Boris: Oh! Over here, then! *He leads the group into a room, with six small circular tables, and pure black shapes above each one* We need a gear, a record, a Bendy plush, a book, a wrench, and a jar of Ink... 

Anon: Welp, looks like Honeyfrost's gonna have to give up the plush.

Sans: Uh... Can't you Anon's just make another one?

Anon: Nope. Well, we can, but we only have a certain amount of magic, I mean, It comes back after a minute or two, but still, we don't want to waste it on a plushie... So, Honeyfrost's gonna have to give it up. Unless you know someone else who has a Bendy plushie.