-

I was on the wiki and was talking with my friends earlier, and I think I know who Physic is. Also, a lot of people think Physic is Cryah of Joie, so here is my eveidence.

-

I think Cadence is Physic. Remember when she was attacked at the Blackswan sent someone to heal her? Wasn't it weird that they sent Elwin instead of Physic? Strange... Also, Mr.Forkle mentions that she didn't know Sophie that long, but Physic says Sophie does know her. Cadence fits that since 'technically' she only mentored Sophie for a few months because the five went to join Blackswan.

Some people think its Cyrah. I don't think it's her, because even though Wylie would be happy, I don't think a mother would have the heart to watch her son grow up without her. Also, elves break from guilt, so it would be too difficult.

Also, I know some people think it's Jolie. It would be awesome to know shes alive, but I don't think she could stay in hiding that long. Also, she knew her parents were going through a hard time, which any child probably wouldn't be able to stand by, especialy since eleves can break from guilt.

Sorry if I'm bashing your theories, this is just my thoughts. Also, what are Physic's abilities? I don't remember if she shows Cadence's powers of a Conjurer. Also, if Cadence was studying in Ravagog for a while, how long did it say she was there? If she resigned from the Collective eleven years ago or something, she may have fit into the time frame of disappearance. It would also make sense to have a spy, checking on the Ogres, that's in the Black Swan.

-

These were some thoughts I had while looking at past books, please comment your thoughts!

-