Charlie pulls out a chair from one of the other tables , linking it to the table Sam is sitting beside. Since the Table only occupied 2 seats She had no choice in the matter. Gabriel had already seated Himself down in front of Sammy , His eyes focusing on Sams bruises. He could not look away. Sam tried covering them again however, it did not stop Gabriel from looking away.

Sam gave Charlie an additional stare as She does in return, before turning to look at Gabriel.

" So ... Since no one is going to speak , I guess I should begin ? ... " She sighs , helping Herself to Sams coffee. He didn't seem to care.

" Sammy's in an abusive relationship , with a Man named Lucifer. " She said bluntly.

This caused Gabriel's eyes to widen , It was not a shocked expression , more focused and aware. Sam was unable to speak , He was unsure of what to say or do. On the other hand , a part of him was relieved; Scared. I guess what Sam was really scared of is starting a new relationship. If He ever did leave Lucifer, would His new lover be the same way ?

Charlie could feel the intensity , She decided to pause for a couple of moments before continuing on with Her explanation .

" Sam doesn't think its abusive , thinks He can ' fix Him ' " She quoted with Her fingers.

" It gets worse by the day , Sam comes into work with new Bruises, He try's to avoid questions. I recently found out the Man sometimes leaves home for days on end and comes back whenever He feels like it " She finishes , taking note that Sam was looking away towards the wall at this point. 

Gabriel closes His eyes , taking in a deep breath before beginning to speak. " Is it Lucifer Novak ? " He asks , Sam turning His attention back to Gabriel with a confused expression.

" Yeah ?.. " Sam replied , causing Gabriel to curse slightly under His breath. " You know Him ? " Sam asks.  Approximately ten seconds of silence passed by before Gabriel responded. 

" I'm sorry Sam ... He's my Brother " Gabriel says apologetically. All Sam could do was stare, even Charlie was taken a back at this.

" Wow this is some plot twist " She blurts out accidentally , the two Men looking at Her with a ' What the Hell ' expression. " Ooops ignore Me ... Got carried away there. " She raised Her hands up in defence before folding them. Sam shook His head briefly before turning His attention back to Gabriel.

" That explains why You look so shocked earlier " Sam points out as Gabriel leans back in His Chair.

" No .. I'm just ... Angry ? ...Feeling Guilty ? " Gabriel pauses.

" Guilty ? Why ? Because you hit on your Brothers Boyfriend ? " Charlie asks.

" No , for not finding Sam first. " Gabriels voice almost broke. His emotions were all over the place.  " For being Lucifers Brother ... And  "

" H-Hey its okay ! " Sam grasps Gabriels hands , leaning forward slightly as He makes eye contact. " You don't have to feel responsible because He is your Brother "

" You don't know what happened growing up with Him ... " Gabriel spoke, His voice still cracking.

" Whatever happened , does not excuse Him to ... Do such harsh things " Sam pauses for a moment.

" He's right Gabes , Lucifer chose to be this way " Charlie added , finishing up Sams coffee.

" You don't understand , I did nothing to help Him ... " Gabriel finally broke , He takes His hands back from Sam to cover His face.  Sam and Charlie just watch Him , letting Gabriel pour out all of His emotions. Charlie rubs the mans back , sighing contently. Sam did not move a muscle , He began reminiscing about Lucifer ...

Sam could see Himself in Gabriel , becoming more aware of how Broken He had become... Taking note on how Poisonous Lucifer really is. Sam always kept telling Himself that Lucifer was not always so horrid ... Sam blamed Himself for not being good enough. Turns out , Lucifer tortured other people; His own family. Did His family do this to Him ? Did they create such a monster ?

" Gabriel , what exactly happened to Lucifer ? " Sam asks , Gabriel had barely finished crying. Charlie had handed Him tissues to wipe His face with.

" Our Father " Gabriel mumbled behind the tissue. " That's all I'm going to say "

" It's okay , You don't have to tell me anything ... I wont push you " Sam smiles gently.

Gabriel finally brings His attention back to Sam , shaking His head ever so slightly. Gabriel still could not believe it , What His Brother had done. What His Brother was doing to Him.

" He should be taking His anger out on His family ... Not His lover "Gabriel sighs , again wiping His eyes.

" It wasn't love ... Not for Him anyway ... " Sam pauses turning over towards Charlie " I'm Sorry "

" You have nothing to be sorry for ..." Charlie smiles softly. Did Charlie feel helpless too ?

" You told me to get away , and I didn't ... " Sam argued , " I ... I pushed away my friends to be with Him ... "

" That's what You do when You're in love " Charlie again smiles , patting the tall Winchester on the back reassuringly   " You loved Him Sammy , when a threat arises you fight back ... "

" The threat was Lucifer ... He had me stuck in a cage like some animal ... " Sam whimpers , trying to hold back His tears.

" And now You're free " Charlie glances at Gabriel , urging Sam to turn and Look at Him also. 

" Sam , I can't take away what my Brother put You through ... I may not make You forget either... However, If You allow me to be apart of Your life ... Look Sammy will You have another drink with Me sometime ? .... " Gabriel rubs the back of His neck nervously.

All Sam could do was stare , again , not realising the smile appearing on His face as usual. Charlie smiles like an Idiot as She looks back and forth awaiting His response. She nudges Him as She notices Sam was too much in shock.

" O-Of course ...! " Sams smile widens along with Gabriels.

" Wow finally , Jesus Sammy You do stare a lot " Charlie jokes as Sam blushes at the comment.