"No kidding." Hermey said. "Where are we?" Rudolph asked.  They see a castle on top of a high peak. Then, Yukon points up to the sky, where a winged lion is flying. "Hey, looky up there." "Oh..."" Stepping back, Hermey bumps into a purple box, causing the lid to pop up, and a figure to suddenly emerge from it. "Halt! Who goes there?" "Us, of course. Who'd you think?" Yukon asked. Y/N mentally face palmed. 'Yeah, like he's gonna know who we are' "Oh well, that's okay." He suddenly caught himself. "Okay? Who, may I ask, are you?" "We're Rudolph, Y/N, Hermey, and Yukon Cornelius, sir. Who are you?" Rudolph asked. "I'm the official sentry of the Island of Misfit Toys." He declared.  "A jack-in-the-box for a sentry?" Hermey asked. "Yes. My name is-- " "Jack, right?" Y/N asked.

"No. Charlie. That's why I'm a misfit toy. My name is all wrong. No child wants to play with a "Charlie-in-the-box", so I had to come here." "Where's here?" Hermey asked.
Other misfit toys are appearing out from their boxes, and begin to sing.
Toys: (female voices) ♪"We're on the island of misfit toys. Here we don't want to stay.♪
Toys: (male voices): ♪"We want to travel with Santa Claus..."♪
Toys: (all together) ♪"In his magic sleigh."♪
Nesting Clowns toy: (singing, as it is opening to reveal graduating sized clowns, until the smallest is, instead, a wind-up mouse) ♪"A pack full of toys. means a sack full of joys. For millions of girls. And for millions of boys."♪
Toys: (singing) ♪"When Christmas day is here. The most wonderful day of the year."♪
Male voice-over: (singing as a blue bear with wings, hops onto the lid of Charlie's box, causing Charlie to emerge) ♪"A jack-in-the-box waits for children to shout." ♪
Doll: (speaking) "Wake up! Don't you know that it's time to come out?"
Toys: (singing) ♪"When Christmas day is here. The most wonderful day of the year.Toys galore scattered on the floor. There's no room for more, and it's all because of Santa Claus."♪
Scooter: (singing) ♪"A scooter for Jimmy."♪
Doll: (singing) ♪"A dolly for Sue."♪
Toys: (singing) ♪"The kind that will even say:"♪
Doll: (speaking) "How do you do?"
Toys: (singing) ♪"When Christmas day is here. The most wonderful day of the year."♪
(Toys start speaking):
Spotted elephant: "How would you like to be a spotted elephant?"
Train: "Or a choo-choo with square wheels on your caboose?"
Water pistol: "Or a water pistol that shoots jelly?" (shoots grape jelly on Hermey's face, and Rudolph licks it off)
Spotted elephant, Train, Water pistol (saying in unison): We're all misfits!
Misfit Bird: "Would you like to be a bird that doesn't fly? I swim!"
Cowboy: "Or a cowboy who rides an ostrich?"
Boat: "Or a boat that can't stay afloat?"
(In unison): "We're all misfits!"
Toys: (singing) ♪"If we're on the Island of Unwanted Toys, we'll miss all the fun with the girls and the boys. When Christmas day is here. The most wonderful, wonderful, wonderful, wonderful, Wonderful day of the year"♪

"Hey, we're all misfits, too. Maybe we could stay here for a while?" Y/N asked. "Well, You'd have to get permission from King Moonracer." Charlie said. "Who's he?" Rudolph asked. "He rules here. Every night, he searches the entire earth. When he finds a misfit toy, one that no girl or boy loves, he brings it here to live on this island 'til someone wants it. He's holding court in his castle right now." The quartet go into the throne room, where King Moonracer is seated on his throne. "Come closer." They do so. "What do you desire?" "Well, we're a couple of misfits from Christmastown, and now we'd like to live here." Rudolph explained. "No. That would not be possible. This island is for toys alone." King Moonracer said. "How do you like that? Even among misfits, you're misfits." Yukon complained. "Unlike playthings, a living creature cannot hide himself on an island. But, perhaps, being misfits yourselves, YOU might help the toys here." He suggested. "Help them?" Y/N asked.

"Yes. When someday you return to Christmastown, would you tell Santa about our homeless toys? I'm sure HE could find little boys and girls who would be happy with them. A toy is never truly happy until it is loved by a child." King Moonracer explained. "When and if we ever get back, we'll tell Santa, sir." Rudolph promised. "Good. You are free to spend the night." He claps his front paws twice. "Footman!" A spotted elephant appears. "Show our friends to their chambers." Y/N, Rudolph, Hermey, and Yukon are now tucked in for the night. "No. It's all settled. We leave tomorrow together." Hermey told the two reindeer.  "But the Abominable will see our noses and get us all. We've got to go alone." Rudolph argued. "Nonsense. It's all for all... I mean, one..." Yukon's eyes close. "Ahh, let's get some shut-eye." "But--" Y/N tried to protest. "It's all settled." Hermey clicks off the light and he and Yukon fall asleep, snoring loudly. As they were asleep, Rudolph and Y/N quietly sneak out, and ride through the waters on an iceberg.

"Good-bye, Cornelius. We hope you find lots of tinsel. Goodbye, Hermey. Whatever a dentist is, we hope, someday, that you're the greatest." They see the Aurora Borealis lighting the nighttime sky, and hear the distant roar of Bumble. Rudolph and Y/N are playing with the polar bear cubs, but then their mother growls, telling them to leave. But it wouldn't last long, and they would be on their own again. But during all that time, a strange and wonderful thing was happening... they were growing up, and growing up made them realize that you can't run away from your troubles. And pretty soon they knew where they had to go: home. When Rudolph and Y/N return to Christmas Town, the other reindeer begin to make fun of them again.

"You two! I thought you were both gone for good. Hey, look who's back: old Neon Noses!" The others laughed and Rudolph and Y/N glared at them, then enters their cave. "Mom? Pa? We're home!" Rudolph shouted. "They're gone, Rudolph. They've been gone for months, out looking for you two." Santa informed. "Clarice?" Y/N asked. "She's gone, too, and I'm very worried. Christmas Eve is only two days off, and without your father, I'll never be able to get my sleigh off the ground." Santa said. "Gone? We'll find him, sir. We'll find them all." Rudolph promised. Before they knew it, they were in the middle of a terrible snowstorm. A shingle from the castle's roof blows away. The wind blows away two Eskimos and their igloo. The storm of storms, and only two days before Christmas Eve. Christmas trees are being denuded of their ornaments, and elves are struggling to hold on to their packages.

Rudolph and Y/N look inside, and to see their parents and Clarice being held captive by Bumble. Bumble picks up Clarice. "Put her down!" Y/N demanded. Y/N charges at Bumble. "Y/N!" Rudolph quickly ran after her, but Bumble breaks off a stalactite and uses it as a club, knocking Y/N out. That was their last chance. Not quite. You see, ever since Rudolph and Y/N left them, Hermey and Yukon Cornelius had tried to find their friends. Well, they arrived in Christmastown just as the storm hit, and it was a good thing that I sent them right out after Rudolph and Y/N. Hermey points to the Bumble's cave. "Hey, look!" "Whoah! WHOAH! Un-mush, will ya?!" They approach the cave's entrance and peek in. "I've got an idea. Listen." Yukon  whispers into Hermey's ear. "Uh-huh. Yes. And then?" Yukon whispers again. "Not bad. It might work." Inside, the three reindeer surround Y/N's unconscious body. "Oh, why doesn't she wake up?" Rudolph cried. Y/N wakes up. "Rudolph? Pa? Ma? Clarice!" She said. "Are you sure we can get him to come out here?" Yukon climbs up onto the top of the cave's entrance. "Never knew the Bumble snow monster yet who'd turn down a pork dinner for deer meat. Do your stuff!" Hermey makes pig noises.

"Put some heart in it! That Bumble's hungry!" Hermey oinks loudly, turning Bumble's attention away from the reindeer. As Bumble emerges, Yukon uses his pickaxe to drop a boulder on him. "Wahoo! Terrible weather we've been having. Snow and ice! All right, dentist, you take it from here!"Hermey gets to work with his huge pincers. "It's Yukon Cornelius!" Rudolph said. "Ta-da! In person." He said. "We're saved!" Clarice said.  "Let's get outta here." Donner said. Bumble re-enters his cave, blocking their path. "Why, blast your hairy bumble hide." Yukon said. Hermey walks underneath Bumble. "Don't let this big blowhard scare you anymore. Just walk right past him."

Bumble gropes inside his mouth, and discovers that he is now toothless. "I tell you, you're looking at a mighty humble bumble." Bumble roars. "He's nothing without his choppers. Let me at him. Wahoo!" Yukon and his dogs begin driving Bumble backwards to the edge of the cliff. They launch themselves at Bumble, causing all of them to fall off the cliff. "YUKON!" Rudolph, Hermey and Y/N shouted. "He's gone! Oh, he's gone!" Y/N cried. Well, they are all very sad at the loss of their friend, but they realize that the best thing to do is to get the women back to Christmas Town. So, they make it back, and when everybody hears their story, they start to realize maybe they were a little hard on the misfits. Maybe... misfits have a place, too. Even Santa realizes that maybe... HE was wrong." "Rudolph, Y/N, I promise, as soon as this storm lets up, I'll find homes for all those misfit toys." "All right. You can open up a dentist office. Next week, after Christmas." "Come here. Open your mouth." He does so. "Oh, dear. Tsk tsk tsk. I'd better set up an appointment for you: week from Tuesday, 4:30-- sharp!" "And I'm sorry, too, Rudolph, Y/N, for the way I acted." Donner apologized.

A loud knock is heard on the doors, and a man's voice is heard. "Open up! It isn't a fit night out for man nor beast!" Two elves open the doors, letting in a swirl of snow, and Yukon Cornelius, accompanied by his five dogs, enters. "Here's the man..." he pulls on a rope to reveal Bumble. "And here's the beast!" Everyone gasped in panic. "Now, calm down, calm down. I reformed this Bumble! He wants a job. Looky what he can do!" Bumble places a star on the top of the Christmas tree and everyone gasped in awe. "And he doesn't even need a stepladder!" "But...but...you went over the side of the cliff!" Rudolph pointed out.  "Didn't I ever tell you about Bumbles? Bumbles bounce!" Everyone laughed.

Time Skip

Santa and Mrs. Claus are in their dinning room. "Eat, Papa, eat." Mrs. Claus ordered.  "How can I eat? That silly elf song is driving me crazy." Santa complained. "You're going to disappoint the children. They expect a fat Santa." Mrs. Claus reminded. "Latest weather report, sir." An Aviator Elf informed. "Well, this is it. The storm won't subside by tonight. We...we'll have to cancel Christmas." He said sadly. "Papa, are you sure?" Mrs. Claus asked. "Everything's grounded! Oh, the poor kids. They've been so good this year, too. But I couldn't chance it. I'll have to tell everybody that it's all off this year." He goes to the big Hall, where everybody is busily working. "Quiet! Quiet! Please, everybody quiet! Quiet! I've got some bad news, folks. Christmas is going to be canceled." Everybody gasps. "There's nothing I can do. This weather--" just then, Rudolph's and Y/N's noses glow near Santa's face. "Rudolph, Y/N, please! Could you tone it down a bit? I mean, those noses of yours. I--" he gazes in amazed realization. "Those noses! Those beautiful, wonderful noses!"

"Huh?" Rudolph and Y/N asked in sync. "Rudolph, Y/N, Christmas is not off, and you're going to lead my team!" "We are?" Rudolph asked. "Yes, sir." Their noses glow brighter. "You and those wonderful noses of yours." ""Our noses, sir?" Y/N asked. "Ho, ho, ho! From what I see now, they'll cut through the murkiest storm they can dish up. What I'm trying to say is... Rudolph and Y/N with your noses so bright, won't you guide my sleigh tonight?" He asked. The two looked at each other, then back at Santa. "It will be an honor, sir." They say together.

Everyone cheers "I knew those noses would be useful someday. I knew it all along!" Donner said pridefully. Everyone loads presents onto Santa's sleigh, and they begin to sing, accompanied by Sam, who is outside at one of the windows.
♪"Have a holly, jolly Christmas..."♪
♪"It's the best time of the year.♪ (Hermey picks up an ornament, and Bumble lifts him up to the Christmas tree)
♪"I don't know if there'll be snow, but have a cup of cheer.
(Tall Elf is carrying a load of presents. A girl elf walks past him, and he bumps into a reindeer, dropping his pile of presents.)
♪"Have a holly, jolly Christmas..."♪
♪"And when you walk down the street. Say "hello" to friends you know, and everyone you meet♪
(Yukon and Boy elves are hanging mistletoe)
♪Ho, ho, the mistletoe. Hung where you can see. Somebody waits for you Kiss her once for me"♪ (Rudolph kisses Clarice on the cheek, and Y/N squeals quietly)
♪"Have a holly, jolly Christmas..."♪
♪And in case you didn't hear..."♪
♪"Oh, by golly Have a holly, jolly Christmas this year."♪
(All eight reindeer are lining up in front of the sleigh, with an elf wearing sunglasses standing near Rudolph's nose)
Elves: ♪"Holly, jolly Holly, jolly. Oooohhhhhh".♪
All: ♪"Have a holly, jolly Christmas..."♪
♪"And in case you didn't hear..."♪
♪"Oh, by golly Have a holly, jolly Christmas this year."♪

Santa, now fat after eating his food. "Ho, ho, ho, ho! Ho, ho, ho, ho!" "Eat now. Ho ho ho later. Let me check. Turn." Mrs. Claus said. Santa turns "Aw, Mama!" "Now, shake when you laugh." Mrs. Claus instructed. "Ho, ho, ho, ho. Ho, ho, ho, ho! Ho, ho, ho, ho!" "Now, that's my Santa." Mrs. Claus said. "Thanks, Mama. My coat! Ready, Rudolph? Y/N" "Ready, Santa!" They called.

"Well, let's be on our way! Okay, Rudolph, Y/N. Full power! Their noses glow. Two of the elves open the doors. "First stop, the Island of Misfit Toys. Up, up, up, and away!" "They'll be heroes after this." Clarice said. "Yes, heroes."  "That's my kids!" "Now, you see how it's done? Wahoo!" Yukon throws his pickaxe, and THIS time... "Peppermint! What I've been searching for all my life! I've struck it rich! I've got me a peppermint mine!" Hermey tumbles backwards down onto the snow in pretended amazement, and then gets up with his smile. "Wahoo!!!"

"Well, it's Christmas Eve, but..." Charlie said sadly. "Looks like we're forgotten again." The Spotted elephant said. "But Rudolph and Y/N promised we'd go this time." The doll reminded. "Guess the storm was too much for them." Charlie dismissed.  High in the sky, bright lights are showing, and jingle bells are heard. Charlie sinks down into his box. "Might... Might just as well go to bed and start dreaming about next year."

"I haven't any dreams left to dream. We'll never get off this island. Never." The doll said tearfully.  The Spotted elephant hears the jingle bells. "Wait a minute. What's that? Is it...is it..." Charlie happily hops. "It sure is! It's Santa! And look! Rudolph and Y/N are leading the way!" "You can see their noses from here." The doll said. The sleigh lands and comes to a stop beside them. "Well, let's be on our way." The toys quickly jump into Santa's sack. "Ready, Rudolph? Y/N?" "Ready, Santa!" "Okay, Rudolph, Y/N, Full power!" Their noses glow. "Up, up, up, and away!" Well, folks, as for the rest of the story...

"They went down in history"♪