XXLeafPoolXX asked....

Do you like Thistleclaw or Scourge better?

In my opinion, Thistleclaw was the source of all evil. (Almost)

My Hypothesis:

Thistleclaw= Trained in Dark Forest willingly-->

Thistleclaw: Trained Tigerstar and taught him to kill

--> Tigerstar was too ambitious--> Killed Redtail Runningwind, Graypool and Brindleface, brought dogs--> Death of Swiftpaw and Bluestar

--> Tigerstar attacked Tiny--> BloodClan

Scourge's Story is just a poor kit misunderstood.

My Hypothesis:  Tiny met Tigerstar--> Got attacked by him--> Seeked revenge--> Created BloodClan--> Killed Tigerstar and wanted Clan territory

So, to answer your question.....

Scourge! <3