You woke up earlier than the rest of the shimejis. Perfect. You glanced at them then seeing as none of them stirred, quickly rushed to the bathroom to wash. After your shower and combing your hair, you went into your wardrobe and picked out the red shirt you've been anxious to wear.

It had "Happy Birthday Papyrus" in Papyrus font and a picture of spaghetti. He's gonna love this. You smiled at the thought of his face lighting up and quickly ran into the bathroom after grabbing some bottoms. After dressing, you re-entered your room, humming thoughtfully. You woke all of the shimejis, except for Papyrus of course.

Thankfully they all knew the occasion and happily obliged to waking up, even Sans. You quickly placed them all in your arms. After closing the door, you made your way down to the kitchen. "What shall we do for him, Y/N?" Asgore whispered. You stopped in your tracks half way down and thought. "I actually don't know." You admitted sheepishly. "Let's hear some ideas. Rational ideas in 3, 2, 1."

"hmm, spaghetti hotdogs?"
"A spaghetti volcano."
"Spaghetti tea?" Asgore said quietly. "Spaghetti a-anime?"
"Spaghetti me~"

They all gave each other menacing looks as no two people agreed on the same idea. "Well my idea is much cooler than you guys." Undyne said while flexing. "yeah, but Y/N said rational ideas, fish face." "FISH FACE?!" Undyne squirmed while trying to reach Sans, though he was in the other arm. "ya heard me, fish face." "LET ME AT EM!!!"

Alphys and Asgore watched the commotion quietly and Mettaton looked indifferent. Toriel was deep in thought so you didn't disturb her. It was a good thing your parents were out of town, or they would have heard the big fuss. "Alright, alright calm down. They were all excellent ideas and I appreciate the input from everyone." "Hmph." Undyne looked at Sans and crossed her arms. Sans simply shrugged and winked back.

You made your way into the kitchen and put them all on the counter. You then rested your chin in your hand and thought about some better ideas. "I've got it!!" Toriel announced gleefully. "W-What is it, T-Toriel?" "Spaghetti pie!" "Hmm. That actually doesn't sound that bad." Mettaton said with an expression that meant he was imagining what it'd look like. "That might be our best bet. Plus it sounds like a fun idea!" "I guess that will be alright." Undyne sighed. Once again, Sans just shrugged.

"Guess that's settled. What do we need, Tori?" "I don't know, my child. I've never made it before." "That's ok, I'll just search it up on Google." "Google?" They all said, looking quite confused. You giggled and told them not to worry about it. After finding a simple recipe, you called out the ingredients for them to get.

"Alright, get some spaghetti from last nights dinner and a pie." Toriel got the already made pie, and Alphys retrieved the left over spaghetti. You stuffed it into the pie and voila: a spaghetti pie. Guess I really didn't need Google. You chuckled at the creation and warmed the pie up in the microwave. After taking it out, you placed it on the table and wrapped it with foil. "now all we have to do is wait."

"HELLO? WHERE DID EVERYONE GO! HAS THE GREAT PAPYRUS BEEN DITCHED?" You laughed and quickly ran upstairs after cueing everyone to hide, dimming the kitchen lights as you passed through. Papyrus noticed your shirt and just as you imagined, beamed and gushed. "DID, DID YOU MAKE THAT SHIRT ALL FOR ME?" You nodded and picked him up. "Wowie.." He said softly, a tone you've never heard before.

"WHERE IS EVERYONE ELSE?" He inquired at his usual volume. "Hmmm, I dunno Papy. Let's go find out, ok?" He nodded and you descended down the stairs while trying to contain your excitement. Halfway into the kitchen, the lights turned on. "SURPRISE! HAPPY BIRTHDAY PAPYRUS!" Everyone shouted with huge smiles on their faces. Papyrus looked stunned and sat there quietly, a single sniffle escaped from him.

"what's wrong, bro? you don't like it? we tried to make it bone-tastic." He shook his head, groaning at the awful pun as everyone hung their heads. You all really tried to make the best party for him. "W-What about the p-pie we made..?" "A spaghetti pie." Mettaton added. Papyrus shook his head and you felt hurt.

"I LOVE IT!"

Papyrus practically screamed and the huge smile returned to everyone's face. You placed him on the table and allowed him to examine the pie.

"HMM VERY GOOD. VERY GOOD INDEED. ALMOST AS GREAT AS ME!" You scooped up the tiny monsters into a huge hug. "We all love you Papyrus." You stated and looked at him as the shimejis agreed. He blushed and was lost for words. "That's the best birthday gift I could have ever gotten." He said in his rare soft voice. Tears streamed down his face and he snuggled deeper into the hug. "Finally! Let's dig in." Undyne said, patting her stomach.

You placed them down and served the first piece to Papyrus. Everyone watched his expression carefully as he took a bite. He looked around with a poker face before smiling again and wiping his face from any remaining tears.

"Thanks, you guys. I love you all too."