Book: Dear Journal 

Author: @VeraChendra

Title: 3/5

The title fits the story well since it's about writing a journal. However, it's not very unique, as many books on Wattpad have similar titles. A more creative or original title might help your book stand out.

Cover: 3/5

The cover doesn't grab attention as much as it could. It's simple, but it might not make readers want to click on it. You could make it more eye-catching by adding design elements that represent a journal, like a handwritten font or a textured background. If you don't want to change the whole cover, small adjustments like changing the font color or adding borders could help.

Blurb: 5/10

The blurb is good, but it's too short. It doesn't give enough detail about the story. You could add more information, like a few lines from the journal entries, to make it more interesting and give readers a better idea of what to expect.

Plot: 19/20

From what I've read so far, the plot is interesting, though not super unique at first. What makes it stand out is that the story focuses on the male protagonist, which is a nice change since many books focus on female characters. This makes the story feel fresh and keeps readers wanting to know more.

Characters: 10/20

The characters are introduced well, but they need more depth. Alexander's actions are sometimes confusing. For example, why does he kiss his ex? What happened between them? Adding more backstory or explaining his actions will make the characters feel more realistic.

Grammar: 18/20

The writing is generally good, but there are a few small grammar mistakes. For example, in the sentence: "Carla, my ever-persistent and loyal colleague, pulled me aside last week and told me that if I don't produce anything worthwhile, I'll be fired as creative director of Haus of Lyon." It would be better to say: "Carla, my ever-persistent and loyal colleague, pulled me aside last week and told me that if I didn't produce anything worthwhile, I'd be fired as creative director of Haus of Lyon."

Also, there are too many metaphors and philosophical sentences. Since the story is written in a journal format, it would work better to keep the writing simple and direct.

Writing Style: 10/20

The story would be stronger if it included the perspectives of other characters. Right now, we mainly see things from Alexander's point of view. It would be interesting to know what other characters think and how they affect Alexander. Also, showing more of Alexander's growth and vulnerability could make him feel more relatable.

Overall: 68/100

Suggestions for Improvement:

Grammar Suggestions: "Carla, my ever-persistent and loyal colleague, pulled me aside last week and told me that if I don't produce anything worthwhile, I'll be fired as creative director of Haus of Lyon."  Replace "if I don't produce" with "if I didn't produce" to maintain consistent past tense with "pulled me aside."

Try to use fewer metaphors. They can be effective, but too many make the writing feel heavy. Keep it simple to match the journal style.

Consider exploring Emily's character in more depth to avoid clichés.

Balance the protagonist's arrogance with moments of vulnerability or growth.

Comment down any emoji to let me know you've read the review >>>

Thanks for choosing my shop!