A/N: this is something that I've been looking around for a bit after the recent SMG4 Video. Near the end of it, where they find claw marks in meggy's apartment, some of them put the blame on Axol. This however would lead into half of the group accusing Axol of doing it while others thought he was innocent and leading in them turning on each other.

However, I personally don't think Axol had kidnapped Meggy. And here are my reasons on it.

While Yes, Boopkins does discover the Naruto DVD in her apartment. However, then we get to things such as the claw marks and something about Axol that people seem to miss.

Axol is an Axolotl. An Amphibian. Amphibians do not posses claws. Compare Axol's fingers to those of an actual Axolotl.

They seem to resemble more of simple fingers than claws.

Some could also argue that he kidnapped her for inkling ink so that he could continue to have enough stuff to make his characters to come to life fully. However, why exactly he went after Meggy SPECIFICALLY if he wanted more inkling ink when he could have gone after another one?

And before anyone says that it was because Meggy shot him with Ink when he was younger seen in the flashback in Mario Saves Anime, there's no evidence to prove that Meggy was the one who shot at him. There are multiple inklings who posses the same color sometimes. So, it was likely some random orange inkling.

And my last bit of evidence for why I don't think it's axol is because it would be too simple. One of the things that Luke likes to do is make the culprits in his videos more ominous. 

Such as back in the Waluigi Arc. The first time either Mario Saw or Mario and the T-Pose Virus came out, did anyone have the suggestion that it was waluigi until the very end of each videos revealed that he was responsible for those?

Next thing would be how he keeps the culprit hidden in terms of appearance. The shape of the shadow in the end of the current video. It doesn't resemble all that much like Axol's at all. Yes, I'm away it was given that shape to give mystery to it. But, there have been videos where the shadows of the culprit are a little more revealed to give some few guesses.

So with all this, I really don't think it can be axol who did it. But, the question would truly be on who.

I personally think that this is all being done by a pre-existing character in smg4. Or, an all new character all together who either:

 A. has a personally Agenda against Meggy. 

B. Wants to Frame Axol. 

Or C. Both.

But, that's all the evidence I can think of. But, I'm positive future will come along to possibly disprove, or further prove my points. We'll only need to wait and see. This video is placed under the Anime Arc with the other videos so.....