You exclaim quietly as your finger pricks something sharp. Grabbing the item you pull out a mechanical pencil. You smack away the twins' hands as they go to push you into the closet again, and you walk in on your own, rolling your eyes at the two gingers.

It takes a minute for the host to enter the closet with you, and you hear muffled arguing outside the door. Who could this be? Suddenly the door is cracked open just enough for the host to be pushed into the room, accidentally falling into you, so you both tumble to the floor.

"Y-Y/N I'm so sorry!" A delicate voice fills the darkness and you grin as you feel the position you two have fallen in, with the host straddling your waist.

"Haruhi, I was supposed to guess." You say in a pouting tone as she moves to stand up. You grab her wrists gently so she stays on top of you.

"I-I'm sorry, those two idiots pushed me in here, because Tamaki-Senpai didn't realize I was playing too, so he was freaking out." Haruhi stops in her movements, shifting slightly so her weight isn't fully on you.

Of course that blonde idiot didn't think Haruhi would be included. You knew she was straight for the most part, but on your girl only sleepovers she had admitted to being bi-curious.

"What, Tamaki didn't like the thought of two girls getting it on in the closet?" You smile up at her, knowing her face is red from embarrassment. You hear her scoff quietly in agreement. Letting go of her wrists, you move yourself up onto an elbow, reaching your other hand up to caress Haruhi's cheek. "So you wanted to test that bi-curiousness in you, huh?"

"W-well, I don't see why not." Haruhi tries to sound indifferent, her hand raising to cup over yours. "I'm not really sure what to do though. I'm pretty inexperienced in this department, both male and female wise."

This makes your smile soften, of course she was inexperienced. "Did you want me to lead then?" You ask softly, and feel her nod under your hand. The both of you changed positions, so instead you were on top of her. You lean down to press a soft kiss on her neck, with Haruhi gasping in response.

Her arms come up to loop around your neck as you begin to kiss and suckle on her supple skin, deciding to have fun and leave a few small marks for Tamaki to freak out over. You enjoy the soft whimpering sounds coming from Haruhi's throat as you make your way along her jaw and slowly to her lips. Hesitating for a moment before pressing them softly against hers.

Haruhi's grip tightens around your neck as she kisses you back with a quiet hunger you didn't realize she had. Letting her lead the kiss, your hand trails up her side to her chest, catching the zipper of her onesie. You feel Haruhi slow in her kiss, and you gently nip her lip to get her attention again as you slowly unzip her pajamas. Haruhi's breath catches in her throat as your hand grazes over her chest, gently fingering the lace on her A-cup bra.

You pull away at this, searching for her eyes in the darkness. "Tell me if you're uncomfortable, okay?" You whisper softly, seeing her silhouette nod as her hand grasps yours, leading it underneath the fabric.

You go back to kissing as the hand not holding you up begins exploring her chest, gently rolling her nipple between your fingers. Enjoying her soft whimpers into your mouth as you fondle her, you shift your weight, so one of your legs was between hers, gently pressing against her groin.

This makes her pull away from your lips, panting quietly. "Th-this is a l-lot better than I was expecting." She breathes out, making you giggle.

"I'll admit, I'm a little experienced." You muse, feeling Haruhi wiggle against your leg in the slightest. "But take it with a grain of salt, I don't need you falling for me when you haven't tasted the other side yet. And you and I both know Tamaki has a huge crush on you."

At this she pauses in her movements, her arms once again draped around your neck, and you can only bet she's blushing red. "Y-yeah, well, he likes you t-too.. You guys were just in here y'know."

"I know he likes me too, but he knows that already. I don't think the blonde idiot's realized he likes you yet, despite all of the obvious ways he acts around you." You smile at her in the darkness as she mulls it over.

"W-well.. Enough about Senpai, can I try kissing you again?" Haruhi asks cutely, making you dip your head in response, capturing her lips once more as you gently squeeze her breast.

You continue to make out and fondle/tease her until Tamaki is rapping on the door, saying we have two minutes left. This made Haruhi jump, accidentally biting down on your lip and causing you to bleed.

"Shit- I-I mean shoot, Y/N-Senpai, I'm sorry." Haruhi says frantically as we both pull away, you gingerly touching your lip.

"Nah, it's okay, Haru." You reply, moving off of her while you suck on your lip.

You hear the zzzzzzip of her onesie as she dresses herself. "Y'know, besides that one girl at the party, that was my first kiss." Haruhi says, making you beam.

"I'm glad I got to be the first~" You coo, pulling the hood of her onesie up and kissing her nose. "Hope I didn't make you fall for me~"

Before she could respond, the door opens and Tamaki is pulling her out of the closet. "What did you two do in there?!" He demands to know, looking at you and glancing to your lip, which you're still currently sucking on.

"Woah, Haruhi, did Y/N give you hickies?" The twins ask, to which Tamaki shrieks, grabbing her to examine her closer. All you can do is laugh at their antics, watching Haruhi stay silent, with a red tint to her cheeks while Tamaki cries to her about her innocence even though you sucked that man dry not even thirty minutes ago.

"I think it'd be best if you chose the next item, Y/N." Kyoya says from beside you, making you look up at him. You smile, reaching your hand into the hat again.

Sorry for the few months of ghosting >< I knew Haruhi was next, and I haven't written girlxgirl before so it took me a fat minute. And then I was obsessed with stardew valley for a while... and playing video games. Anyway here's another chapter! Much love <3