gilian as Carli Mayner

Eric Allen Kramer as Charlie Mayner

(Only thing I'd change is his eye color to the same as the actress for Carli.)

David Letterman as Will O'Shay

(Except O'Shay is a little more...plump 😅)

Nick Frost as Marcus

(But I picture his beard more like it is in this picture below⬇)

Woody Harrelson as Gordon

(If you're picturing him as Haymitch from THG, then you're picturing right. 😃)

Tom Felton as Evan

Josh Holloway as Fletcher Graham

I honestly didn't think it was possible to find people so close to who I pictured in my head, but here they are! 😍

Was anyone spot on with your imagination, too?

Any castings that surprised you?