If you want it to be creepier read at night
Tbh its not the best :P

I lost her at a park. My doll. The one I cared so much for. The one that I could talk to and she would listen. I loved playing with her orange pigtailed hair, un braiding it and the braiding it again. I love the way paint looked on her, as if she was wearing real makeup. With her red lips and her roses cheeks and her smile.

Oh her smile.

That's all she ever did.

She smiled.

I loved how no matter what she kept smiling. And her smile made me happy.

But now I lost her...

But that's okay! I can get a new one. That's what daddy said!

He said we could get another one! With the same smile and the same hair. The hair that I could braid.

This one would be new! It would be better!

And so that's what daddy did! He bought me a new one! I kept her with me at all times. I braided her hair, played with her. Did everything I did with my other one!

Tonight daddy was tucking me into bed. He kisses me good night and left my room. I turned around and looked at my new doll. She was so pretty! I hugged her and closed my eyes.

Scratch

Scratch

Something was making a noise.

I looked behind me and looked at my window. I'm not sure why I did.

I saw something. It was small, with very muddy red hair that I would hate to touch.

And chipped paint that made it look like a messy attempt at makeup.

And a smile.

My doll. She stood there scratching at the window. I sat up on my bed and looked toward her.

He head moved ever so slowly.

Her clown like smile stretching across her face.

You replaced me....

I thought I heard something so I looked around. No one was here.

You replaced me....

There it was again! The shadowy whisper echoing in my room.

YOU REPLACED ME!!

I blinked for a second. And there she was. Standing on my bed side table. Her head slowly moved to face me.

YOU REPLACED ME! NOW I SHALL REPLACE YOU!

Lighting flashed illuminating her face. The chipped paint.

The messy hair.

Her happy....no....her crazed smile. It was the last thing I saw. Her clown like face brightened by the light of the storm.

This is one that o made.... It was A LOT creepier in my head.. Seriously I was flinching at every sound

Well I hope you enjoyed this one!