Aka how the cast would look in 2019

CAST
Grace Phipps as
Pepper Mallory

Shawn Mendes as
Griffin Mallory

Abby Cowan as
Rory Quinn

Nick Robinson as
Kai Wakefield

Brandon Soo Hoo as
Asa Henwick

Bonus! CHB 1996 cast (this'll make sense in the story I promise)

CAST

Isabella Fuhrman as
Young! Laurel Mallory

Isabella Moner as
Young! Mel Mercer

Jenna Ortega as
Thea Mercer

Griffin Gluck as
Thatcher Grayson