Sugguested by JonJon_Kirkland

You had know Rhys and Lewis for a while now. You met them at the same time when Ryan of the channel 8-Bit Ryan invited you to a game to make teams even. Thing is, you love both of them. You can choose who you love more. Ryan tries to help you come to one person or the other but nothing seems to work. Rhys is a wild coocy(can't spell, hang in there.) type that you find handsome but Lewis is a shy funny person you find more adorable than anything.

Today was no different but Ryan had already left to go make his video of the day. You already made your video for the day before he came over. Ryan usual comes over two or three times a week to help you with the decision. But something different happened today, about an hour after Ryan left there was a knock on your door. You got up to answer only to find the two guys you mentally debate about who you love more.

"Hey (Y/n)! How are you doing?" Lewis asked, seeming as if he was trying to block Rhys who was behind him. "I'm doing alright... How are you two doing?" You asked, overall confused about what was happening in front of you. "I'm doing good!" Rhys said finally managing to get in front of Lewis. "He's doing good as well." Rhys said leaning towards you. You nod. "Did you guys want to come in?" You asked again. "Actually, yeah!" Lewis said nodding.

You opened the door all the way and both of the boys came in and sat on the couch. You closed the door and grabbed your phone, messaging Ryan with "They are both at my house, help!" Which got a reply after about five minutes saying, "Try not to tell them anything, this might help you make a decision!" You shook your head, replying with a "Ok." And you walked to the living room. "So why did you two want to come over?" You asked the two males glaring at each other.

Rhys looked over at you. "Well..." He got up and walked over. "I wanted to see the person who I thought was the most beautiful person in the world.~" He said in a flirty tone, causing you to blush slightly. Lewis walked over and gently tugging you away from Rhys. "I-I wanted to play video games with my best friend, which I ad-admit is very pretty." Lewis said in his usual nervous tone. You looked at him and smiled slightly. "Thank you both for the compliments. So what game did you have in mind Lewis?" You looked at Lewis.

The three of you soon decided on a game and you went to go get it. While you were gone both of the males glared at each other and Lewis smirked, knowing in your book, he was a point closer to getting to be your boyfriend. Rhys thought a bit before getting an idea, quickly going to find you, Lewis followed quietly. After a few minutes Rhys walked over to you, who was still searching for the game. "Oh, hey Rhys. Did you-" You started to speak only to be cut off by being kissed, making you blush darkly.

Lewis walked over just as Rhys pulled away, leaving you dazed and confused. He just kissed you, but you didn't know what to think. Just as you were getting out of your dazed state, you felt your body get pulling into one of the two's chests. You look up and see Lewis looking down at you lovely before kissing you. Now you were back to being dazed. After a few moments he pulled away just like Rhys did and they both look at you.

After a few minutes you look back at the two. "That's the real reason you both came over isn't it." You asked to which you received a nod from both of the males. "You have to choose (Y/n). Who do you love more?" Lewis asked.

Lewis Ending

"I choose.... Lewis. I'm sorry Rhys." You said and Rhys nodded. "Well I'll leave you to it." He said before leaving. Lewis looked down at you lovely and you looked back up at him, smiling brightly. "I love you Lewis." You said hugging him, nuzzling your head into his chest. Lewis smiled as well, kissing the top of your head causing you to blush. "I love you too (N/n) (Nickname)." He said picking you up and taking you back to the living room so you both could watch a movie together.

Rhys Ending

"I pick Rhys. I'm so sorry Lewis." You said looking at Lewis. Lewis sighed and nodded. "Alright, it's fine. I'll talk to you two later." He said and waved before leaving. Rhys pulled you into his chest, causing you to blush a bit before nuzzling your head into his chest. "I love you (N/n)." Rhys said before kissing your forehead and picking you up bridal style. You blushed slightly and nuzzled close to his body. "I love you too Rhys." You said as you were carried back to the living room so you guys could cuddle.  

Can't Pick Ending

"I...... I'm sorry, I can't pick either of you. I've loved you both for so long and I can't pick one person or the other person." You explained, backing up a bit. Rhys and Lewis looked at each other a moment before nodding. Rhys walked over and picked you up. "Lewis grab a movie. If you can't choose (N/n), we're gonna share you until you can pick." Rhys explained, walking back to the living room with Lewis following.

Lewis Ending Two

"I'm so sorry, I can't pick between either of you at the moment. Can I get a day to think?" You asked. Lewis and Rhys looked at each other before nodding. "Yeah, we'll come back tomorrow to see if you have a choice." Lewis said and dragged Rhys out of the house. On the two boys way home Lewis dragged Rhys into the woods behind his house. He let his dark side, Darko, take over and kill him.

He burned the body, bloody bat, and the bloody clothes. The next day Lewis was the only one that came and he simply said that he didn't know where Rhys was. After a few hours of you and Lewis talking you went ahead and picked him which he knew you would if Rhys didn't come the following day. For the rest of the day you both cuddled, he made you guys dinner and once you fell asleep he mumbled to himself about how happy he was to be your boyfriend.