Y'all, your girl just Slayed her Prelims!!!

Author:- Sohinigoswami
Book:- Mr. Peter

Alright, bestie, buckle up because this roast is about to take flight—unlike poor Peter Peter by the end of this chaotic word salad. What starts as a whimsical jaunt into Neverland quickly devolves into a Shakespearean fever dream, sprinkled with gothic melodrama and topped off with a plot twist so wild it could only come from a sleep-deprived poet. The metaphors are dense, the pacing is unhinged, and the emotional whiplash is strong enough to leave even the lost boys reeling. Let’s dive in and dissect this glittery mess of despair, one tangled metaphor at a time.

.　 . • ☆ . ° .• °:. *₊ ° . ☆

Oh, bestie, this is such a chaotic masterpiece that it feels like Peter Pan crashed into a gothic poetry slam and dragged Bluebeard along for the ride! The sheer whirlwind of metaphors, random plot twists, and over-the-top imagery makes it as exhausting as it is entertaining. Let’s break this fever dream down, shall we?

First off, the opening lines scream "mystical Pinterest quotes gone rogue." The imagery of "captive fantasies in an ornate gale" and "lost boys on swings" is whimsical, sure, but what’s the vibe here? Fairy tale? Dystopia? Existential crisis? The metaphors are so dense that by the time Peter is flying "towards the town's crown," my brain was too tangled in the ornate web of your words to care. And let’s not forget the very sudden shift from Neverland to a wounded girl’s melodramatic stare-off with Peter—like, girl, we didn’t even get to settle into Neverland's aesthetics before you threw her into a full-blown existential decision.

Moving on, the narrative pace is like a caffeinated squirrel—bounding wildly from poetic musings to bizarre tonal whiplash. One second, Wendy is "moonstruck" and swooning over Peter’s honeyed tongue, and the next, she’s being evicted from Neverland by "peacekeepers" for sins we barely understand. What even is the sin? Love? Yearning? Asking Peter to Venmo her some emotional stability? And the siren-death subplot? ICONICALLY unnecessary. You’ve got fairies dying, Neverland drowning in metaphysical blood, and Tinkerbell taking a ForeverNap™, but no emotional payoff because the pacing gives us zero time to care.

Finally, what even is that Bluebeard twist? You took a sad boy Peter Pan and turned him into a murderous doctor with a tragic grooming routine. Like, was the moral of this fever dream "don’t trust men with unresolved trauma and questionable facial hair"? The idea of Neverland devolving into chaos and Peter spiraling into villainy is cool, but it’s buried under too many layers of unnecessary imagery and subplots. My advice? Pick a theme, stick with it, and let your characters breathe instead of drowning them in poetic quicksand. Also, maybe let Tinkerbell live—she deserves better, babe.

And there you have it, bestie—a literary rollercoaster that left us spinning, confused, and slightly concerned for Peter Peter's mental health. From whimsical beginnings to gothic heartbreak and a final descent into Bluebeard-level madness, this story really said, "Why stick to one vibe when you can have them all?" While the ambition is admirable, the execution feels like it got lost in Neverland and never quite found its way back. But hey, every chaotic tale has its charm, and this one definitely keeps us entertained, even if it’s for all the wrong reasons. Here’s hoping Peter Peter finds a good therapist and maybe some beard oil.
  

.　 . • ☆ . ° .• °:. *₊ ° . ☆

Review Time Girll!!!

Your poem is a beautifully imaginative piece with vivid imagery and a unique blend of whimsy and tragedy. The transition from Neverland’s magic to Peter’s downfall is creative, though a bit rushed. With smoother pacing and more clarity in the narrative, it could shine even brighter.

Rating: 3.5/5 - Great concept and emotion!
It's just that I don't read much poetry so hope you understand!

.　 . • ☆ . ° .• °:. *₊ ° . ☆

Ps. Your creativity shines through in this poem, and it’s clear you’ve poured a lot of heart into it. The blend of fantasy and dark themes is captivating, and the imagery paints a vivid, haunting picture.  Keep writing, bestie—you’ve got something special here!

P

lease check out her poem it's really good!

Please don't take this seriously as this is meant for fun!!!